Mattresses Comparisons

If you’re in the market for a new mattress, it’s always a good idea to do some comparison shopping. But you don’t have to open a million tabs and build out a comprehensive spreadsheet because we’ve done all the research for you! 

Want to skip ahead? Click the links below for quick access!

How to Compare Mattresses Online

Comparing mattresses online isn’t quite the experience as comparison mattresses in a store. When you’re comparison shopping in a mattress store, you’re mainly checking price tags and hopping back and forth to compare the initial feel of the mattress. But when you’re doing comparison shopping online, you can compare many different factors across different brands to truly find the best mattress for you.

Here are several tips for factors to look out for when you’re comparing mattresses online: 

Mattress Type

The mattress type has a big impact on the feel of the mattress. Compare the materials in the mattresses you’re looking at including memory foam, latex, hybrid, innerspring coils, and any other materials to consider how the mattress will feel.

Mattress Firmness

You can also take a look at firmness ratings. Generally, mattress brands will provide a number on a scale from 1 to 10 (with 1 being the softest and 10 being the firmest). Here at Mattress Clarity, we also identify a firmness rating for each mattress.

Support for Various Sleeping Positions

We understand that there is no single sleep position. Some sleep on their sides while others sleep on their back, stomach, or a combo of all three! We will evaluate each mattress and rate how it performs for each type of sleeper.

Temperature Regulation

This is especially important to consider if you tend to sleep hot–you don’t want to end up with a mattress that traps your heat in the bed. Look out for cooling factors like gel beads, copper, coil layers, or other features that can help you sleep cool.

Motion Transfer

If you sleep with a partner or animal, you may want to consider how well each mattress isolates motion. This means, you won’t be disturbed by the movements from your sleeping partner(s). 

Durability

If you’re investing in a mattress, you want to make sure it lives up to the price you pay. Look out for talk about how durable the mattress is. Are there a lot of complaints about it quickly sagging? Is the mattress very thin and people sink through to the bottom? Here at Mattress Clarity, we’ll always talk about the durability of a mattress.

Price

You want to consider the price of each mattress to figure out which is the best value option or just the cheapest option if you need to find the most affordable option. Keep in mind that the larger size a mattress is and the more high-quality materials used in its construction, the more expensive it typically is. 

Return Policy and Warranty

The return policy is super important for online shoppers. If you end up with a mattress that doesn’t feel the way you expected or isn’t working out for you, you want to know that you’ll be able to return it for a refund within a reasonable amount of time. The same goes for the mattress warranty. It’s important to understand what you need to do so you don’t void your warranty.

We hope that with these factors in mind, you can best decide which mattress is right for your sleep needs!

Types of Mattresses

In a market flooding with hundreds of mattress options, it can be difficult categorizing them. Below are the five most common mattress types to select from!

Spring

Latex

Memory Foam

Hybrid

Natural

Mattress Comparisons Directory

Click on any brand to see how it compares to its competitors. Each of our mattress comparison guides provides a breakdown of each mattress side-by-side so you can choose which is a better fit for you. 

Looking for the Best Mattress for You?

Take our FREE Best Mattress Quiz to to receive tailored mattress recommendations!

Our Methodology

Our comparison reviews are made of up a combination of objective facts and our personal experience with each mattress or sleep product. We want to make sure you leave each review knowing what to expect – both from an objective standpoint and as if you’d just spoken with your friend about the new bed they got.

To help you get the best idea of what mattress will work for you, we have multiple reviewers with different sleep preferences and body types looking at the same mattress and share their unique experiences.

We also use a series of objective tests to show how these mattresses perform. All in all, you can get a well-rounded understanding of each mattress so you can make an informed choice.

In our reviews, you can expect to learn about the following with each mattress:

Construction Overview

We will go through each mattress layer by layer, explaining the material and thoughts behind the design. We will give you more information about mattress construction than you would ever want to know!

 

Support

By the end of every review, you’ll have a solid idea of how much support you can expect from the mattress. We will give our opinion based on the materials of the mattress and from our experience sleeping on the mattress.

Firmness

We provide two different perspectives on the firmness of the mattress in each of our reviews. Our reviewers have different body types. We give this two-person approached in order to give you the clearest idea of how firm a mattress will feel to you.

Feel

Reviews include a written and a visual sense of a mattresses’ overall feel. In addition to visuals, we give our subjective overview of the feel and tell you how it compares to other types of mattresses.

Bounce

Some people like bouncy mattresses, while others prefer to have very little bounce. We use a lacrosse ball to show you visually how bouncy the mattress is going to be.

motion transfer

Motion Transfer

If you sleep with a partner, it’s important to know how much you’ll feel their movement while you sleep. In our video reviews, we show off exactly how well the mattress isolates motion with a number of different tests.

Comfort

We will give you our subjective assessment about how comfortable each mattress really is. Our multiple review approach gives you a range of perspectives.

Pressure Relief

While we do provide our subjective opinion about the overall comfort of a mattress, we also have a way to give you a very objective visual of how well the mattress relieves pressure. In our videos, we lie down on a pressure map and you can see very clearly where you might feel pressure on the mattress.

Breathability

We will give you our assessment as to whether you will sleep hot on each mattress. This will be based on our assessment of the materials and our experience sleeping on the mattress.

Sleeping Positions Assessment

Is the mattress good for back sleeping? Side sleeping? Stomach sleeping? Is it good for combination sleepers? In our video and written reviews, we will tell you what level of pressure relief and support you can expect in the mattress in each sleeping position.

Value

We will let you know if we think the mattress is a value. Our experts assess how much you get for the price you pay. While this may appear subjective, we can tell a lot based on mattress construction and design. We will honestly let you know if you are getting a good deal on each mattress.

Customer Service

Some companies are good with customer service, while others are not quite as good. We share customer service experience and reputation with each review.

Our Latest Blogs

Want to dive into specific reviews of a mattress? Looking for honest feedback on the newest latex mattress release? Check out our latest blogs to get the most up-to-date reports on the hottest mattresses in the market! 

My Green Mattress - featured
Reviews
Elisa Regulski

My Green Mattress Review – The Most Eco-Friendly Mattress On The Market?

Many mattresses contain eco-friendly and hypoallergenic materials, but few actually manufacture latex-free mattresses. Enter: My Green Mattress. This company builds all of their bedding products in their certified organic factory, and they sell a wide range of earth-friendly mattresses. In our My Green Mattress review, we’ll look closely at two of their most popular models:

Read More »
Reviews
Tony Klespis

Birch Luxe Natural Mattress Review – Resting in the Lap of Luxury?

Are you wanting a more luxurious mattress that is also made of eco-friendly materials? If so, then the Birch Luxe Natural Mattress is the luxury mattress you’re looking for. Birch by Helix has taken luxury, safety, and comfort and combined them into this premium mattress. So, let’s dive into this Birch Luxe Natural Mattress review!

Read More »
Boll and Branch Sheets - featured
Sheets Reviews
Angela Myers

Boll and Branch Sheets Review — The Sheets for Presidents?

Looking for crisp, breathable sheets? The Boll and Branch Signature Hemmed sheets might fit the bill. These are some of the best cotton sheets on the market and a favorite of multiple US presidents. In our Boll and Branch sheets review, we’ll take a close look at their construction, feel, care instructions, and more. Are

Read More »
Reviews
Elisa Regulski

Polysleep Mattress Review – Is This Canadian Mattress For You?

It’s antimicrobial. It’s liquid resistant. And it has amazing edge support. That’s right, we’re talking about the Polysleep mattress. Canadians know and love this bed because it offers spectacular comfort and support, but Americans are quickly catching on as well. Ready to see whether it’s the bed-in-a-box for you? In our Polysleep mattress review, we’ll detail

Read More »
Zephyr Mattress - Featured Image
Reviews
Tony Klespis

Zephyr Mattress Review – Should You Get This Canadian Mattress?

Everyone knows how important a good mattress is for your best night of sleep. Anyone on the market for a mattress that helps them recharge overnight needs to know where to look. In this Zephyr Mattress review, we’ll discuss why and how the Zephyr is meant just for that. The Zephyr Mattress by Polysleep is

Read More »