Saatva Vs. Puffy – Which Is Right For You?

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site. See our disclosure page for details.

When it comes to the online mattress market, many beds on offer seem pretty similar. Not so with the Saatva and Puffy. The Saatva is an innerspring mattress with a pillow-top, while the Puffy is an all-foam mattress. And the differences don’t end there.

That’s good news, because it makes it easier to choose between these two beds. Read this in-depth Saatva Vs. Puffy mattress comparison, and by the end you’re all but guaranteed to know which option is right for you.

Saatva vs. Puffy

Innerpsring bounce or plush foam? Both of these beds offer superior comfort, but they're better suited for different types of sleepers.
Product
Firmness
Score
Saatva Mattress
Multiple firmness options
4.1/5
Puffy Mattress
Medium-firm: 7/10
3.9/5

Saatva vs. Puffy

Innerpsring bounce or plush foam? Both of these beds offer superior comfort, but they're better suited for different types of sleepers.
Product
Saatva Mattress
Firmness
Multiple firmness options
Score
4.1/5
Product
Puffy Mattress
Firmness
Medium-firm: 7/10
Score
3.9/5

Saatva Vs Puffy Mattress Overview

The Saatva Classic mattress is the flagship bed from the Saatva company, which produces a variety of high-quality mattresses that are sold online. Other Saatva mattresses include the Saatva Solaire, Saatva Latex Hybrid, and Saatva HD. The Saatva is an innerspring mattress with a pillow-top. It has a unique construction that includes two layers of coils. The Saatva comes in three firmness options (Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm) and two height options: 11.5” and 14.5”. We reviewed the 11.5” Luxury Firm model.

As a company, Puffy is fairly new to the scene of bed-in-a-box mattresses. It was founded in 2016, but it’s quickly grown its presence in the mattress space and already produces several popular beds. In addition to the Puffy mattress, the Puffy brand also sells the Puffy Lux and the Puffy Royal. The original Puffy mattress is an all-foam bed with a simple, three-layer construction. The materials in these layers are proprietary to Puffy; together, they create a balanced foam feel.

Who Should Get The Saatva?

  • People who enjoy a traditional innerspring feel
  • Back and combination sleepers
  • Heavier-weight sleepers, who require a more supportive mattress
  • People who are looking for an orthopedic mattress

Saatva Mattress

The Saatva is an organic mattress that is both comfortable and supportive. This mattress comes in multiple firmness options to fit a variety of sleepers.

Clarity Score 4.1/5
Read Saatva Mattress Review

Material

Innerspring

Trial Period

365 nights

Shipping Method

Free white glove delivery

Firmness

Multiple firmness options

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight, average weight, and heavyweight back sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight stomach sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
4.9/5
Watch Our Video Review

Saatva Mattress

The Saatva is an organic mattress that is both comfortable and supportive. This mattress comes in multiple firmness options to fit a variety of sleepers.

Clarity Score 4.1/5
Read Saatva Mattress Review

Material

Innerspring

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Firmness

Multiple firmness options

Shipping Method

Free white glove delivery

Trial Period

365 nights

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight, average weight, and heavyweight back sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight stomach sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
4.9/5
Watch Our Video Review

Saatva Mattress

The Saatva is an organic mattress that is both comfortable and supportive. This mattress comes in multiple firmness options to fit a variety of sleepers.

Clarity Score 4.1/5
Read Saatva Mattress Review

Material

Innerspring

Firmness

Multiple firmness options

Trial Period

365 nights

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Shipping Method

Free white glove delivery

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Hot Sleepers
If you often overheat while you sleep, this mattress should help you stay cool.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight, average weight, and heavyweight back sleepers.
Stomach Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight stomach sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
4.9/5
Watch Our Video Review

Who Should Get The Puffy?

  • People who prefer a balanced foam feel
  • Light- or medium-weight side sleepers
  • Back sleepers who want an all-foam mattress

Puffy Mattress

Puffy is a comfortable memory foam mattress that is especially great for back and side sleepers.

Clarity Score 3.9/5
Read Puffy Mattress Review

Material

Foam

Trial Period

101 nights

Shipping Method

Free shipping

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Kids
This bed is perfect for young sleepers.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight back sleepers.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight side sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
5.0/5

Puffy Mattress

Puffy is a comfortable memory foam mattress that is especially great for back and side sleepers.

Clarity Score 3.9/5
Read Puffy Mattress Review

Material

Foam

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Shipping Method

Free shipping

Trial Period

101 nights

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Kids
This bed is perfect for young sleepers.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight back sleepers.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight side sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
5.0/5

Puffy Mattress

Puffy is a comfortable memory foam mattress that is especially great for back and side sleepers.

Clarity Score 3.9/5
Read Puffy Mattress Review

Material

Foam

Firmness

Medium-firm: 7/10

Trial Period

101 nights

Warranty

Lifetime warranty

Shipping Method

Free shipping

Price Range

$$$$$

We recommend this mattress for the following sleeper types:

Kids
This bed is perfect for young sleepers.
Back Pain
This bed is perfect for anyone suffering from back pain.
Back Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight back sleepers.
Side Sleeping
Ideal for lightweight and average weight side sleepers.

Financing Options

Financing options are available for this mattress.

Average Customer Rating
5.0/5

Saatva Vs Puffy Mattress Video Comparison

Test out both of these mattresses vicariously by watching our in-depth video comparison! Our reviewer, Joe, reveals the construction on each of these beds and shares his experiences with sleeping in every position on the Saatva and Puffy.

 

Similarities Between The Saatva And Puffy?

For the most part, the Saatva and Puffy are very different mattresses. But they do have a few things in common.

  • These are both popular mattresses that are sold online.
  • Both beds are sold by companies with good customer service terms.
  • Both mattresses should offer back sleepers a nice blend of support and comfort.
  • Both beds use memory foam in their comfort layers.
  • The Luxury Firm model of the Saatva and the Puffy Original are around the same firmness.

See how the Saatva stacks up against other brands with our Saatva mattress comparisons.

Key Differences Between The Saatva And Puffy?

As we noted above, the Saatva and Puffy have many more differences than similarities. Here’s an overview.

  • The Saatva features an innerspring construction with coils, while the Puffy is all-foam.
  • True to their constructions, the Saatva has a traditional innerspring feel while the Puffy has a classic memory foam feel.
  • The Saatva is a more substantial mattress, and it’s thicker than the Puffy.
  • The Saatva sleeps cooler than the Puffy.
  • The Puffy costs a bit less than the Saatva.

Check out our Puffy mattress comparisons to see how this bed compares to other brands.

Firmness And Feel Differences

Whenever you’re hunting for a new mattress, two of the most important factors to consider are firmness and feel. So let’s take a close look at these qualities on the Saatva and Puffy!

How Firm Are The Saatva And Puffy Mattresses?

As noted above, the Saatva mattress comes in three firmnesses: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. We ranked the Luxury Firm around a 7/10 on the firmness scale. The industry standard for average firmness is 6.5/10, meaning we found the Luxury Firm model to be a bit firmer than average. The soft pillow-top is balanced out by the firmer coil layers underneath. While we aren’t focused on the Plush Soft model in this review, it’s worth noting that we ranked this as one of the best soft mattresses.

We also ranked the Puffy mattress around a 7/10, or a touch firmer than average. While the bed’s comfort layer is soft, it’s also very thin, so we felt the firmer transition and support layers underneath. Note that any bed’s firmness will vary a bit depending on your body weight and personal preferences.

Sleeping On The Saatva And Puffy Mattresses (Sleeping Positions)

We personally tested each of these mattresses in every sleeping position. Here’s how we felt on these beds.

Saatva

We enjoyed a great balance of spinal support and comfort while back sleeping on the Saatva. Our hips sank into the pillow-top a bit for some pressure relief, but not too far—so our spine stayed aligned. The dual coil layers offered plenty of spinal support, including great lumbar support. The microcoils also created some additional body contouring. All told, we found the Saatva to be a fantastic mattress for lower back pain and sciatica and well as one of the best mattresses for arthritis.

Saatva Mattress - Back Sleeping

While side sleeping on the Saatva, we enjoyed a decent amount of pressure relief around our shoulder and hip. That said, folks who spend all night in this position might prefer the softer Plush Soft model.

The Saatva offered decent support while stomach sleeping. Our hips stayed aligned with our spine, and we enjoyed good overall spinal support. Note that heavier-weight sleepers might need the Saatva Firm model or another more supportive bed.

Puffy

While back sleeping on the Puffy Original mattress, we enjoyed a pleasant balance of comfort and support. Our hips sank through the thin comfort layer, but the transition layer underneath ensured they didn’t bow too far into the mattress. Meanwhile, the comfort layer offers some nice body contouring.

Puffy Mattress - Side Sleeping

Our heavier-weight reviewer felt some pressure on the shoulder and hip while side sleeping on the Puffy. However, lighter-weight sleepers should get the pressure relief they need here since the thinner comfort layer should be sufficient.

In our experience, the Puffy is not supportive enough for stomach sleeping. Our hips dipped into the mattress and pulled the spine out of alignment, which created some pain in the lower back. People who prefer this position will definitely want a more supportive mattress for stomach sleepers.

What Do The Saatva And Puffy Mattresses Feel Like?

The Saatva has a classic innerspring feel with a pillow-top feel right on top. The pillow-top and the microcoils offer some body contouring, while the dual layers of coils create plenty of bounce and responsiveness. It’s easy to move around on this mattress, and sleepers won’t feel stuck.

Overall, the Puffy has a balanced foam feel. It has a layer of slow-moving memory foam on top, which is balanced out by firmer and more responsive foams underneath. It should be pretty easy to change positions on this bed.

Average-Weight Sleepers – 130lbs – 230lbs

The Saatva’s Luxury Firm model should be a great fit for most average-weight sleepers. It offers excellent spinal support to back sleepers, decent pressure relief for side sleepers, and a supportive feel for stomach sleepers. Note that side sleepers who prefer a softer feel will probably want the Plush Soft model.

The Puffy should offer a nice blend of comfort and support for average-weight back sleepers. Average-weight side sleepers will most likely experience too much pressure around the shoulder and hip. The Puffy will not be supportive enough for most average-weight stomach sleepers.

Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs

Heavyweight back sleepers who weigh closer to 230lbs should feel well-supported on Saatva’s Luxury Firm model. Folks who require more support should consider the Firm model or the Saatva HD, which is made specifically for heavy people. Heavyweight side sleepers should enjoy decent pressure relief on the Luxury Firm model. Most heavyweight stomach sleepers will probably require a more supportive mattress.

The Puffy should offer decent spinal support to heavyweight back sleepers who weigh close to 230lbs. Folks who weigh closer to 300lbs will probably require a mattress with coils. Most heavyweight side sleepers will experience too much pressure around the shoulder and hip. Meanwhile, the Puffy probably won’t be supportive enough for heavyweight stomach sleepers.

Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs

The Saatva’s Luxury Firm model could be a great fit for lightweight sleepers of all stripes. It offers plenty of support to back and stomach sleepers and should relieve pressure for side sleepers. That said, some side sleepers might prefer the softer Plush Soft model.

The Puffy should be a good fit for lightweight back and side sleepers, who should enjoy spinal support as well as body contouring. Lightweight stomach sleepers could get enough spinal support on the Puffy.

Mattress Construction Differences

Let’s dig beneath the surface of these mattresses to see what they’re really made of. Here’s a close look at each layer of the construction on the Puffy and the Saatva—plus how different materials impact feel and performance.

Cover

The Saatva’s cover is made from organic cotton, which makes a soft and breathable surface. The cover is tufted and quilted with soft foam to create a pillow-top look and feel.

The Puffy’s polyester cover is thin, soft, and breathable. Overall, it doesn’t really affect the bed’s performance and feel.

Comfort Layers

The primary comfort layer on the Saatva is the pillow-top that’s quilted into the bed’s cover. Below the pillow-top, there’s a thin layer of memory foam that offers some additional pressure relief.

Saatva Mattress - Construction

The Puffy’s first comfort layer is dubbed Cooling Cloud. It’s made of soft memory foam and has some of the slow-moving feel that’s usually associated with this material. This layer is also infused with a cooling gel to help dissipate heat. Below the Cooling Cloud layer, there’s a Climate Control layer that acts as a transition layer between the softer memory foam and the firmer support foam underneath. This layer is also designed to support cooling.

Puffy Mattress - Construction And Foam Layers

Support Layers

The Saatva features a unique construction in the form of a dual set of steel coils. First, there’s a layer of smaller microcoils that simultaneously offer support and body contouring. Underneath the microcoils, there’s a layer of thick, high-grade coils that offer excellent support.

The Puffy has a simpler support layer that consists of a high-density base foam. This material provides overall structure and support.

Mattress Height

The Saatva comes in two height options: 11.5” and 14.5”. The Puffy comes in one firmness option and stands 10” tall.

Saatva And Puffy Mattress Size Options And Price

Check out the charts below for the most up-to-date size and pricing information for both the Saatva and Puffy mattresses!

Saatva

Size Dimensions Price
Twin 38" x 75" $912.00
Twin XL 38" x 80" $1198.00
Full 54” x 75” $1670.00
Queen 60" x 80" $1770.00
King 76" x 80" $2170.00
California King 72" x 84" $2170.00
Split King 76" x 80" $2396.00
Split California King Two 38" x 80" pieces $2396.00

Puffy

Size Dimensions Price
Twin 39" x 75" $899.00
Twin XL 38" x 80" $949.00
Full 54” x 75” $1099.00
Queen 60" x 80" $1299.00
King 76" x 80" $1449.00
California King 72" x 84" $1449.00
CHECK PRICES
Saatva
  • Click the button for the best deal on Saatva. 
  • A firmer, more supportive mattress. 
  • A good fit for larger people as well as back and stomach sleepers.

Doesn't expire

SAVE $300
Puffy
  • Click the button below to save $300
  • A soft mattress with a classic memory foam feel. 
  • A good match for light- and medium-weight side sleepers.

Doesn't expire

Saatva And Puffy Performance Differences

We compared these two beds head-on in a range of tests to assess their temperature regulation, edge support, motion isolation, and more. Let’s see which mattress performed best in each category!

Sleeping Hot Or Cold

The Saatva is the more cooling mattress. Not only does it have a breathable cover, but its dual layers of coils create tons of room for air to circulate throughout the center of the mattress. This means sleepers shouldn’t overheat.

When it comes to cooling, it’s tough for all-foam beds to compete with innerspring mattresses. This holds true for the Puffy—it did trap some heat. That said, the cooling gel infusion in the top comfort layer and the breathable cover do help this bed sleep a bit cooler than some all-foam mattresses.

Motion Transfer

The Puffy wins this category. Its memory foam comfort layer does a great job of absorbing motion and minimizing disturbances across the surface of the mattress. In contrast, the Saatva does not do a good job of absorbing movement. Its bouncy and responsive coils allow disturbances to travel across the mattress.

Edge Support

The Saatva wins out. Its dual layers of coils create excellent edge support, and we felt very secure while sitting and lying down near the edge of this mattress.

Saatva Mattress - Edge Support

 

The Puffy features decent edge support; it collapsed a bit when we sat near the edge, but we felt fairly secure while lying near the edge of this bed. Still, the Saatva will offer much stronger edge support overall.

Puffy Mattress - Edge Support

Durability

The Saatva takes another win. The high-grade coils make this a long-lasting mattress that won’t sag for years to come. With proper care, the Saatva should last for at least 7-10 years.

Off-Gassing

The Saatva wins here. Unlike most online mattresses, the Saatva does not arrive rolled up in a cardboard box. Instead, the Saatva company offers free White Glove Delivery, meaning people will remove your old mattress and set up the new mattress in your bedroom. Because it doesn’t spend time rolled up in a box, the Saatva doesn’t off-gas upon arrival. The Puffy is a more conventional bed-in-a-box, and it will probably emit a slight chemical smell at first. This should dissipate after 48 hours.

Noise

The Puffy could win here, but only time will tell. During our review, we didn’t observe any significant noise from either of these beds. But because the Saatva contains a lot of coils, it’s possible they could squeak a bit over time. Because the Puffy is all-foam, it should stay noise-free over the long haul.

Sex

We called this a tie. Both mattresses are responsive, and it should be easy for sexual partners to move around and change positions on both the Saatva and the Puffy. That said, the bouncier Saatva could make things even easier.

RELATED: Best mattresses for sex

Company Policies

Here’s a quick look at the fine print that will come along with a purchase of either of these beds.

Warranty Info

The Saatva comes with a lifetime warranty. This is longer than the average warranty for many online mattresses.

The Puffy mattress comes with a lifetime warranty, which is longer than the warranty for many all-foam beds.

Sleep Trial

The Saatva comes with a 365-day sleep trial. Like this bed’s warranty, its sleep trial is a bit longer than average. You’ll have nearly half a year to make up your mind about this bed.

The Puffy mattress comes with a 101-night sleep trial that lets you test out the bed risk-free in your own home.

Return Policy

Not satisfied with the Saatva? You can initiate a return during the 365-day sleep trial. The company will refund or exchange the mattress for a $99 transportation fee that covers the cost of labor and gas involved in picking up the mattress.

If you decide the Puffy mattress isn’t right for you, simply initiate a return at any point during the sleep trial. The Puffy company will schedule a return pick-up and provide a full refund. The company donates returned beds to charity.

Saatva Vs Puffy Mattress FAQs

If you still have questions about one or both of these beds, the answers to these commonly asked questions might help.

Which mattress is better, Saatva or Puffy?

The Saatva and Puffy are both popular mattresses with a lot to offer, but they’re better suited to different types of sleepers. The Saatva is a great match for back and combination sleepers, fans of innerspring beds, and people who need a supportive bed. The Puffy could be a solid choice for fans of a balanced foam feel, back sleepers, and lightweight side sleepers.

How long will the Saatva and Puffy mattresses last?

The Saatva is a durable innerspring mattress that should last for at least seven to 10 years. The all-foam Puffy probably won’t be as long-lasting; it should last for around five to seven years.

Can you flip the Saatva or Puffy mattress?

No, you cannot flip the Saatva or Puffy mattress. This would cause you to sleep on the firm support layer instead of the dynamic comfort layers.

Gravatar for Joe Auer

Joe Auer

Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.

He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 250 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 5 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.

Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.