If you spend much time looking for a mattress, you probably come across a large amount of memory foam and all-foam mattresses. However, what if this isn’t the feel you are looking for?
Many of us grew up sleeping on traditional innerspring mattresses and love the support and durability that they offer. Still, there are so many to choose from. Which will you choose?
To help you find the right innerspring mattresses, I have put together a list of my favorite seven innerspring mattresses. These are high-quality, supportive mattresses that really stand out among the rest.
Which innerspring mattress is right for you? Read on for my full innerspring mattress buying guide.
Good For Multiple Positions
The Saatva has a great balance of comfort and support and should be a good match for all three sleeping positions.
The WinkBeds is a very comfortable yet supportive mattress with four firmness options to choose from.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature is a comfortable and supportive mattress sold for a value price.
The Avocado features all-natural latex and supportive coils. It is a good option for those who want to avoid chemicals in their mattress.
With Helix, the company will customize a mattress to meet your specific sleeping preferences.
New Purple Mattress
The New Purple mattress features a hyper-elastic gel polymer and supportive coils. It is very durable and should be a good, long-term investment.
The DreamCloud is a luxury innerspring mattress that could be a great option for back sleepers, side sleepers, and heavier sleepers.
Top Picks Explained
Take a look at my top picks for innerspring mattresses. There is no right mattress for everyone but, if you read closely, you should be able to find the innerspring mattress that meets your specific needs.
Good For Multiple Positions
The Saatva mattress is a very comfortable and supportive innerspring mattress. It features dual layers of coils as well as a plush, Euro-style pillow top.
The coils offer a good amount of support while the pillow top provides some very nice pressure relief. Because of this construction, the Saatva is a great match for all three sleeping positions. You should feel nice support on your back and stomach and good pressure relief when you are on your side.
The coil-on-coil construction also allows for a good amount of airflow. This makes the Saatva a breathable mattress that shouldn’t make you overheat at night.
Finally, the Saatva is a great value. It is very durable and very affordable when you consider the quality materials used in its construction.
What Makes The Saatva Stand Out?
- The mix of coils and soft pillow top make this a good fit for all three sleeping positions.
- It is a durable mattress that is also a very good value.
- The Saatva is very breathable and should be a good match for hot sleepers.
Read the full Saatva mattress review
The WinkBeds, like the Saatva, features coil-on-coil construction and a soft pillow top. It too offers a great balance of comfort and support and could be a good fit for all three sleeping positions.
What sets the WinkBeds apart is the options available. You can choose from four mattresses depending on what firmness you are really looking for. Do you sleep on your side and need some extra comfort? The WinkBeds Soft will be great for you. Are you a larger person and need more support? Check out the WinkBeds Plus.
In addition, the WinkBeds mattresses are, in my experience, the most comfortable mattresses on this list. That plush pillow top is comfortable and very pressure relieving, especially on the Soft model.
If you are looking for options and want to find that perfect balance of comfort and support, the WinkBeds mattresses should be a great choice.
What Makes The WinkBeds Stand Out?
- The WinkBeds mattresses offer a great balance of comfort and support.
- The company offers four mattress models so you can find the mattress to meet your specific needs.
- The two layers of coils make this a very durable mattress. It should be longer-lasting and a good long-term investment.
- The coils promote airflow throughout the mattress. This keeps the mattress from trapping too much heat so it should work for hotter sleepers.
Read the full WinkBeds mattress review
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
The Brooklyn Bedding Signature contains pocketed coils and proprietary TitanFlex Foam. TitanFlex is similar to latex and gives the top of the mattress a bouncy feel. It is very responsive and easy to move around.
The TitanFlex is also infused with TitaniumGel. This is meant to keep the mattress from trapping heat and to ensure you sleep cool at night. The pocketed coils also allow for air to flow throughout the mattress. Altogether, you shouldn’t be sleeping hot on the Signature.
In addition, the Signature is a medium-firm mattress with a nice balance of comfort and support. Back sleepers, side sleepers, and combination sleepers should find the support and comfort they need.
This is also the most affordable mattress on this list. Brooklyn Bedding owns their own factory so they are able to pass the savings along to the customer.
If you want a comfortable, supportive mattress for a value price, take a look at the Brooklyn Bedding Signature.
What Makes The Signature Stand Out?
- The mattress features durable, high-quality materials. This means the Signature should be a good long-term investment.
- The TitaniumGel and airflow-promoting coils should make this a cooler-sleeping mattress.
- The Signature offers a good balance of comfort and support. It should be a good match for back, side, and combination sleepers.
- The mattress has some nice bounce so you should be able to move around easily.
Read the full Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress review
The Avocado is an organic mattress with all-natural Dunlop latex and pocketed coils. It is free of harmful chemicals and should be a great option for those who want a green mattress.
This latex mattress is both supportive and comfortable. You can also opt to add a pillow top to your mattress if you need even more comfort. It should help relieve pressure, especially when you are on your side.
In addition, the latex and coils make this a breathable mattress. Latex is naturally cooling and the mattress’ Dunlop latex layers are also ventilated. At the same time, the coils allow for a great amount of airflow. With these features combined, you shouldn’t be sleeping hot.
Dunlop latex is also a bouncy and durable material. It may cost a bit more up front, but it should last for a good amount of time.
If you a mattress that is comfortable, supportive, and free of harmful chemicals, the Avocado should be right for you.
What Makes The Avocado Stand Out?
- It contains all-natural Dunlop latex. It is organic and doesn’t contain harmful chemicals.
- The latex and coils make this a breathable, cooler-sleeping mattress.
- The Avocado comes with an optional pillow top which provides more pressure relief.
- Latex is a very durable material so this should be a solid long-term investment.
Read the full Avocado mattress review
The Helix mattress is unique in that the company customizes a mattress to meet your needs. You complete a survey and, based on those answer, Helix puts together a mattress just for you.
If you are more of a side sleeper, Helix will send you a softer, more comfortable mattress. If you are a back or stomach sleeper, Helix will put send you something more supportive. They even take your sleeping temperature into account.
In addition, if you are a larger person, the Helix Nightfall is made specifically for you. It is extra supportive and should be able to handle heavier weights.
If you just aren’t sure what type of mattress you want, Helix should be a great choice. No matter your sleeping preferences, Helix should be able to accommodate you.
What Makes The Helix Stand Out?
- After you take a sleep quiz, Helix customizes a mattress to meet your needs.
- Should be a good match for pretty much any type of sleeper.
- The coils allow for airflow and the company will also include more features for hot sleepers.
Read the full Helix mattress review
New Purple Mattress
The New Purple mattresses contain individually-wrapped coils along with a proprietary, hyper-elastic gel polymer. This forms a gel grid which is both firm and pressure relieving at the same time.
If you want coils in your mattress, you can choose from three models: Purple 2, Purple 3, and Purple 4. These mattresses contain varying amounts of the gel grid. The Purple 2 has 2″, the Purple 3 has 3″, and the Purple 4 has 4″.
This allows you to choose the right New Purple Mattress to meet your needs. The Purple 2 will be the firmest and should be a better fit for stomach sleepers. The Purple 3 is right in the middle and could be a good pick for back sleepers. The Purple 4 is the softest and should work for side sleepers.
The gel grid is also a very breathable material. There is tons of room of airflow so the mattress is completely temperature-neutral. If you worry about sleeping hot, the New Purple mattresses should be a great option.
Finally, the New Purple mattresses are the most durable options on this list. The gel grid shouldn’t sag so it should last for a good amount of time. If you are looking for a long-term investment, the New Purple could be right for you.
What Makes The New Purple Stand Out?
- It adds coils to the already popular Purple mattress.
- The gel grid is pressure relieving and supportive at the same time.
- You can choose from three models, allowing you to find the right firmness for you.
- The gel grid promotes airflow throughout the mattress so you shouldn’t overheat.
- The New Purple mattresses are the most durable options on this list.
Read the full New Purple mattress review
The DreamCloud is a luxury innerspring mattress with a pillow top and pocketed coils. The top is tufted and woven with cashmere so it gives you that luxury hotel experience.
The mattress offers a balance of comfort and support and should be a great match for back and side sleepers. Back sleeping, the pillow top allows your hips to sink in the right amount while the coils support you. Side sleeping, the pillow top relieves pressure on the shoulders and hips.
The DreamCloud is also a good match for hot sleepers. The cover is very breathable and there is even gel-infused memory foam in the top layers. You shouldn’t be sleeping hot on the DreamCloud.
In addition, the DreamCloud should work for heavier people. The mattress is 15″ tall and the top comfort layer is very thick. Larger people shouldn’t have issues with bottoming out, but should also feel the proper amount of support.
What Makes The DreamCloud Stand Out?
- It has a luxury feel that gives you that hotel mattress experience.
- It should be a great match for back and side sleepers.
- It is a breathable mattress that should work for hot sleepers.
- The DreamCloud should be a good match for heavier people.
Read the full DreamCloud mattress review
Best for Back Pain
If you have back pain, you’re going to really want to focus on great support. All of these options can address the issue, and it might depend most on your sleeping position – but personally, I would head for Saatva if I was having lower or mid back pain.
Best for Stomach Sleepers
If you are a stomach sleeper, you should go with a firmer mattress to get the right feel and support. Of these options, Saatva and Aviya offer firm options. You may consider some of the firmer Simmons Beautyrest options as well..
Best for Side Sleepers
If you are a side sleeper, you are going to want a slightly softer mattress to deal well with the pressure points on your hips and shoulders. I would start with WinkBeds, as I think that has a really nice feel when laying on one’s side.
Marten is a staff writer for us. He has a much different body type than me: He is 6’7″ and weighs about 230 lb; I am 5’9″ and 160 lb. Here is what he thought about these mattresses:
The great thing about innerspring mattresses is that they are usually a good fit for heavier people like myself.
While all seven of these worked for me in different positions, there are four that really stand out for heavier people.
First off, we have the DreamCloud. This is a fantastic mattress with a luxury feel. When I am on my back, my hips sink in just the right amount and the mattress supports me overall. On my side, I also feel nice pressure relief.
The New Purple, namely the Purple 4 is a great option for heavier side sleepers. I press into those 4” of gel material and feel almost no pressure on my shoulders and hips. Even being a larger person, I feel great side sleeping on the Purple 4.
Then, you have the WinkBeds Plus. This is made specifically for heavier people. It is very supportive when I am on my back and stomach. The Helix Nightfall is also made for heavier people. The Nightfall features high-grade coils and high-density foams so it is a very supportive mattress.
While all seven could be a good match for heavier people, I would look at these 4 mattresses in particular.
If you are a larger person, an innerspring mattress is always worth considering. Coils can offer the support that your heavier weight requires. Definitely keep your sleeping position in mind as well. If you are a larger side sleeper, for instance, you need something with a thicker comfort layer.
Benefits Of An Innerspring Mattress
- More Breathable. One of the great things about innerspring mattresses is that they allow for air to flow through the mattress. All-foam mattresses don’t have that space for airflow. If you are a hot sleeper, an innerspring mattress could be worth considering.
- More Supportive. Coils also offer more support than what you might find in an all-foam mattress. Their design allows them to handle more weight than base foams. If you are a larger person or simply need some extra support, an innerspring mattress should be a good option.
- More Durable. Coils also add a level of durability to your mattress. They shouldn’t sag the way that some foams are known to do. They should also offer support for a good amount of time. While you might spend some more money up front, an innerspring mattress could be a good, long-term investment.
Drawbacks Of An Innerspring Mattress
- More expensive. Coils are a pricier material than many base foams. While they are more durable and more supportive, you will probably have to pay more.
- Less motion isolation. If you sleep with a partner, you want to know whether their movements will disturb you on your side of the bed. Memory foam and other foams are often much better at isolating motion in a mattress. When you add coils, it could cut increase motion transfer. Because of this, innerspring mattresses aren’t always the best choice for couples.
What Should You Look For When Buying An Innerspring Mattress?
If you are looking for an innerspring mattress, how can you gauge the quality? Here are a few things you should consider when you are shopping for an innerspring mattress.
Coil Count and Gauge
If you are in a store or on a website, you will see a lot of talk about how an innerspring mattress has a certain number of coils, a certain gauge (thickness of the steel wire), etc.
- Coil count refers to the number of coils used in the mattress. Depending on the new size of the mattress, you can have as few as 200 or as many as 2000.
- Coil gauge is a measure of how thick the metal wires are in a given mattress. The lower the number, the thicker the wire.
These types of stats have the potential to be pretty misleading for a couple of reasons. For example, many people think more coil equals a better quality mattress.
However, you can have a higher coil count but the coils are made of lower quality steel. There are many different factors that go into the quality of the innerspring unit. I would, therefore, recommend being a little cautious when using this rationale.
An innerspring mattress can be made more or less firm in a number of different ways, and a lot of it depends on what is in the top layer. Therefore, saying a blanket statement like “thicker gauge means firmer mattress” isn’t always true, because it depends on a few other factors too.
You will also probably hear a lot about the type of coil being used in a mattress’s construction. There are differences between the types.
- Pocketed coils. Pocketed coils are individually wrapped and tend to be better overall at contouring to your body. They are usually more expensive.
- Open coils. This is the most affordable and oldest innerspring design. There are numerous coils held together by a wire frame.
- Offset coils. These feature an hourglass shape and offer better contouring than open coils.
- Continuous coils. One metal wire runs throughout the mattress to create rows of coils.
However, the type of coil matters more or less depending on the rest of the components of the mattress, so I would take statements like “it has pocket coils, so it’s better” with a grain of salt.
If you have a thick layer of memory foam on top of the mattress, the fact that the innerspring unit has pocket coils doesn’t really matter as much, because the memory foam does the contouring. Overall, the type of coil does matter, but its importance is dependent on the rest of the mattress.
Not all innerspring mattresses are made equal. There is a wide range of materials that can be used to add comfort to the springs, and that makes the feel of the mattress quite different. For example, an innerspring with a thin layer of latex on top will feel much different from one with a very thick layer of memory foam.
As a result, you need to understand the differences between the different types of comfort layers. Know the difference between polyfoam, memory foam, and latex foam, and decide which feel you like better.
Also, understand that the thickness of the comfort layer matters a lot too. If the mattress has a thick layer of memory foam, then it is more of a hybrid and will feel more like a memory foam mattress, which tends to be quite a different feel from the traditional feel associated with innerspring mattresses.
An innerspring mattress is always a good option if you want more support or durability. While there are so many quality innerspring mattresses, these seven are the best that I have tried. Just consider your size and sleeping positions and it should be easy to choose which of these mattresses is best for you.
Featured image: ImYOUR/Shutterstock
Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.
He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 250 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 5 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.
Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.
Latest posts by Joe Auer (see all)
- 5 Best Firm Mattresses 2019 - June 13, 2019
- Lucid Memory Foam Hybrid Mattress Review – A Great Value? - June 3, 2019
- Linenspa Memory Foam Hybrid Mattress Review – Affordable Comfort? - May 30, 2019