Mattress Reviews - Top Choices Revealed, Avoid Scams

Mattress Reviews and Buying Guide 2017

I’ve been reviewing mattresses online for a few years now and have personally slept on over 70 mattresses.  However for ever mattress I review, it seems like 5 new brands emerge, making everything more confusing.


Everyone has their own needs and preferences (and I of course have my own), but I try to be objective as I review each mattress personally, highlighting what I like and don’t like.  I also break down my reviews into categories (see the table of contents for my top picks by category).

Note: I receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where I am compensated for items purchased through links from our site (at no cost to the buyer). See our disclosure page for our list of comped products and affiliate programs.

Below is a list of some of my favorite mattresses, as well as some of my favorite mattresses by certain categories.  If you have a question about a brand not listed here, please reach out and I will add it to the list!

Overall Top Mattress Picks

MATTRESS RATING ANALYSIS LINK
1

Amerisleep

95.6
Read review
Comfort
98
Support
97
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
95
Amerisleep
2

Loom and Leaf

95.4
Read review
Comfort
96
Support
97
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
96
Loom and Leaf
3

Helix Sleep

95
Read review
Comfort
95
Support
94
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
93
Company
95
Helix Sleep
4

GhostBed

94.8
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
95
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
95
GhostBed
5

Layla

94.6
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
92
Value
97
Doesn't Sleep Hot
94
Company
93
Layla
6

Saatva

94.4
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
95
Value
95
Doesn't Sleep Hot
96
Company
93
Saatva
7

Lull

94.4
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
95
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
93
Company
91
Lull
8

WinkBeds

94.2
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
96
Value
91
Doesn't Sleep Hot
96
Company
94
WinkBeds
9

Casper

94
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
93
Value
93
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
95
Casper
10

Love & Sleep Nest Bedding

94
Read review
Comfort
95
Support
91
Value
97
Doesn't Sleep Hot
93
Company
94
Love & Sleep
11

Sapira Mattress

93.8
Read review
Comfort
90
Value
96
Support
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
95
Company
90
Sapira
12

Nolah

93.8
Read review
Comfort
96
Support
92
Value
94
Doesn't Sleep Hot
95
Company
92
Nolah
13

Novosbed

93.8
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
95
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
94
Novosbed
14

Tuck Mattress

93.6
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
95
Value
95
Doesn't Sleep Hot
95
Company
90
Tuck
15

Intellibed

93.6
Read review
Comfort
92
Value
91
Support
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
97
Company
90
Intellibed
16

Brooklyn Bedding

93.6
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
94
Value
97
Doesn't Sleep Hot
94
Company
90
Brooklyn Bedding
17

Purple mattress

93.4
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
92
Value
94
Doesn't Sleep Hot
98
Company
90
Purple
18

PlushBeds

93.4
Read review
Comfort
90
Support
92
Value
94
Doesn't Sleep Hot
94
Company
97
PlushBeds
19

The Alexander

93
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
94
Value
93
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
94
The Alexander
20

Alexander Hybrid

93
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
94
Value
95
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
94
Alexander Hybrid
21

Herobed

92.8
Read review
Comfort
95
Support
90
Value
90
Doesn't Sleep Hot
95
Company
94
Herobed
22

Zenhaven

92.8
Read review
Comfort
90
Support
92
Value
94
Doesn't Sleep Hot
96
Company
92
Zenhaven
23

Spindle

92.6
Read review
Comfort
90
Support
93
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
90
Spindle
24

Aviya

92.6
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
94
Value
95
Doesn't Sleep Hot
97
Company
85
Aviya
25

Tuft and Needle

91.6
Read review
Comfort
85
Support
92
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
97
Tuft and Needle
26

Addable

91.6
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
88
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
92
Addable
27

Bear Mattress

91.4
Read review
Comfort
91
Support
94
Value
92
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
92
Bear Mattress
28

Cocoon By Sealy

91.2
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
90
Value
92
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
94
Cocoon
29

eLuxurySupply

91.2
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
88
Value
95
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
90
eLuxurySupply
30

Aloha Sleep Mattress

91.2
Read review
Comfort
89
Support
93
Value
93
Doesn't Sleep Hot
91
Company
90
Buy Now!
31

Leesa

91
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
93
Value
92
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
90
Leesa
32

NECTAR Mattress

91
Read review
Comfort
90
Support
92
Value
91
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
92
Buy Now!
33

Hyphen

90.8
Read review
Comfort
90
Support
92
Value
92
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
90
Hyphen
34

EzoBed

90.8
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
89
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
85
Company
94
EzoBed
35

Dromma Bed

90.6
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
88
Value
90
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
90
Dromma Bed
36

Eve Mattress

89.4
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
90
Value
90
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
91
Eve
37

Endy

89
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
90
Value
93
Doesn't Sleep Hot
85
Company
85
Endy
38

Brentwood Home

89
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
89
Value
94
Doesn't Sleep Hot
82
Company
92
Brentwood Home
39

ReST Bed

88.2
Read review
Comfort
90
Support
88
Value
85
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
88
ReST Bed
40

Zinus

88
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
85
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
81
Company
88
Zinus
41

iKrema

87.6
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
88
Value
88
Doesn't Sleep Hot
86
Company
84
iKrema
42

Tempur-Pedic

87.6
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
98
Value
72
Doesn't Sleep Hot
86
Company
85
Tempur-Pedic
43

Eight Sleep

86.2
Read review
Comfort
85
Support
88
Value
85
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
85
Eight Sleep
44

Luxi

86
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
83
Value
91
Doesn't Sleep Hot
85
Company
83
Luxi
45

Sonno Bed

84.8
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
85
Value
85
Doesn't Sleep Hot
83
Company
83
Sonno Bed
46

Ameena

84
Read review
Comfort
85
Support
88
Value
83
Doesn't Sleep Hot
80
Company
84
Ameena
47

MyCloud

83.6
Read review
Comfort
89
Support
80
Value
85
Doesn't Sleep Hot
80
Company
84
MyCloud
48

Wright

83.2
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
85
Value
75
Doesn't Sleep Hot
83
Company
85
Wright Bedding
49

Yogabed

81.6
Read review
Comfort
85
Support
83
Value
85
Doesn't Sleep Hot
81
Company
74
Yogabed
50

Simmons Beautyrest

79
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
90
Value
58
Doesn't Sleep Hot
87
Company
68
Simmons Beautyrest
51

Organica

70
Read review
Comfort
75
Support
65
Value
65
Doesn't Sleep Hot
70
Company
75
Organica

Memory Foam Mattresses

Many people start by looking at memory foam because they are familiar with Tempur-pedic.  I think they make some great mattresses, but there are lots of other companies that offer great memory foam mattresses at a much better value.  See my memory foam mattress reviews for my top picks.

MATTRESS RATING ANALYSIS LINK
1

Amerisleep

95.6
Read review
Comfort
98
Support
97
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
95
Amerisleep
2

Loom and Leaf

95.4
Read review
Comfort
96
Support
97
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
96
Loom and Leaf
3

Layla

94.6
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
92
Value
97
Doesn't Sleep Hot
94
Company
93
Layla
4

Lull

94.4
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
95
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
93
Company
91
Lull
5

Novosbed

93.8
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
95
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
94
Novosbed
6

Bear Mattress

91.4
Read review
Comfort
91
Support
94
Value
92
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
92
Bear Mattress
7

Cocoon By Sealy

91.2
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
90
Value
92
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
94
Cocoon
8

Brentwood Home

89
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
89
Value
94
Doesn't Sleep Hot
82
Company
92
Brentwood Home
9

Wright

83.2
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
85
Value
75
Doesn't Sleep Hot
83
Company
85
Wright Bedding
10

Yogabed

81.6
Read review
Comfort
85
Support
83
Value
85
Doesn't Sleep Hot
81
Company
74
Yogabed

Innerspring Mattresses

There are fewer innerspring mattress companies that impress me, but the ones that do offer great products.  Read my innerspring mattress reviews to see what I look for in an innerspring mattress.

MATTRESS RATING ANALYSIS LINK
1

Saatva

94.4
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
95
Value
95
Doesn't Sleep Hot
96
Company
93
Saatva
2

WinkBeds

94.2
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
96
Value
91
Doesn't Sleep Hot
96
Company
94
WinkBeds
3

Aviya

92.6
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
94
Value
95
Doesn't Sleep Hot
97
Company
85
Aviya

Hybrid Mattresses

Hybrid in the mattress industry basically means not just one material – this could mean latex and memory foam, or even spring and foam in one mattress.  When done right, these mattresses can offer the best of different materials.

MATTRESS RATING ANALYSIS LINK
1

Helix Sleep

95
Read review
Comfort
95
Support
94
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
93
Company
95
Helix Sleep
2

GhostBed

94.8
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
95
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
95
GhostBed
3

Lull

94.4
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
95
Value
96
Doesn't Sleep Hot
93
Company
91
Lull
4

WinkBeds

94.2
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
96
Value
91
Doesn't Sleep Hot
96
Company
94
WinkBeds
5

Casper

94
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
93
Value
93
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
95
Casper
6

Tuck Mattress

93.6
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
95
Value
95
Doesn't Sleep Hot
95
Company
90
Tuck
7

The Alexander

93
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
94
Value
93
Doesn't Sleep Hot
90
Company
94
The Alexander
8

Herobed

92.8
Read review
Comfort
95
Support
90
Value
90
Doesn't Sleep Hot
95
Company
94
Herobed
9

Leesa

91
Read review
Comfort
92
Support
93
Value
92
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
90
Leesa
10

Eve Mattress

89.4
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
90
Value
90
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
91
Eve
11

Ameena

84
Read review
Comfort
85
Support
88
Value
83
Doesn't Sleep Hot
80
Company
84
Ameena

Latex Mattresses

Latex is less known than memory foam, but in my opinion has an opportunity to be the best sleeping surface.  In addition, it can actually be all natural (though many companies choose to use synthetic latex).  See my latex mattress reviews page for my top picks in this category.

MATTRESS RATING ANALYSIS LINK
1

GhostBed

94.8
Read review
Comfort
94
Support
95
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
95
GhostBed
2

Casper

94
Read review
Comfort
97
Support
93
Value
93
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
95
Casper
3

Brooklyn Bedding

93.6
Read review
Comfort
93
Support
94
Value
97
Doesn't Sleep Hot
94
Company
90
Brooklyn Bedding
4

PlushBeds

93.4
Read review
Comfort
90
Support
92
Value
94
Doesn't Sleep Hot
94
Company
97
PlushBeds
5

Spindle

92.6
Read review
Comfort
90
Support
93
Value
98
Doesn't Sleep Hot
92
Company
90
Spindle
6

Eve Mattress

89.4
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
90
Value
90
Doesn't Sleep Hot
88
Company
91
Eve
7

Luxi

86
Read review
Comfort
88
Support
83
Value
91
Doesn't Sleep Hot
85
Company
83
Luxi
8

Ameena

84
Read review
Comfort
85
Support
88
Value
83
Doesn't Sleep Hot
80
Company
84
Ameena

My Mattress Rating Experience

Mattress Reviews and Ratings

I test out every mattress personally for at least one week so that I can have a useful personal experience to share.  Note that my opinion isn’t the ultimate authority – everyone has their own preference, and I’ll do my best to communicate my experience in an unbiased way.  Take my reviews with a grain of salt, because something I might hate might be exactly what you’re looking for!

Review Methodology

Generally I look for how each mattress satisfies the following criteria:

  • Quality construction and materials (especially for newer mattress brands that haven’t been around along enough to evaluate over a long time period)
  • Comfort
  • Support and spinal alignment
  • Sleeping hot (especially for memory foam and proprietary foam mattresses)
  • Return policy/Warranty
  • Eco-friendliness
  • Customer support and company reputation
  • Value/Price

I would like all of the content on Mattress Clarity to be up for discussion, so let me know if you have any questions about specific brands, my review process, or purchasing a mattress in general.

This post was last updated on January 26th, 2017 at 11:36 am