Brooklyn Bedding Propel Mattress Review – Great For Side Sleepers?

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

Recently, Brooklyn Bedding has been expanding its line of mattresses. The company has unveiled the Titan, made just for larger people, and the Plank, an extremely firm, flippable mattress.

Now we have the Propel, a very comfortable mattress designed for athletes. TitanCool keeps the mattress cool while Upcycle technology increases blood flow, helping with recovery.

After reviewing the many other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses, I have been impressed by their high-quality components and value pricing. So I was excited to see how the Propel compares to the other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses.

This review will cover everything consumers should know about this mattress, including a full breakdown of the construction, the pros and cons, firmness and feel, comfort, support, motion isolation, edge support, breathability, durability, and much more.

25% Off

The Propel mattress comes from Brooklyn Bedding. It is a very comfortable mattress that should be a good fit for side sleepers and athletes. Click the button and use code MLK25 to save 25% on your purchase.

Who Might Want To Pick The Propel…

  • Those who prefer a softer mattress- I believe most people will agree that the Propel is softer than average. Whether people just like the feel of a soft mattress or have some extra comfort needs, the Propel should be a good choice. Check out the best soft mattresses instead.
  • Side sleepers- The Propel features some fantastic pressure relief, and with its thick comfort layer, people shouldn’t be feeling much pressure on their shoulders and hips. In fact, the comfort layer is so thick, even heavier side sleepers should feel great pressure relief.
  • Back sleepers who likes to sink in- The mattress also features a decent balance of comfort and support. If someone is a back sleeper and doesn’t mind sinking into the mattress, the Propel should work for them. People should feel good overall support while their hips are allowed to sink in.
  • Athletes- The Propel is a great mattress for athletes because it contains Upcycle technology, which is designed to assist with muscle recovery. If someone is an athlete and needs a mattress to help them recover after a hard workout, the Propel is definitely a good option.
  • Hot sleepers- There is a Phase Change Material called TitanCool in the top layer of the Propel that helps with temperature regulation. So if people often sleep hot, the TitanCool should keep them from overheating too much.
  • People who are looking for a good value- Brooklyn Bedding is a unique mattress company, because they own their own factory and are able to price their mattresses as low as possible. While the Propel features some high-quality materials, it is still priced very affordably. For another great value, take a look at the Dreamfoam Chill from Brooklyn Bedding.

A man points to the different layers of a mattress.

Who Might Not Want To Pick The Propel…

  • Those who prefer a firmer mattress- Whether people are looking for a medium-firm or firm mattress, the Propel might not be the best choice. It is definitely softer than average and will not be a good fit for those who want something on the firmer side. People may want to check out the best firm mattresses instead.
  • Stomach sleepers- Softer mattresses are usually not a good match for stomach sleeping. When people are on their stomach, they will want to make sure their mattress is giving them enough support on their hips. The Propel is softer and might not give people that needed support.
  • Back sleepers who don’t want to sink in- While the Propel could be a good match for some back sleepers, others might think the mattress is too soft. People do sink into the mattress quite a bit, so if they like a back sleeping mattress that keeps them more aloft, they should look elsewhere.
  • People who prefer to sleep on top of their mattress- While sleeping on the Propel, sleepers should sink in quite a bit. If people like to sleep on top of their mattress, they might want to look for something without such a soft, thick comfort layer.

A man lays his hand on top of a mattress.

Construction Overview

  • The mattress is 11.5” tall and features a complex construction with coil and foam layers.
  • The cover is soft and contains Upcycle technology, which can potentially bring certain health benefits.
  • The first layer is 1.5” of CopperFlex foam, which is a very responsive foam that has great pressure relief.
  • Then there are 2” of Energex foam, which provides pressure relief and bounce.
  • Below that, there is a 1” layer of swirl gel memory foam, which gives the mattress extra body contouring.
  • The support layer contains 6” of individually-encased Ascension coils, which are highly supportive, durable, and breathable.
  • The coils rest on 1” of high-density foam, and the mattress is made in the USA.

A man lies on his back on a hybrid mattress.

Construction Takeaways

  • The cover’s Upcycle technology is designed to help athletes recover after working out. The Upcycle absorbs body heat, transforms it into infrared energy, and directs it back at you. This has been shown to increase blood flow, which could help your muscles recover.
  • The top layer also contains a Phase Change Material called TitanCool. Phase Change Materials are meant to assist with temperature regulation. If you are sleeping hot, the TitanCool will cool you down. If you are sleeping cool, it will actually warm you up.
  • The CopperFlex layer has a combination of memory foam and latex qualities. It is soft and pressure-relieving but also responsive. The Energex foam beneath that is similarly soft yet responsive. You should sink into these top layers, but you also shouldn’t be getting stuck.
  • Altogether, you have 4.5” of comfort material. A thick comfort layer like this usually means the mattress is going to be a good fit for side sleepers. You should sink into the mattress and feel almost no pressure on your shoulders and hips.
  • The combination of coils and thick comfort layer should make this a good mattress for larger people. Sometimes larger people, especially those who sleep on their side, can press through thinner comfort layers and bottom out. Because the comfort layer on the Propel is 4.5”, larger people should not be bottoming out. In addition, the coils should provide enough support, even for heavier weights.
  • Brooklyn Bedding offers many other mattress models. Read our Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress review.
25% Off

The Propel mattress comes from Brooklyn Bedding. It is a very comfortable mattress that should be a good fit for side sleepers and athletes. Click the button and use code MLK25 to save 25% on your purchase.

How This Compares To Other Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses

If you are taking a look at the Propel mattress, you might want to know how it compares to the other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses.

First off, there are some similarities between the Propel and the rest of the Brooklyn Bedding mattresses. Like the other mattresses, the Propel is a very good value. Brooklyn Bedding owns and runs its own factory, so they are able to cut out the middle man. This allows them to use premium materials and sell their mattresses for an affordable price.

RELATED: Best Mattress For The Money

Second, like the other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses, the Propel sleeps cool. All of the Brooklyn Bedding mattresses address the issue of sleeping hot in some way. The Propel features TitanCool in its top layer. This is a Phase Change Material that will cool you down if your body temperature rises too much.

So, why would you want to buy the Propel instead of one of the other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses, and what sets it apart?

If you are a side sleeper, the Propel relieves pressure better than most of these other mattresses. As I said above, it has a 4.5″ comfort layer that really allows you to sink in. I have tried all of the available Brooklyn Bedding mattresses and I felt the best pressure relief on the Propel.

In addition, the Propel is a great mattress for athletes. Unlike the rest of the Brooklyn Bedding mattresses, the Propel features Upcycle technology. This will help improve blood flow and should shorten recovery time for athletes. Whether you are a professional athlete or just want to recover after a workout, the Propel is a great option.

Firmness And Feel

In terms of firmness, I thought the Propel felt close to a 6/10, a little bit softer than average. There is a soft, thick comfort layer and then you get down to some supportive coils. Together, this gives the mattress a softer-than-average firmness.

Here is how it felt in different sleeping positions:

  • Back sleeping on the Propel, I do sink in quite a bit, but I still feel the necessary amount of support. The coils beneath the comfort layer are providing that overall support. The foams in the comfort layer are conforming to the shape of my body and adding some nice contouring as well.
  • When I move to my side, I really feel those foam layers go to work. Again, I sink in pretty far, but I do not hit the firm support layers. The comfort layer is relieving almost all the pressure on my shoulders and hips, so side sleepers of many sizes should like the Propel.
  • Moving to my stomach, the Propel is a bit too soft for me, as I am not getting enough support on my hips, and I do feel like I am sinking too far into the mattress. Stomach sleepers are going to want to look for a firmer, more supportive mattress.

The Propel has a balanced foam feel that still allows you to sink in. So the mattress is soft but responsive at the same time. You will get that soft foam feel, but you shouldn’t have any trouble moving around.

Motion Transfer

If you share your bed with someone, it is very important to think about how your mattress deals with motion transfer. When you or your partner move around at night, will you disturb each other or not?

To test how well the Propel isolates motion, I first placed a glass of water on top of the mattress. I then pressed into the other areas of the mattress in an effort to mimic the movements you or your partner might make. I saw very little disturbance in the glass of water.

Also, I laid on the mattress and asked Marten to move around on the opposite side. He got in, switched positions a few times, and then got out. I did not feel many of these movements.

Looking at the results of these two tests, I can say that the Propel isolates motion quite well. It should be a good mattress for couples who don’t want to be disturbed by their partner’s movements.

Edge Support

Those who sleep with a partner should also think about the edge support of their mattress. When you sit or lie down near the edge of the mattress, will you feel like the mattress is holding you up? Or will it feel more like you are falling off?

While sitting down near the edge of the Propel, it compresses quite a bit. This is not surprising given how soft the top layers are. Still, I don’t feel like I am going to pitch forward. When I lie down near the edge, I also feel secure. I don’t feel like the edge is giving way or letting me roll off the mattress.

People can see the good edge support in the photo below.

A man sits near the edge of a mattress.

Marten’s Take

It is important to consider your weight when you’re looking at a mattress. Since I am 5’9″ and 160 lb, I thought it was important to get a different perspective. I asked Marten, who is 6’7″ and 230 lb, to talk about his experience on the Propel mattress. Here is what he had to say about the mattress and how appropriate it is for heavier sleepers:

In terms of firmness, Joe said this was a 6/10, and I actually agree. Often on softer mattresses, I will press through the comfort layer and hit the support layers beneath. Since the comfort layer is so thick on the Propel, I am not bottoming out.

Here is how it felt in different sleeping positions:

  • When I am on my back, I feel some good overall support, as my hips sink in but not too far. It is a decent match for back sleeping.
  • Moving to my side, I feel fantastic pressure relief. I press into the comfort layer without bottoming out and feel almost no pressure on my shoulders and hips.
  • However, when I sleep on my stomach, the mattress is too soft for me, as I bow in at the hips and feel like I am not in neutral spinal alignment.

If someone is a heavier back sleeper, this could be a decent option. If someone is a heavier side sleeper, the Propel is definitely a good option. If someone is a heavier stomach sleeper, they should look elsewhere.

Marten’s experience is pretty much what I expected. The Propel has a comfort layer thick enough to prevent him from bottoming out. Because of this, he too felt nice pressure relief when he was side sleeping. Also, as a heavier person, he felt even less support when he was on his stomach.

Unboxing The Propel Mattress

Like most online mattresses, the Propel will be shipped straight to your door. It will come in a cardboard box.

First, take the box to your bedroom. You will probably need a friend’s help, as this isn’t the lightest mattress.

Remove the rolled-up mattress from the box and position it on your bed. You can then start cutting through the few layers of plastic. Do this carefully so that you do not damage the mattress.

Once you’ve cut through the last layer of plastic, the mattress can be laid down flat. You can then cut away the last layers of plastic. Clear away all the packing materials and give your mattress some time to off-gas and expand!

What Makes The Propel Stand Out?

  • It is a softer mattress that should offer great pressure relief for side sleepers.
  • The Propel should keep people from sleeping hot throughout the night.
  • It should help athletes recover more quickly.
  • Like all of Brooklyn Bedding’s mattresses, it is a good value and a great long-term investment.

Overall Rating

Propel Mattress
3.9 Overall
Edge Support
Motion Transfer
Trial Period

The Propel is an extremely comfortable mattress that should be a good fit for side sleepers of all sizes. Hot sleepers, athletes, and those who want a good deal should also take a look at the Propel.

The mattress comes with a 120-night sleep trial, 10-year warranty, and free shipping and returns, and financing is available. There are also many other Brooklyn Bedding mattresses and accessories to choose from.  Consumers should take a look through this article multiple times, assess their own needs and preferences, and then make a more informed decision.

The following two tabs change content below.
Gravatar for Joe Auer

Joe Auer

Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.

He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 250 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 5 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.

Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.

Gravatar for Joe Auer

Latest posts by Joe Auer (see all)