Best Reviewed Mattress for Under $2000

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site. See our disclosure page for details.

If you’re looking for a mattress under $2000, you have the opportunity to get one of the best mattresses available.  With the new online-only business model for mattresses, the middle men are cut out of the sales process, passing on a lot of savings to the consumer.  This allows you to get a mattress that historically would cost $4,000-5,000 in a retail store.

Most of the online mattress companies are targeting low-mid tier customers (~$800), though a few are targeting the luxury market.  What’s great about the business model is that you can have all of the bells and whistles in the mattress and still not exceed $2000 (even for a queen or king size).

If you were shopping at a retail store and looking at a Tempurpedic or Beautyrest, you would only be able to get one of the lower-end models for under 2000 dollars.

My Top 3 Mattresses Under $2000

All of these recommended mattresses are very high quality, but even a high quality mattress is not a one-option-fits-all product.  I’ve broken down the options to four categories to help with the selection: memory foam, spring, and natural.

These mattresses also rank top amongst my mattress reviews overall.

Top Under $2k Mattresses Compared

Loom and Leaf

Loom and Leaf ReviewThough Loom & Leaf tops the memory foam option for less than $2k, it is actually significantly less (priced at $1,699 for a King), though shipping is not include in the price (most online-only companies include shipping).

This memory foam mattress is the closest that you’ll come to Tempurpedic, but at a fraction of the cost.  They have multiple firmness options, and have used gel-infused foam so that the mattress does not sleep hot.  Loom and Leaf also ranks amongst top memory foam and side sleeper picks.

You’ll also have the feeling of sleeping “in” the mattress, not “on” the mattress, and will have the slow response foam experience that memory foam lovers adore.  Learn more about my experience with this mattress in my Loom & Leaf review.

WinkBeds

WinkBeds Mattress ReviewWinkBeds is a smaller brand, but spent their marketing dollars building the best innerspring mattress possible.  There are two layers of coils and 2 inches of high density memory foam on top.

Though technically a hybrid, WinkBeds feels more like an innerspring mattress.  The extra layer of foam on top makes it a good option for side sleepers.

The company also has a great reputation and very personable customer support.  To learn more about this mattress visit my WinkBeds review.

PlushBeds

PlushBeds Botanical Bliss ReviewPlushBeds Botanical Bliss is personally one of my favorite options, a high quality latex mattress that is actually 100% natural.

They import the latex themselves from Sri Lanka, and ensure every part of the mattress high quality and organic.  Learn about their process in my PlushBeds review.

Latex is also a great sleeping option because it has the comfort/support tradeoff similar to memory foam, but has more “spring”.  This makes it better for sex and easier to move around when sleeping.

Note of Caution

When purchasing a mattress, there are a number of bells and whistles that you can definitely spend money on, but (in my opinion) won’t improve your sleep experience whatsoever.

Yes, you can pay an extra $1k for diamond infused gel foam, but this isn’t going to sleep noticeably cooler than other gel options.

The options I chose above of course aren’t the most expensive mattresses available, but I do think that they have all the features that are worth paying for.  That is, I don’t have any mattresses that I strongly recommend that are priced higher than $2000.  See our best mattresses overall article and all mattress reviews too.

The mattresses are, in my opinion, some of the best for the money, but also the best available.  Let me know if you have any questions on these brands or others listed on the site!

The following two tabs change content below.
Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site. He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 100 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 4 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications. When he isn't testing sleep products, he enjoys working out, reading both fiction and non-fiction, and playing classical piano. He enjoys traveling as well, and not just to test out hotel mattresses! Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.

34 thoughts on “Best Reviewed Mattress for Under $2000

  1. Hey Joe,
    Would appreciate your opinions on the Bentwood Home Sequoia and the Palmetto mattresses and which might be the better? Saw your impressive review of the Sequoia but didn’t hear anything on whether or not the Sequoia tends to “bottom out” with its top layer of gel infused (bamboo infused?) memory foam and the 2″ of latex as opposed to the Palmetto with its 2 x 2″ layers of latex. Is the Palmetto a better buy for those who aren’t crazy bout memory foam? Thanks.

  2. Me and my GF are in the market for a new mattress. We want to replace a 2-1/2 year old Southland spring plush mattress with a high quality alternative. I appreciate your comments about coil based mattresses, implying they are best for sex. Hey, I’m a guy and that’s important.

    We’re also looking at a firmer mattress, which she prefers and durability is important so there won’t be any intentions left in the mattress after a night’s sleep, which is the case. I’m 6′, 235 lbs, yet the Southland mattress leaves an indention and is no longer comfortable. I’m considering several options.

    Consumer reports has given the Charsles P Rogers PowwrCore Elite 5000 mattress their highest rating. The powerCore Nano 2 has a double layer of coils, but was not rated. Can you compare these two mattresses.

    Money is an object, but if it wasn’t, what is the best option for side and back sleepers, who want a responsive mattress for sex, but one that allows for a comfortable sleep after, with a 10 year durability, without altering its level of support over time.

    Thanks,

    Greg in Texas

    • Did Joe ever respond to your post? I would love to see what he said. You asked a great question and the response and information would be helpful to me, too! Good luck!

  3. When the New York Times checked on the return policies for a bunch of these mail-order mattress, they found that some gave the mattress to a local charity/homeless shelter and several others paid a ‘got-junk’ type of company to take it to the dump.
    None returned the mattress to the ‘factory’ for recycling, re-use or whatever.

    Makes you wonder what the mattress really cost to make (very little).

  4. We got a PlushBed Matress 2 months ago, the Botanical Bliss in a 12″. It is already showing “sinking” impressions where we sleep! We don’t know what to think! Will this mattress hold up over time?

  5. Hi Joe! I like the Flagship Mattress that Saatva sells, found out it won’t work on an adjustable base. They recommended Zenhaven and we prefer inner spring over foam, what do you suggest?

      • Hi Joe, I just ordered the Loom and Leaf Queen Relaxed Firm mattress a few days ago, due to yours and a few other reviews I have read. Is this the bed that Patti is referring to that will NOT work on an adjustable base? Or is she talking about their inner spring mattress? I was going to order an adjustable base because when I was ordering mine from their site, the chat person said it would work with one. I hope this is true. Do you know if it will work?

      • Hi Paula – to the best of my knowledge, Loom & Leaf will be fine on an adjustable base, but I would check with the company itself to confirm if you have doubts.

  6. SO an option for no memory foam due to OVERHEATING would be to go with organic latex? Also what about an innerspring with what type of blend, latex , cotton, gel? HELP!!

    • Hi Marsha! Older memory foam mattresses generally sleep a lot hotter than current memory foam mattresses (across brands) due to construction changes (infused gel, copper infusion, better air flow, etc). BUT generally memory foam will sleep hotter than other materials, even with the changes. For me they sleep cool enough, but if you are very sensitive to sleeping hot, I’d look at other materials (at least for the comfort layer).

Leave a Comment