Nolah Vs Casper- Which Should You Choose?

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site (at no cost to the buyer). See our disclosure page for our list of comped products and affiliate programs.

Nolah and Casper are both popular online sellers of foam mattresses. Casper, probably the best known online mattress seller, offers three mattress options but its namesake flagship is still its most popular. Nolah is a lesser known but still popular brand with only one mattress design. To help you decide which one is best for you, I’m going to break down the key similarities and differences.

Key Similarities

  • Both are all-foam mattresses.
  • Both are 10 inches thick.
  • Both offer cooling solutions.
  • Both use a proprietary foam for comfort.
  • Similar price range. ($550-$1,150 for Casper, $549-$1,069 for Nolah)
  • Both offer free shipping.

Click Here To Get The Highest Discount Available On Nolah

Key Differences

  • Nolah is softer.
  • Nolah has 3 layers, while Casper has 4.
  • Nolah has a thicker support layer.
  • Casper has a transition layer between its two top comfort layers and its base layer.
  • Casper has a layer of memory foam.
  • Nolah offers a longer trial period of 120 days, compared to Casper’s 100 days.

Click Here To Get The Highest Discount Available On Casper

Nolah Construction

The picture below shows how the Nolah mattress is constructed. Here’s a breakdown:

  • The cover is a thin, very soft and breathable viscose.
  • The top layer is 2 inches of a proprietary “AirFoam.”  This foam is said to relieve pressure better than memory foam while also ensuring you sleep cool.
  • Below the AirFoam is is 1 inch of latex-like Avena foam, which is highly durable and provides some bounce.
  • The base support layer is 7 inches of 1.8 lb. density poly foam.  This is a pretty typical base layer for foam mattresses.

Read Our Full Nolah Review

Casper Construction

  • A lightweight premium fabric makes for a stretchy, breathable cover.
  • The top layer is 1.5 inches of a latex-like specialty polyfoam the company. This material has small holes for breathability — Casper describes the material as “open-cell” — and has good bounce.
  • The next layer is 1.5 inches of 3.5 lb. density memory foam, which helps the mattress conform well to the curves of your body. This layer provides good pressure relief.
  • The third layer is a “transition layer” of 1.5 inches of polyfoam with a 2.5 lb. density. This layer is supposed to help ensure even weight distribution and ease the transition from the comfort layers to the firm support layer.
  • The base layer is 5 inches of polyfoam with a 1.8 lb. density, the same used in many other bed-in-a-box mattresses.

Read Our Full Casper Review

Construction Differences/Notes

  • I expect the durability of the mattresses to be about equal.  I would perhaps give Nolah the slight edge.
  • Nolah has a softer top layer with more give, and is softer overall than Casper.
  • Casper has a transition layer on top of a thinner base layer.
  • Both mattresses should be breathable
  • Casper will have more bounce than the Nolah

Related: Best Mattress Picks

Firmness/Feel Differences

Casper is a little firmer than average, but you can push into it about as much as you can the Nolah if you put enough pressure. But Casper springs back more quickly and forcefully. Watch the videos below to see the similarities and differences illustrated.  Overall, I would say the Nolah is softer than the Casper.

Motion Transfer Differences

Both absorb pressure well, meaning they don’t easily transfer motion. That makes each a good option for couples. Nolah has a bit of an edge here, though, because it sinks so much that it doesn’t really transfer motion at all. If you bounce around enough on the Casper, the person next to you will feel it a bit. Watch these videos to see for yourself.

Pick Nolah If:

  • You are a side sleeper — Nolah’s softness make it great at absorbing pressure so you can sleep comfortably on your side.
  • You like sinking into your mattress — Nolah has a quicksand-feel to it, meaning is has a lot of give, so you’ll sleep “in” it more than “on” it

Pick Casper If:

  • You are a stomach or back sleeper — Casper’s firmness makes it a good option for people who sleep on their stomach or back.
  • You prefer established companies — Casper has weathered a good amount of press attention and redesigned its flagship mattress a few times. If you prefer a company that has a more developed track record, go with Casper.

Overall

I hope this comparison helped you with your mattress search. If you have any specific questions about the Nolah or Casper mattress, please leave them in the comments.

The following two tabs change content below.

Joe Auer

Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.

He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 250 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 5 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.

Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.

2 thoughts on “Nolah Vs Casper- Which Should You Choose?”

  1. I was considering getting a Casper Wave, but after reading your reviews I am now considering a Nolah (maybe 12″.) I am a side sleeper who sleeps hot. I currently am sleeping on a inner spring mattress that is plush (& also 16 years old.) I remember trying a pillowtop and thinking it was too soft for me, which has me hesitating about the Nolah. Which would would recommend for me? Or should I even try a different brand? Gah! There are so many of them now!

    • The Nolah 12″ is definitely quite soft. I think it’s perfect for a side sleeper who sleeps hot but the Wave will definitely be firmer (more of a medium firmness).

Leave a Comment