If you close your eyes and think about it, Nectar probably evokes images of life, renewal, and perennials in bloom. Casper might make you think of, well, being dead. Fittingly, both are in the sleep business because great sleep is all about feeling dead at night and alive again in the morning.
But between these two popular mattress brands, which one actually offers you the better fit for your sleep style?
Since our founding in 2015, the Mattress Clarity team has tested more than 500 mattresses (including the Casper The One and the Nectar Classic) and helped over 43,000 readers find the right mattress for their sleep needs and preferences. We know what separates a mattress that feels comfortable in a showroom from one that truly delivers night after night.
Learn more about how these mattresses stack up against each other below.
Product
Type
Score
Product
Type
Score
Should You Choose the Casper or Nectar?
We found that the Casper and Nectar mattresses were an even match in many categories. That said, our testers awarded the Casper perfect scores in cooling and motion isolation, making it ideal for couples who are prone to overheating or waking up because of a restless partner.
| Who Should Choose the Casper? | Who Should Choose the Nectar? |
| Couples | Hot sleepers |
| Hot sleepers | Back sleepers |
| Combination sleepers | Back pain |
Casper vs. Nectar Mattress Video Comparison
Casper vs. Nectar Performance Scores
The Casper and Nectar are very similar mattresses. At 7/10 on our firmness scale, both of these all-foam models are a touch firmer than medium-firm (6.5/10). They are equally responsive and supportive for memory foam mattresses, making both solid options for combination and back sleepers. However, the Casper has an edge over the Nectar in pressure relief and edge support.
To find out how we came up with each score, you can look at our full Casper mattress review or Nectar mattress review.
| Test | Casper The One | Nectar Classic | Average |
| Firmness | 7/10 โ Firm | 7/10 โ Firm | 6.7/10 โ Medium-Firm |
| Side Sleeper Comfort | Unpleasant | Good | Good |
| Back Sleeper Comfort | Excellent | Excellent | Good |
| Stomach Sleeper Comfort | Good | Good | Good |
| Pressure Relief | 4/5 | 3.7/5 | 3.9 |
| Edge Support | 4.7/5 | 3.4/5 | 4.1 |
| Cooling | 5/5 | 5/5 | 3.8 |
| Motion Isolation | 5/5 | 4.7/5 | 3.9 |
| Response | 4.5/5 | 4/5 | 4.3 |
| Sinkage Depth | 4โ | 3.35โ | 3.12โ |
| Sinkage Rating | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate |
| Bounce Height | 6โ | 15โ | 17.89โ |
| Bounce Rating | Low | Moderate | Moderate |
| Noise | 5/5 | 5/5 | 4.5 |
| Sex | 4.7/5 | 4.1/5 | 4.3 |
| Trial Period | 3.5/5 | 5/5 | 4.2 |
| Warranty | 3/5 | 5/5 | 4.6 |
Casper vs. Nectar Pricing
| Casper The One Price | Nectar Price | |
| Twin | $895.00 | $1081.00 |
| Twin XL | $995.00 | $1148.00 |
| Full | $1195.00 | $1498.00 |
| Queen | $1295.00 | $1664.00 |
| King | $1695.00 | $2131.00 |
| California King | $1695.00 | $2131.00 |
The above prices may not reflect current sales or promotions. Visit our coupons page to ensure youโre getting the best deal on your new mattress.
At full price, the Casper mattress is a much better deal than the Nectar Classic; a queen-sized mattress will cost you over $600 more from Nectar. Fortunately, both models land at roughly the same price point when on sale, with the queen Nectar priced as low as $649.
Key Differences Between the Casper and Nectar
The Nectar and Casper are very similar in terms of construction. However, there are a few significant differences between the two, namely in edge support, pressure relief, and company policies.
The Casper Has Better Edge Support
If you tend to sleep near the edge of the bed or need a secure surface to press down on when getting up in the morning, the Casper is a better option. The One earned a 4.7/5 in the edge support category during testing, while the Nectar Classic only scored a 3.4/5. Our testers felt more secure lying and sitting along the side of the Casper mattress.
โThe Casper has solid edge support when lying on my side, stomach, and back,โ said mattress expert Sosha Lewis. โThe bed had very little sinkage when I was lying down. I felt extremely secure.โ
The Casper Offers Deeper Pressure Relief
Memory foam mattresses are often highly regarded for their pressure-relieving abilities, thanks to their cushiony, deep-sinking feel. However, since both mattresses are on the firmer side, sleepers seeking that slow-moving, traditional memory foam feel will likely fare better on a different model altogether.
The good news is that, in a way, the Casper offers the best of both worlds. Despite its above-average support and firmness, the Casper still scored a 4/5 in our pressure relief category, making it a well-rounded option for average-weight back sleepers and side sleepers.
The Nectar only earned a 3.7/5 in this category. While it provided solid spinal alignment and pressure relief for back sleepers, our testers experienced more tension when lying on their sides.
โThe Nectar offers the support of an innerspring mattress while adding a touch of softness,โ said Dr. Hannah Habeeb, our chief medical product tester. โHowever, I think some side sleepers may want more sinkage if theyโre spending the whole night in that position.โ
The Nectar Has a More Generous Trial and Warranty
There are not many online mattress companies that can go toe-to-toe with Nectar in customer experience, and this matchup is no different. Like all of its mattresses, the Nectar Classic is backed by the companyโs 365-night sleep trial and limited lifetime warranty. If you are concerned about not being able to try the mattress beforehand and would prefer more time to ensure your new bed is right for you, Nectar offers better peace of mind.
Conversely, the Casper offers a 100-night sleep trial and 10-year warranty. While weโre confident that the Casper is durable enough to hold up at least that long (or longer), this is still on the lower end of sleep trials and warranties.
Similarities Between the Casper and Nectar
Perhaps unsurprisingly, both of these memory foam models excel at absorbing motion and preventing it from rippling across the mattress surface. They also excel in areas where memory foam mattresses typically lack, including cooling and responsiveness.
Both Isolate Motion Well
Memory foam mattresses are often a hit among couples because of their motion-dampening properties. Since memory foam models lack bouncy innerspring coils or responsive latex, they tend to absorb the movement that would normally disturb sleepers.
During testing, both mattresses performed well above average, with the Casper earning a perfect 5/5 and the Nectar scoring 4.7/5.
โI could feel Rileyโs presence on the Casper, but could not tell when she was getting in and out of bed, nor switching around to different positions,โ said Sosha during the partner motion transfer test. โIt was not the least bit disturbing, and I can be woken up by dust settling on the bed, so that says something. Those who sleep with restless partners should love this!โ
Both Have Perfect Cooling
Hybrid mattresses are often preferred by hot sleepers because their innerspring coils naturally ventilate and regulate temperature better. Memory foam mattresses typically trap heat because there is nowhere for it to escape.
Fortunately, the Nectar and Casper are exceptions to this rule, both earning a perfect 5-star score in the cooling category.
โI didnโt feel overheated on the Nectar,โ said mattress tester Livvi DiCicco. โThere was a slight warm-up because the Nectarโs foams conformed to my body, but I felt comfortable overall.โ
Both Are Bouncy for Memory Foam Models
Responsiveness is another category where the Nectar (4/5) and Casper (4.5/5) surpassed our expectations. All-foam mattresses can be easy to get trapped in because they often lack the bounciness provided by innerspring coils. However, the firmer-than-average surface of both models prevents you from sinking in too much and feeling stuck.
Combination sleepers who prefer the feel of memory foam should be able to move around without issue on either bed.
โIt is very easy to switch positions on the Casper,โ Sosha said. โIt is all foam, and you sink in very slightly, but I canโt imagine it giving anyone any problems. Combo sleepers who are foam lovers should like this bed.โ
Which Bed Is Better For Your Body Type?
Lightweight Sleepers (Up to 130 lbs)
Barring back and stomach sleepers who prefer a firmer sleep surface, neither the Casper nor the Nectar is the best fit for people in this body weight category. Notably, side sleepers in this weight category will need something softer to contour pressure points, such as the hips, shoulders, and lower back.
We recommend opting for one of our best soft mattresses instead.
Average-Weight Sleepers (130-230 lbs)
The Casper and Nectar are best suited for average-weight sleepers, thanks to their firmer-than-medium-firm-but-not-too-firm constructions. During testing, our mattress experts experienced solid pressure relief across the board in every sleeping position, especially on their backs.
โAverage-weight back sleepers rejoice,โ Sosha said about the Casper. โThis is a great mattress for back sleeping, especially if you like the feeling of being on top of the bed.โ
Heavyweight Sleepers (230 lbs and Up)
Unfortunately, neither mattress is a great option for this type of sleeper. Larger-bodied folks will likely need something taller and firmer to support their weight and prevent them from sinking too far and โbottoming out.โ
Some side sleepers with larger bodies who prefer a softer, cushioned surface might fare better on the Nectar Classic because it is one inch taller than the Casper. However, we would recommend one of our best mattresses for heavy people instead.
Casper vs. Nectar Construction and Materials
| Casper The One | Nectar Classic Memory Foam | |
| Type of Mattress | Foam | Foam |
| Number of Layers (Including the Cover) | 4 | 4 |
| Height | 11โ | 12โ |
| Pillow Top | No | No |
| Organic Materials | No | No |
Casper vs. Nectar Company Policies
| Casper | Nectar | |
| Trial Period | 100-night trial | 365-night trial |
| Warranty | 10 years | Limited lifetime |
| Shipping | Casper offers free shipping via UPS on mattresses within the contiguous United States. If you are in Alaska or Hawaii, you will have to pay an extra $250 fee. | Free within the contiguous United States. Non-refundable $350 shipping fee to Alaska and Hawaii. |
| Return Policy | Casper gives you 100 nights to try your mattress for free. Returns are free after the 30-night adjustment period. There is no restocking fee. | Returns are free in the contiguous U.S. A delivery charge is added at checkout if you are outside of the US. |
Casper vs. Nectar: Clarityโs Conclusion
The Casper and Nectar are both formidable foam beds with more in common than not. However, the Casper has a slight edge over the Nectar overall, thanks to its excellent performance in a handful of categories. Still, if a firm, supportive bed-in-a-box is on your wishlist, you canโt go wrong with either model.
 | | |
| Casper The One Mattress | Nectar Classic Memory Foam Mattress | |
| Rating | ||
| Firmness | Medium-Firm: 7/10 | Medium-Firm: 7/10 |
| Material | Foam | Foam |
| Cooling | โ | โ |
| Best For | Back Pain, Seniors, Couples | Side Sleepers, Back Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers |
Casper vs. Nectar FAQs
Are the Nectar and Casper mattresses good for cooling?
Despite not having the same airflow and breathability as hybrid models, both the Nectar and Casper mattresses sleep fairly cool for all-foam beds.
What are the Nectar and Casper mattresses made of?
Both mattresses have multiple foam layers, including contouring memory foam layers designed for pressure relief and comfort. Underneath, each bed uses a durable base layer that supports the mattress and maintains its shape over time.
Which mattress is the firmest between the Nectar and the Casper?
Both mattresses scored 7/10 on our firmness scale and are firm mattresses compared to other similar models weโve tested. That said, firmness levels can feel different depending on your body type and sleeping position.
What other models does Casper make?
Casper also makes the Casper Dream Hybrid and the Snow Hybrid mattresses. Casperโs lineup includes a mix of all-foam and hybrid options designed for different sleeping styles and cooling preferences.
What other models does Nectar make?
Beyond its flagship mattress, Nectar also offers the Nectar Premier and Nectar Luxe models. Both come in all-foam and hybrid models, giving shoppers more options for cooling, support, and pressure relief.
How do the Casper and Nectar ship?
Casper and Nectar are both mattress-in-a-box brands, meaning their mattresses are compressed, rolled, and shipped directly to your doorstep in a cardboard box. After unboxing, the mattresses expand over the next several hours and are usually ready to use the same day.
