Brooklyn Bedding Vs Loom And Leaf

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

Brooklyn Bedding and Loom & Leaf are two mattress brands that have seen great success online.  They both rely on the online-only business model to pass massive savings onto the consumer in the form of a high-quality, affordable product.  

Brooklyn Bedding vs Loom and Leaf

While they have a similar business model, the two mattresses are actually quite different in the way they feel.  This article will highlight those differences to help you if you are making the decision of Brooklyn Bedding vs Loom And Leaf.

Key Similarities

  • Similar business model (online-only) and value to the consumer
  • Both mattresses consist of all-foam
  • Both use great, durable materials
  • Both companies are known for their customer service
  • The return policies / trial period of both are really great for consumers
Brooklyn Bedding vs Loom and Leaf
4.2 Reviewer
Comfort
Support
Value (Price)
Doesn't Sleep Hot
Motion Transfer
Edge Support
Materials/Durability
Company Reputation
Return Policy/Warranty
Overall Sleep Experience
4.7 Reviewer
Comfort
Support
Value (Price)
Doesn't Sleep Hot
Motion Transfer
Edge Support
Materials/Durability
Company Reputation
Return Policy/Warranty
Overall Sleep Experience

Key Differences

  • Brooklyn Bedding is $750 for a Queen with free shipping; L&L is $1,299 with white glove delivery
  • Brooklyn Bedding is shipped free in a box; L&L has a shipping charge but white-glove delivery
  • Brooklyn Bedding has 3 firmness options; Loom and Leaf has 2 options
  • Brooklyn Bedding has latex in its comfort layer; L&L has memory foam
  • Brooklyn Bedding is resilient/bouncy; L&L has a slow-moving, pure memory foam feel

Construction/Feel

The Loom and Leaf has two layers of memory foam, over a transition foam layer, over a support polyfoam layer.  The memory foam layers have 4 lb. and 5 lb. densities.  Learn more in my Loom and Leaf mattress review.

Loom and Leaf memory foam mattress construction
Loom & Leaf mattress

The Brooklyn Bedding has two layers of latex, one of talalay and one of dunlop, over a support polyfoam layer.  Learn more in my Brooklyn Bedding review.

Brooklyn Bedding Research and Rating
Brooklyn Bedding mattress

Both mattresses use good materials that should be very durable for most people.  The difference really is in the overall feel.  Brooklyn Bedding is bouncy and resilient.  The mattress conforms well, and you definitely feel that you sleep “on” the mattress.  

With L&L, it retains a pure memory foam feel that is slow-moving (although more resilient than most memory foam mattresses).  It’s awesome for pressure relief, and it sleeps cool as well.  See how the feel compares in the videos below:

Brooklyn Bedding firmness and feel (medium option)

Loom and Leaf firmness and feel (relaxed-firm)

Which feel is better?  It really comes down to personal preference.  The feel of these two mattresses is so different that you just have to decide which general feel you like better.

Price

For a Queen mattress, Brooklyn Bedding is $750 with free shipping.  You can usually get a 5% discount as well.

L&L charges $999 for a Queen.  There is also a shipping cost (usually around $99 depending on where you live), as the mattress is not delivered in a box (it’s hand-delivered).

The Loom and Leaf has a more luxury feel and has more expensive materials.  That explains the price difference.  Ultimately, you will have to decide whether the difference in price is justified.

Pick Brooklyn Bedding If:

  • You Want A Bouncy, Latex Feel– The biggest difference between the two mattresses is the feel.  If you want a more resilient mattress or you don’t necessarily like the memory foam feel, then you should go for Brooklyn Bedding.
  • You Want To Save– There is a fairly substantial price difference between the two mattresses.  Brooklyn Bedding is definitely high-quality, so you will save money and still get a good product by choosing the #bestmattressever.

Pick Loom And Leaf If:

  • You Love Memory Foam– This is definitely a pure memory foam mattress.  Some people love the feel of memory foam, and if you do, then you should without question go for L&L.
  • You Want More Luxury– Loom and Leaf definitely has the feel of a true luxury mattress.  There are more bells and whistles and more expensive materials in the mattress.  If you have the budget and want a more luxury mattress, this may be the way to go.

Overall

These are both two really good choices (and have both made our best mattress list).  They have great sleep trials / return policies, so there really isn’t a big risk in trying out either one.  The difference in feel is pretty big though, so hopefully you can make a clear decision on which one will be right for you.

The following two tabs change content below.

Joe Auer

Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.

He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 250 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 5 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.

Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.

Leave a Comment