If youโre shopping for a luxury hybrid mattress to upgrade your sleep setup, youโve likely encountered the Saatva and WinkBed on your journey to better rest. Both brands are known for hotel-like comfort, sturdy support, and high-quality materials, but which one is a better fit for your needs?
Since starting in 2015, the Mattress Clarity team has tested over 500 mattresses (including the Saatva and WinkBed) and has helped more than 43,000 readers find a new mattress.
For this comparison, our team got hands-on with each bed in our studio, evaluating everything from firmness and motion isolation to edge support and responsiveness.
See how the two models compare below.
Product
Firmness
Score
Product
Firmness
Score
Should You Choose the Saatva or WinkBed?
While both models are technically hybrid mattresses, the Saatva has two layers of innerspring coils instead of one. This dual-coil-layer construction makes the Saatva one of the best mattresses for combination sleepers seeking a responsive surface to make movement easier. On the other hand, our testers found that the WinkBed was better at isolating motion, making it a better option for couples with restless partners.
| Who Should Choose the Saatva Classic? | Who Should Choose the WinkBed? |
| Back sleepers | Back sleepers |
| Combination sleepers | Couples |
| Hot sleepers | Hot sleepers |
Saatva vs. WinkBed Mattress Video Comparison
Saatva vs. WinkBed Performance Scores
Our mattress experts thoroughly test every mattress in-house at our Charlotte, NC, studio. We look at factors that could significantly impact your sleep, such as cooling, pressure relief, motion isolation, and more. See how the Saatva and WinkBed compare category by category below.
For a deeper dive into how we arrived at these scores, check out our full Saatva mattress review and WinkBed mattress review.
| Test | Saatva Classic | WinkBed Luxury Firm | Average |
| Firmness Level | 7.5/10 โ Firm | 6.5/10 โ Medium-Firm | 6.7/10 โ Medium-Firm |
| Side Sleeper Comfort | Good | Good | Good |
| Back Sleeper Comfort | Excellent | Excellent | Good |
| Stomach Sleeper Comfort | Excellent | Good | Good |
| Pressure Relief | 4.5/5 | 3.8/5 | 3.9 |
| Edge Support | 5/5 | 4.4/5 | 4.1 |
| Cooling | 4/5 | 4/5 | 3.8 |
| Motion Isolation | 2.7/5 | 3.7/5 | 3.9 |
| Response | 5/5 | 3/5 | 4.3 |
| Sinkage Depth | 3.7โ | 3.4โ | 3.12โ |
| Sinkage Rating | Moderate | Moderate | Moderate |
| Bounce Height | 34.5โ | 18โ | 17.89โ |
| Bounce Rating | High | High | Moderate |
| Noise | 5/5 | 4/5 | 4.5 |
| Sex | 4.7/5 | 3.8/5 | 4.3 |
| Trial Period | 5/5 | 4/5 | 4.2 |
| Warranty | 5/5 | 5/5 | 4.6 |
Trying the Saatva and the WinkBed Back-to-Back
Mattress expert Riley Otis stacked these models against each other (literally and figuratively) in our studio to make a direct comparison. Despite both beds having a similar hybrid construction, Riley noted a handful of significant differences between the two mattresses.
โAlthough they both feel similar in firmness, the Saatva Classicโs Euro top is slightly loftier than the WinkBedโs Euro top,โ Riley said. โIt offers a bit more cushioning around the hips and shoulders when side sleeping. The pressure relief wasnโt necessarily bad on the WinkBed, as it does have a decent amount of foam. That being said, both mattresses were super supportive, both at the center and along the edge.โ
Saatva vs. WinkBed Prices
| Saatva Price | WinkBed Price | |
| Twin | $1399.00 | $1149.00 |
| Twin XL | $1499.00 | $1249.00 |
| Full | $1999.00 | $1499.00 |
| Queen | $2099.00 | $1799.00 |
| King | $2595.00 | $1999.00 |
| California King | $2599.00 | $2049.00 |
The above prices may not reflect current sales or promotions.
At full price, a queen-sized Saatva Classic is almost $400 more than the WinkBed. However, both models frequently go on sale for around the same price. Be sure to check out our coupons for the best deal possible.
Key Differences Between the Saatva and WinkBed
During testing, we found that the real differentiator between the Saatva and WinkBed was the additional coil layer in the Saatva. As a result, the Saatva is better at relieving pressure for back and stomach sleepers, thanks to its robust support system. On the other hand, the WinkBed does a better job of preventing movement from rippling across the bedโs surface.
The WinkBed Isolates Motion Better
The only category in which the Saatva performed poorly during testing was motion isolation (2.7/5). To no oneโs surprise, its coil-on-coil construction made the Saatva feel like a springboard. While it is incredibly easy to maneuver on the surface, we would not recommend it for couples or folks who share their bed with a pet. These sleepers will likely be disturbed by their partnerโs movements.
While some movement was noticeable on the WinkBed, it wasnโt nearly as bad. Motion transfer shouldnโt be a concern for most sleepers on the WinkBed, unless theyโre particularly sensitive to movement. Our testers gave the WinkBed a motion isolation score of 3.7 stars.
โThe WinkBedโs performance during the motion isolation test was a pleasant surprise,โ said mattress tester Melanie Kassel. โThe foam in the pillow top absorbed a lot of motion. I could feel my fellow mattress testerโs movement very slightly on my side of the bed. I donโt think it would have been enough to wake me up.โ
The Saatva Is More Supportive
There are very few mattresses that can compete with the next-level support of the Saatva Classic. During testing, we gave the Saatva a perfect 5-star edge support score because of its secure feel that extends from corner to corner.
โI can actually notice the reinforced edges when I sit down, which I donโt think Iโve experienced on any other bed,โ said mattress tester Livvi DiCicco. โGetting in and out of bed is almost like sitting on a table. Thereโs no sinkage or slipping that I can notice, a sign of amazing edge support. Iโd say that older adults and those with mobility concerns would be set on this bed.โ
While the WinkBed also provides solid edge support (4.4/5), the Saatva is the best choice for sleepers who rely on a strong perimeter to stand up in the morning.
The Saatva Relieves More Pressure
The Saatva also earned an impressive overall pressure relief score (4.5 stars) during our testing. The additional support provided by the coils in its construction provides stomach and back sleepers with more lift for their lower bodies. This elevation helps keep the spine in a neutral position, which can help ease tension.
โI can feel the Saatva providing really great contouring at my hips and lower back while also giving me a great level of support,โ said Dr. Hannah Habeeb, our chief medical product tester and licensed physical therapist. โIn the back sleeping position, my spine feels aligned, and my lumbar region is supported. My upper back also feels really cushioned, and Iโm not feeling any pain anywhere.โ
The WinkBed only scored a 3.8/5 in this category, as some of our testers found that they sank further into the memory foam than they would have liked. Excessive sinkage over time can cause pressure buildup.
Both mattresses have a soft pillow top, making them a solid choice for most side sleepers. That said, the Saatva might be too firm for lightweight side sleepers and those with existing joint pain.
Similarities Between the Saatva and WinkBed
Despite their key differences, the Saatva and WinkBed are two hybrid models that share many similarities. Learn more about what the two have in common below.
Both Are Hybrid Models
While the WinkBed is slightly softer than the Saatva Classic, neither mattress delivers that slow-sinking, traditional memory foam feel. Both are hybrid mattresses that combine an innerspring coil system with memory foam layers to balance support and cushioning.
That said, the Saatva has a more traditional innerspring feel overall, which is why you may see it categorized as an innerspring mattress elsewhere.
Both Have Strong Cooling
The Saatva and the WinkBed both performed well in our cooling tests, as the steel coils both facilitate airflow and temperature regulation. Our mattress testers gave both models a 4/5 in the cooling category, meaning hot sleepers should remain cool and comfortable through the night.
Neither Model Is Great for Adjustable Bases
At 11.5 and 13.5 inches thick, respectively, both the Saatva and WinkBed were somewhat difficult to use on the adjustable base in our studio. During testing, our mattress experts noticed that neither bed conformed especially well to certain positions and settings.
In general, all-foam memory foam mattresses tend to be more malleable and better suited for adjustable bases.
Which Bed Is Better For Your Body Type?
Lightweight Sleepers (Up to 130 lbs)
In most scenarios, the WinkBed is a better option for lightweight sleepers because its softer surface (6.5/10 on our firmness scale) provides more sinkage. Lightweight side sleepers, in particular, should find that the WinkBed offers more cushioning and contouring around common pressure points, such as their hips and elbows.
Since the Saatva is a firm mattress (7.5/10 on our firmness scale), itโs not a great fit for side sleepers in this body weight category. However, back and stomach sleepers should find plenty of support on the Saatva.
Average-Weight Sleepers (130-230 lbs)
Both mattresses are an excellent fit for average-weight sleepers. Back sleepers should find plenty of lift from the pocketed coils in each model to maintain neutral spinal alignment.
The Saatva will likely have a slight edge among average-weight stomach sleepers, thanks to its additional layer of coils. Stomach sleepersโ hips tend to sink more, so the extra support helps them stay in a healthy position.
Conversely, side sleepers will fare better on the WinkBed, thanks to its softer surface and gentle cushioning around the shoulders and hips.
Heavyweight Sleepers (230 lbs and Up)
Sleepers with bigger bodies benefit from more support, making the Saatva Classic the clear winner for this weight category. Back and stomach sleepers in this weight category should get ample support from the reinforced innerspring coils, while side sleepers will sink in just enough into the Euro pillow top cover to get the gentle contouring they need in their hips and shoulders.
Saatva vs. WinkBed Construction and Materials
| Saatva | WinkBed | |
| Type of Mattress | Hybrid | Hybrid |
| Number of Layers (Including the Cover) | 5 | 6 |
| Height | 11.5โ or 14.5โ | 13.5โ |
| Pillow Top | Yes | Yes |
| Organic Materials | Organic cotton cover | No |
Saatva vs. WinkBed Company Policies
| Saatva | WinkBed | |
| Trial Period | 365-night trial | 120-night trial |
| Warranty | Lifetime warranty | Lifetime warranty |
| Shipping | White glove delivery and free shipping in the 48 contiguous states | Free shipping within the 48 contiguous states |
| Return Policy | Free returns minus $99 processing fee | Free returns with no fee during the 120-night sleep trial |
Saatva vs. WinkBed: Clarityโs Conclusion
The Saatva Classic and WinkBed are both high-quality hybrid mattresses, but they cater to slightly different sleepers. The Saatva stands out for its traditional innerspring feel and strong lumbar support, while the WinkBed offers a slightly softer, more balanced feel overall.
No matter which you choose, both mattresses deliver durable support, quality materials, and a premium sleep experience.
 | | |
| Saatva Classic | WinkBed Mattress | |
| Rating | ||
| Firmness | Multiple Firmness Options | Multiple Firmness Options |
| Material | Innerspring | Hybrid |
| Cooling | โ | |
| Best For | Back Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers, Hot Sleepers | Side Sleepers, Back Sleepers, Stomach Sleepers |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which mattress feels more comfortable?
Both options are high-quality mattresses that should feel comfortable to most sleepers. That said, the firmer feel of the Saatva will likely feel more comfortable for stomach-sleeping individuals.
What firmness options is the Saatva available in?
The Saatva comes in three different firmness options: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. Our team tested the Luxury Firm model.
What firmness options is the WinkBed available in?
The WinkBed also comes in three different firmness options: Softer, Luxury Firm, Firmer. We tested the Luxury Firm version of the WinkBed in our studio.
Which mattress is better for back pain?
While both mattresses are a solid option for sleepers with back pain, the Saatva has a slight edge over the WinkBed. The Saatvaโs firmer feel and coil-on-coil construction offer superior lumbar support.
What other mattress models does Saatva sell?
In addition to the Saatva Classic, Saatva sells several specialty mattresses, including the Saatva HD for heavier sleepers, the adjustable air-bed Saatva Solaire, and the Saatva Rx, which is designed for sleepers with chronic back and joint pain.
What other mattress models does WinkBed sell?
Beyond the flagship WinkBed, the brand also offers the WinkBed GravityLux memory foam mattress, the WinkBed Plus for heavier sleepers, and the WinkBed EcoCloud, a latex hybrid made with more natural and eco-friendly materials.
Which mattress is better for heavier sleepers?
The Saatva Classic is a better choice for heavy people, thanks to its durable coil-on-coil construction and high-density foam base.
