Those who are shopping for a bed-in-a-box mattress have undoubtedly come across the Casper and Tuft and Needle mattresses; they have been at the forefront of the online mattress market for many years and are two of the more popular mattresses.
For those who are attempting to decide between these two mattresses, it might be a difficult decision; to make it easier to choose, let’s take a look under the hood of the Casper and Tuft and Needle mattresses.
- The Casper and Tuft and Needle are both terrifically popular online mattresses.
- Both of these bed-in-a-box mattress companies offer fantastic customer service terms.
- The Casper and Tuft and Needle are both all-foam mattresses that do not incorporate coils.
- These online mattresses have comparable base layers consisting of supportive polyfoam.
- The mattresses have an almost identical bouncy, responsive foam feel.
Click To Get The Highest Available Discount On Casper
- The Casper mattress is pricier than the Tuft and Needle mattress.
- The mattresses incorporate some different materials; the Casper features latex-like foam and memory foam, and the Tuft and Needle incorporates a proprietary Adaptive Foam.
- The Casper has four layers while the Tuft and Needle only features two layers.
- The Casper contains a zoned construction, but the Tuft and Needle does not feature this kind of construction.
- The Tuft and Needle mattress feels slightly firmer than the Casper mattress.
- The zoned construction gives the Casper a slightly different feel than the Tuft and Needle.
Click To Get The Best Deal On Tuft & Needle
- The Casper mattress is 10” tall.
- The mattress has a soft, thin cover that allows sleepers to easily feel the comfortable upper layers of the mattress.
- The first layer of the Casper mattress is 1.5” of responsive, latex-like foam.
- Below this is 1.5” of memory foam that offers that slow, sinking experience and assists with pressure relief.
- The next layer is 1.5” of a zoned transition foam that moves sleepers from the comfortable upper layers to the support layers beneath.
- The base layer of the Casper mattress is 5” of durable support foam.
Check out the full Casper mattress review
Tuft And Needle Construction
- The Tuft and Needle mattress is 10” tall.
- The cover is thin and soft and shouldn’t affect the overall feel of the mattress.
- The first layer of the mattress is 3” of proprietary Adaptive foam.
- 7” of standard base polyfoam comprises the base of the Tuft and Needle.
Read the full Tuft & Needle mattress review
- The Tuft and Needle features a particularly simple construction – there is a standard base layer, and the Adaptive Foam is similar to a combination of latex and memory foam; it offers exceptional pressure relief, but sleepers shouldn’t have difficulty moving around.
- The Casper has a significantly more complex construction; it features a Zoned Support system that makes the transition layer firmer toward the middle of the mattress. Because of this, the mattress will feel more supportive when someone is back sleeping or stomach sleeping and softer when they are side sleeping.
- While both mattresses feature a bouncy, responsive feel, the Casper will still feel marginally different – the zoned construction provides the mattress with a unique feel that changes depending on what position someone is sleeping in.
- The Casper and Tuft and Needle should be nearly identical in terms of breathability; they should both be reasonable options for hot sleepers.
- The Casper might be slightly more durable than the Tuft and Needle mattress.
RELATED: Most Comfortable Mattress
In terms of firmness, the Casper feels like a 6/10 and the Tuft & Needle feels like a 6.5/10 – I will note that, since the Casper features a zoned construction, it might feel slightly softer or firmer depending on one’s sleeping position; the Tuft and Needle, on the other hand, features the same firmness across the mattress.
Back sleeping on the Casper, the mattress is extremely supportive; my hips don’t sink in particularly far, and the zoned construction adds extra support under my lumbar area. When I am side sleeping, the mattress is actually softer under the shoulder area, so I feel nice pressure relief there; moving to my stomach, I also experience fantastic support.
Back sleeping, the Tuft and Needle is an exceptional match; my hips sink into that Adaptive Foam just the perfect amount, but I will mention that I feel superior support on the Casper mattress. Sleeping on my side, I also feel reasonable pressure relief on my shoulders and hips, but the mattress is not quite as comfortable as the Casper.
Finally, when I am stomach sleeping, I don’t feel fantastic support; I sink too far into the mattress when I am in this sleeping position.
Both mattresses have a similarly balanced foam feel; they are bouncy and responsive, so people shouldn’t feel stuck in either mattress. Again, the Casper will feel a bit different because of the zoned construction; depending on one’s sleeping position, it might feel somewhat firmer or softer.
See more of what I thought of Casper’s zoned construction in the video below.
Now, see what I thought of the Tuft and Needle mattress’ firmness and feel.
Motion Transfer Differences
For those who are looking for a mattress for couples, it is definitely worth considering how well a mattress handles motion transfer.
I placed a glass of water on both mattresses and then pushed into the surrounding area; I saw much less of a disturbance on the Casper mattress. Also, I lay down on both mattresses and asked Marten to move around next to me; I felt fewer of his movements when I was lying on the Casper mattress.
For those who people sleep with a partner, the Casper mattress should be an excellent option.
See how the Casper handles motion transfer in the video below.
Compare this to the Tuft and Needle’s performance during my motion transfer tests.
Edge Support Differences
Customers also want to consider edge support if they are looking for a mattress for couples – will they be able to sit and lie near the edge of the mattress, or will they feel like they are going to fall off?
Between the two mattresses, the Casper features superior edge support; sitting on the edge of the mattress, I feel significantly more secure and, lying down near the edge, I feel less like I am going to roll off. Casper’s edge support isn’t absolutely fantastic, but it is better than that of the Tuft and Needle mattress; see the edge support differences in the photos below:
Marten is a staff writer for us, and he has a particularly different body type than me – he is 6’7″ and weighs about 230 lbs (I am 5’9″ and 160 lbs), and here is what he thought about these mattresses:
In terms of firmness, I said the Tuft and Needle was a 6.5/10, and the Casper was a 7/10.
Back sleeping on the Tuft and Needle, I am sinking too far into the mattress but, while side sleeping, I am feeling decent pressure relief. When I am stomach sleeping, I am bowing in at the hips and feeling myself get out of neutral alignment.
Back sleeping, the Casper supports me very well; my hips sink in but not extremely far, and the zoned support is definitely holding me up overall. Side sleeping, I’m feeling a little more pressure than I felt on the Tuft and Needle but, that being said, it is still a decent match for me as a side sleeper. When I am stomach sleeping, I experience good overall support; the zoned construction is keeping my hips from sinking in too far.
For those who are heavier and sleep on their backs, I would lean toward the Casper; heavier side sleepers should consider the Tuft and Needle. However, those who weigh even more than me might want to consider the Casper. The zoned construction should ensure heavier people don’t sink in too extremely far when they are on their sides; heavier stomach sleeper should also lean toward the Casper mattress.
Even for someone of Marten’s size, the Casper is more supportive when he is back or stomach sleeping, but he prefers the Tuft and Needle for side sleeping. Perhaps the shoulder area of the Casper is too soft for him; he might be hitting the firmer support layers beneath.
The Casper Might Work For …
- Those who want a more supportive mattress. While the Tuft and Needle is firmer, the Casper is still more supportive; the zoned construction makes it so the middle of the mattress is firmer so the hips get the requisite support.
- Combination sleepers. The Zoned Support makes this a great match for all three sleeping positions. When someone is back sleeping or stomach sleeping, the firm center section keeps the hips from sinking in too far; also, the shoulder area of this mattress is soft, so people should feel decent pressure relief when they are on their side.
- Those who will pay a higher price for a more complex mattress. Between the two mattresses, the Casper has significantly more to offer; it features a more complex design and could be a superior option for most sleeping positions. For those who are willing to pay more money, the Casper could be a solid investment.
RELATED: Best Mattress For Stomach Sleeping
Pick Tuft And Needle If:
- Those who prefer a bit firmer mattress. The Tuft and Needle is the firmer of these two mattresses; for those who like a mattress with some more firmness, this should be a fantastic match.
- Those who are looking for a value mattress. The Tuft and Needle is much more affordable than the Casper; those who want a simpler, less expensive mattress could save some money by choosing the Tuft and Needle.
RELATED: Best Mattress
If someone is choosing between these mattresses, it really comes down to what they are willing to pay. If someone can pay a few hundred dollars more, the Casper is a more complex mattress that should be a good fit for all three sleeping positions; if they want a more affordable mattress with fewer frills, the Tuft & Needle could work better.
Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.
He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 250 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 5 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.
Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.
Latest posts by Joe Auer (see all)
- Best Mattress For Hip Pain 2020 - March 13, 2020
- Best Pillow Top Mattress 2020 - March 5, 2020
- Amerisleep AS3 Hybrid Mattress Review – A Great Balance Of Comfort And Support? - March 4, 2020