Allswell and Saatva are two bed-in-a-box options with very different qualities as well as a few similarities. The two come at different price points and have different constructions. We’ll look at them side-by-side in this Allswell Vs. Saatva mattress comparison to help you determine which is the better fit for you.
Allswell Vs Saatva Overview
Allswell is Walmart’s bed-in-a-box brand, and they’re sold at low prices. But just because they’re budget-friendly doesn’t mean they aren’t high-quality! All of their mattress models are made with durable materials. The company sells the Allswell Luxe Hybrid and Allswell Supreme, but in this review we will look specifically at the Original Allswell.
Saatva is a well-known luxury mattress brand. They sell a variety of different beds including the adjustable Saatva Solaire, Loom & Leaf, and Saatva Latex Hybrid. In this mattress comparison, we’ll look specifically at the Saatva Classic. This mattress comes in three firmness levels: Plush soft, luxury firm, and firm. It has two thickness levels available: 11.5″ and 14.5.” In this review, we’re focusing specifically on the 11.5″ luxury firm model.
Who Should Get The Allswell?
- Those who are on a budget
- Stomach sleepers
- Lightweight sleepers
Who Should Get The Saatva?
- People who want a luxury mattress
- Side sleepers
- Average or heavyweight sleepers
Similarities Between The Allswell And Saatva?
When comparing mattresses, we always start by looking at what makes them similar. Read on to see what these two brands have in common!
- Both contain some materials that are considered eco-friendly and both contain memory foam.
- Both are good options for couples, and both offer free shipping.
- Saatva has an option that is similar in firmness to Allswell.
- Both brands are made with foam and innersprings
Read our full Allswell mattress review.
Key Differences Between The Allswell And Saatva?
Now, let’s see how the two mattress brands are different. This way, you can learn which one is the right pick for you!
- Saatva offers different firmness options
- Allswell is 10″ thick; Saatva offers thicknesses of 14.5″ and 11.5″.
- Saatva’s support layer incorporates a unique coil-on-coil technology.
- Saatva has a pillow-top, while Allswell has a quilted top.
- Allswell is more budget-friendly
- Saatva offers a 180-night trial, while Allswell offers a 100-night trial.
Read our full Saatva mattress review.
Firmness and Feel Differences
It’s always important to take a close look at a mattress’s firmness level and feel. Read on to see which bed is the best pick for your sleep needs!
How Firm Are The Allswell And Saatva Mattresses?
On our firmness scale, the Allswell is a 7.5/10. A 6.5/1o is considered medium-firm, so this mattress is on the firmer side. Although the top layers are soft, they are quite thin. Sleepers will mostly notice the support layers underneath.
The Saatva luxury firm mattress feels like a 7/10 on our firmness scale. The plush pillow top gives the mattress a good amount of cushioning, but sleepers will mostly feel the support coils beneath it. If you prefer a softer bed, we recommend the Saatva Plush Soft model. In fact, it was named one of the best soft mattresses!
Sleeping On the Allswell And Saatva Mattresses
Comfortability depends a lot on a person’s height and weight. However, most back sleepers should feel quite comfortable on the Allswell mattress. The base layer provides nice support and the comfort layers create a good amount of cushioning.
Generally speaking, side sleepers may not like the Allswell mattress. Because the top layers are thin, this mattress may not provide enough pressure relief in this sleeping position.
The Allswell’s firmness makes it a great pick for stomach sleepers, though. The support layers should prevent hips from sinking out of alignment, which is exactly what you should look for in one of the best firm mattresses.
For back sleepers, the Saatva provides a good balance of comfort and support. Hips will sink into the pillow top layer and feel plenty of support from coils underneath. Because of this, we named it one of the best mattresses for lower back pain and sciatica.
Side sleepers should notice a decent amount of pressure relief on the Saatva. The pillow top layer will give some cushioning to shoulders and hips, but some people may find they need more plushness.
Because it’s slightly firm, the Saatva could be a good match for many stomach sleepers. Lighter people will likely stay in the proper spinal alignment, but heavier sleepers may find they need more support.
What Do The Allswell And Saatva Mattresses Feel Like?
The Allswell has a traditional innerspring feel. It does feature thin layers of foam on top, but most sleepers will sink into the support layers more. Because of its coils, the Allswell has a good amount of bounce. It’s quite easy to move around on top of the Allswell.
The Saatva mattress has a similar feel to the Allswell. The coils underneath give the mattress some bounce, and it’s easy to move around on. The pillow top layers are softer than Allswell’s foam layers, so it will provide a bit more pressure relief. Sleepers won’t feel “trapped” inside this mattress.
Average Weight Sleepers – 130lbs – 230lbs
Average weight back sleepers should find the Allswell mattress is a great fit. The base layer, combined with the soft foam on top, creates a great balance of comfort and support. Side sleepers in this category, however, may feel they need more comfort. Because the foam layer is a bit thin, side sleepers may notice a bit of strain on pressure points over time. Average weight stomach sleepers, on the other hand, should fell well supported on the Allswell mattress.
On the Saatva, average weight back sleepers should feel quite comfortable. The pillow top comfort layer, in addition to the supportive coils, creates a well-balanced firmness and feel. The Saatva Luxury Firm mattress is a decent choice for average weight side sleepers, but some people may prefer the feel of the Plush Soft model. Saatva’s firm feel makes it a great pick for average weight stomach sleepers. People in this category shouldn’t notice their hips bowing out of alignment.
Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs
Heavyweight back sleepers will likely find the Allswell is a great pick. People in this category will sink into the comfort layers and feel the support underneath. However, the Allswell’s thin comfort layer does not make it a great pick for heavyweight side sleepers. People who weigh more than 230lbs will want a mattress that provides more pressure relief. However, the Allswell is a great pick for heavier stomach sleepers. The supportive coils at the bottom should help sleepers maintain the proper spinal alignment all night long.
For many heavyweight back sleepers, the Saatva is a great choice. It provides a nice amount of comfort and support. Those who weigh closer to 300lbs, however, may find they don’t get all of the support they need. Instead, they may want to try the Saatva HD, which we named one of the best mattresses for heavy people. Heavier side sleepers will find the Saatva is a decent pick, but some will need additional pressure relief. For larger stomach sleepers, the Saatva may not be supportive enough.
Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs
The Allswell is a great pick for lightweight back sleepers. Because they won’t sink deeply into the top layers, people in this category will experience both comfort and support. Lightweight side sleepers, though, will likely need some extra cushioning around shoulders and hips. For lighter stomach sleepers, the Allswell is a great pick.
The Saatva is excellent for lightweight sleepers, no matter which sleeping position they choose. People who weigh less than 130lbs should feel the pressure-relieving benefits of the plush pillow top alongside the support from the coils underneath.
Mattress Construction Differences
Now, let’s peel back the covers and see what the Allswell and Saatva mattresses are made out of.
The Allswell has a cover that’s quilted with foam for added comfort.
The Saatva’s cover is made out of organic cotton, which makes the mattress feel breathable and soft. It’s also quilted with foam for a pillow top look and feel. In fact, Saatva is one of the best pillow top mattresses on the market.
Next, the Allswell has a thin layer of copper and charcoal-infused memory foam. In addition to providing pressure relief and body contouring, this material helps dissipate heat.
A good deal of Saatva’s comfort comes from its pillow top, but it also has a layer of memory foam beneath it. This gives the mattress another boost of pressure relief for shoulders and hips.
The Allswell has a support layer made with individually-wrapped coils. In addition to providing support, these coils help eliminate motion transfer. Because of these innersprings, the Allswell has a responsive and bouncy feel.
The Saatva has two sets of steel coils in its support layer. First, there’s a layer of microcoils that provide support and body contouring. Then, there’s a layer of thick and durable coils that are designed to handle heavier weights. This is just one of the reasons why we named Saatva one of the best innerspring mattresses.
The Allswell mattress is 10″ tall.
The Saatva mattress is available in two heights – 11.5″ and 14.5.” In this review, we looked specifically at the 11.5″ model.
Allswell And Saatva Mattress Size Options and Price
Want to learn more about pricing and size availability? Take a look at our handy charts below!
|Twin||38.5 ” x 74.5″ x 10″||$265|
|Twin XL||38.5″ x 79.5″ x 10″||$295|
|Full||54″ x 74.5″ x 10″||$345|
|Queen||60” x 79.5” x 10”||$375|
|King||75.5” x 79.5” x 10”||$465|
|California King||72” x 84” x 10”||$465|
|Twin||38″ x 75″ x 11.5″ or 14.5″||$849|
|Twin XL||38″ x 80″ x 11.5″ or 14.5″||$1099|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 11.5″ or 14.5″||$1399|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 11.5″ or 14.5″||$1499|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 11.5″ or 14.5″||$1899|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 11.5″ or 14.5″||$1899|
|Split King||76″ x 80″ x 11.5″ or 14.5″||$2098|
|Split California King||72″ x 84″ x 11.5″ or 14.5″||$2099|
Allswell And Saatva Performance Differences
How well do the Allswell and Saatva mattresses perform? Keep reading to learn more about their cooling features, motion transfer, edge support, durability, and more!
Sleeping Hot or Cold
The Allswell has a memory foam layer that’s infused with charcoal and graphite. These materials are meant to pull heat away from the body. Beneath this sits a layer of individually-wrapped coils, which promote airflow. Overall, the Allswell does a good job at keeping people cool.
Because the Saatva has two layers of coils, it has plenty of room for airflow. To further aid in heat dissipation, the Saatva has a breathable cover made out of thin, organic cotton. Because of these features, we think Saatva is one of the best cooling mattresses.
Motion transfer is an important element to consider, especially if you sleep with a partner. When your partner shifts sleeping positions in the night, will you feel the mattress move on your side of the bed?
The Allswell doesn’t do a great job of eliminating motion transfer. Memory foam helps absorb motion, but Allswell’s foam layer is quite thin. And with the coils underneath, you’re likely to feel your partner shift around during the night.
The Saatva also isn’t very good at isolating motion. The coil support layer causes the bed to move when people shift sleeping positions. If motion isolation is a top priority, we recommend looking at one of the best mattresses for couples.
If you sleep with a partner, or if you just like to sleep near the side of the bed, you’ll also want to consider a mattress’s edge support. When you sit or lie down near the side, will you feel supported?
The Allswell’s thick coils gives it great edge support. When sitting on the edge, you may feel a bit of collapse underneath your hips, but it’s still quite secure.
The Saatva also has great edge support. Most sleepers will find they can lie down and sit near the edge of the bed without feeling like they will roll off.
The Allswell should have average durability and last 7-10 years.
Because of its high-quality materials, we expect the Saatva to last a little bit longer than the Allswell — at least 10 years.
The Allswell is a bed-in-a-box mattress, so it can’t be slept on right away. This bed needs 48 hours to off-gas and expand. You may notice a slight chemical smell at first, but it should completely fade away in two days.
The Saatva is not a bed-in-a-box mattress, so there is no off-gassing period.
The Allswell and Saatva mattresses are both very quiet. It’s possible the coils could squeak over time, but we do not anticipate this becoming an issue.
People looking for one of the best mattresses for sex usually want a bed that’s responsive, bouncy, and easy to move around on. The Allswell has innersprings and a responsive comfort layer, so it’s a good option for getting intimate. The Saatva is also a great pick because it doesn’t allow sleepers to sink deeply into the foam layers.
Before purchasing a new mattress, we always recommend shoppers read the fine print. Below, we’ve outlined Allswell and Saatva’s warranty information, sleep trial period, and return policies.
The Allswell mattress is backed by a 10-year limited warranty.
Saatva has a 15-year limited warranty.
Allswell has a 100-night sleep trial period.
Saatva offers a 180-night sleep trail period.
If you aren’t happy with your Allswell or Saatva mattress during the initial sleep trial period, you can return it for a full refund.
Before we wrap up, we always like to answer some of the most frequently asked questions. Keep reading to learn more about the Allswell and Saatva mattresses!
Which mattress is better, Allswell or Saatva?
Every sleeper has a different set of preferences, so it’s difficult to say which brand is better. But generally, Allswell is a great pick for stomach sleepers who are on a budget. Saatva is excellent for back sleepers who want a luxurious and long-lasting mattress.
Can you flip an Allswell or Saatva mattress?
No, Allswell and Saatva mattresses are not flippable. They are both designed with support coils on the bottom and comfort foam on top. Flipping it just wouldn’t work.
What if I don't like my Allswell or Saatva mattress?
Both brands offer generous sleep trial periods, so you have several weeks to determine whether it’s the right bed for you. If you are unhappy with your Allswell or Saatva mattress during the initial trial period, you can return it for a full refund.
Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.
He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 250 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 5 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.
Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.