Purple vs. Brooklyn Bedding – Which Should You Choose?

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

When shopping for a new mattress, there’s a lot to consider. Do you want something made entirely out of memory foam? How firm does it need to be? While many bed-in-a-box brands have high reviews, they will work better for some types of sleepers over others.

Let’s take a look at two highly reviewed online mattresses – The Original Purple and Brooklyn Bedding Signature medium model. In this Purple vs. Brooklyn Bedding mattress comparison, we’ll take a deeper look at each bed’s motion transfer, edge support, firmness levels, and more. Keep reading to see which one is right for you!

Free Accessories
Purple
  • Click for free accessories
  • Good fit for hot sleepers 
  • A good durable option

Doesn't expire

20% Off
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
  • Click for 20% off
  • Comes in multiple firmnesses
  • Good for fans of innerspring mattresses

Doesn't expire

Purple Vs. Brooklyn Bedding Overview

The Original Purple and Brooklyn Bedding Signature are two popular online mattresses. They both have a medium firmness level, making them comfortable options for a variety of sleepers. But even so, these two beds will work out better for different people.

The Original Purple is known for its unique, proprietary gel grid. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature, on the other hand, is a hybrid mattress made with pocketed coils and responsive foam. Here’s a quick snapshot of who might enjoy each mattress.

Who Should Get The Original Purple?

  • Larger people
  • People who tend to sleep hot at night
  • Those who want something more durable

Who Should Get The Brooklyn Bedding Signature?

  • Those who prefer a traditional innerspring feel
  • Lightweight people
  • Those who want different firmness options
  • Those who want a good value hybrid mattress

Purple Vs Brooklyn Bedding Video Comparison

Want to learn more about the Original Purple and Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattresses? Check out our video review below!

 

Similarities Between Purple And Brooklyn Bedding?

Even though the Purple is an all-foam mattress and the Brooklyn Bedding Signature is a hybrid mattress, they still share several similarities. Let’s take a look at some of their common traits.

  • Both brands have good customer service and warranties.
  • The Original Purple and medium Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattresses have similar firmness levels.
  • Both mattresses are responsive and easy to move around on
  • They’re both breathable mattresses.

For a deeper look, check out our full Purple mattress review

Purple Original Mattress Review

Key Differences Between Purple And Brooklyn Bedding?

  • The two mattresses have different materials in the comfort layers.
  • The Brooklyn Bedding mattress has springs, and the Purple features base foam in its base layer.
  • The Brooklyn Bedding Signature comes in three firmness levels. The Original Purple only comes in one.
  • The Original Purple has a squishy gel feel while Brooklyn Bedding has a traditional innerspring feel.
  • The Brooklyn Bedding mattress is a more affordable option.

To learn more, read our full Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress review

Firmness and Feel Differences

The Original Purple and Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattresses have similar firmness levels, but they are better fits for some types of sleepers over others. Keep reading to see which one matches your preferences!

How Firm Are The Original Purple And Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattresses?

The Original Purple and medium Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattresses both scored 6.5/10 on our firmness scale, which is the industry standard. Most sleepers will find they feel medium-firm, but that can differ depending on the person’s weight.

Sleeping On the Original Purple And Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattresses

The original Purple mattress is a fantastic option for back sleepers. The breathable gel grid collapses under the hips, all while supporting the rest of the body. Similarly, side sleepers should find the original Purple mattress is a great pick. The squishy grid gives plenty of relief on pressure points.

Purple Original Mattress - Side Sleeping

Stomach sleepers should also feel supported and comfortable on the Original Purple mattress. The medium firmness level will help support spinal alignment in this sleeping position.

Back sleepers should find the Brooklyn Bedding Signature offers a great balance of comfort and support. The comfort layers do a great job of contouring the lower back, while allowing the hips to sink in slightly. While side sleeping, the Brooklyn Bedding also feels quite comfortable. The memory foam layers provide plenty of pressure relief, so sleepers aren’t likely to notice joint pain over time.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature - Back Sleeping

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature is also a good option for stomach sleepers. The top layer is supportive enough to promote proper spinal alignment and alleviate back pain. Heavier people, though, may find the bed feels too soft and lacks the proper support.

What Do The Purple And Brooklyn Bedding Mattresses Feel Like?

The Original Purple mattress has a gel grid comfort layer, which makes it feel squishy and firm at the same time. This would be a great option for those who like a bed that they can sink into.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature has a plush innerspring feel that offers a good bounce. Sleepers who prefer a traditional mattress may want to choose the Brooklyn Bedding.

Average Weight Sleepers – 130lbs – 230lbs

On the Purple mattress, average weight sleepers should feel very comfortable in all sleeping positions. It’s supportive enough to keep the lower back in alignment while stomach sleeping, but comfortable enough to ease pain on pressure points while side and back sleeping. Side sleepers who weigh closer to 130lbs, though, may think the Original Purple mattress has a higher firmness level. It’s possible they could feel some strain on pressure points while lying in this sleeping position.

Generally, people between 130 and 230lbs should feel comfortable while back sleeping on the Brooklyn Bedding Signature. It’s also a good fit for side sleepers because the comfort layer adds extra pressure relief. Stomach sleepers will want to get the Brooklyn Bedding Signature firm model, because that will help keep their lower backs in alignment throughout the night.

Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs

Those who weigh between 230 and 300 lbs should feel comfortable in all sleeping positions on the Purple mattress. Back and stomach sleepers who weigh more than 300lbs, though, may feel the Original Purple mattress doesn’t provide enough support for their lower backs.

Back sleepers who weigh between 230 and 300 lbs should feel supported and comfortable on the Brooklyn Bedding Signature. It’s important to note that back sleepers who weigh more than 300lbs may think the hybrid mattress isn’t supportive enough. The Brooklyn Bedding Signature will feel too firm for heavyweight side sleepers and too soft for heavyweight stomach sleepers. Instead, they will want to look at one of the best mattresses for heavy people.

Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs

The Original Purple mattress will have a higher firmness level for lightweight sleepers. People who weigh less than 130lbs won’t compress the gel grid very far, so they won’t experience the same pressure relief that a heavier person would. Because of this, the Purple mattress is not the best fit for lightweight back and side sleepers. Lightweight stomach sleepers, on the other hand, should feel well supported on the Original Purple mattress. For this reason, it’s one of the best mattresses for lightweight sleepers.

On the Brooklyn Bedding Signature, lightweight sleepers should feel comfortable in all sleeping positions. While back and side sleeping, the Brooklyn Bedding Signature should provide the right amount of body contouring and support. It’s even a good option for lightweight stomach sleepers because its firmness level supports proper spinal alignment.

Mattress Construction Differences

Now that you know each mattress’ firmness level and feel, let’s take a closer look at their construction. Here’s what you can expect to find inside each layer of the Purple and Brooklyn Bedding mattresses.

Cover

The Purple mattress has a SoftFlex cover that’s thin, stretchy, and breathable.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature has a quilted cover made with soft memory foam. This gives it a plush pillow top look and feel.

Comfort Layers

Underneath the cover, The Purple mattress has 2’’ of their proprietary gel grid made with hyper-elastic polymer. The next comfort layer consists of soft foam.

A mattress is opened to show its design.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature’s top layer consists of 2’’ of bouncy TitanFlex foam. It’s infused with TitaniumGel to promote cooling and airflow, making it a great option for those who tend to sleep hot at night. Below the first comfort layer sits 2’’ of high-density Energex foam. In addition to making the mattress feel responsive, the memory foam acts as a transition layer into the lower levels.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature - Construction

Support Layer

The Original Purple’s base layer consists of firm and supportive foam.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature’s support layer is made with individually-wrapped 6″ pocketed coils that rest on a base layer of high-density memory foam.

Mattress Height

The Original Purple mattress is 9.25″ tall, and the Brooklyn Bedding Signature has a height of 11″.

Purple And Brooklyn Bedding Mattress Size Options and Price

Let’s take a look at the sizing and price options for the Original Purple mattress and Brooklyn Bedding Signature.

Original Purple

Size Dimensions Price
Twin 38″ x 75″ x 9.25″ $599
Twin XL 38″ x 80″ x 9.25″ $799
Full 54″ x 76″ x 9.25″ $999
Queen 60″ x 80″ x 9.25″ $1149
King 76″ x 80″ x 9.25″ $1449
California King 72″ x 84″ x 9.25″ $1449
Split King 76″ x 80″ x 9.25″ $1598

If you’re in the market for a deluxe hybrid mattress, read our Purple Hybrid Premier mattress review.

RELATED: Purple vs Helix

Brooklyn Bedding Signature

Size Dimensions Price
Twin 38″ x 75″ x 12″ $599
Twin XL 38″ x 80″ x 12″ $699
Full 53″ x 75″ x 12″ $849
Short Full 48″ x 74″ x 12″ $849
Queen 60″ x 80″ x 12″ $999
Short Queen 60″ x 74″ x 12″ $999
Olympic Queen 66″ x 80″ x 12″ $999
King 76″ x 80″ x 12″ $1249
Short King 72″ x 75″ x 12″ $1249
California King 72″ x 84″ x 12″ $1249
Split California King 36″ x 84″ x 12″ $699
Free Accessories
Purple
  • Click for free accessories
  • Good fit for hot sleepers 
  • A good durable option

Doesn't expire

20% Off
Brooklyn Bedding Signature
  • Click for 20% off
  • Comes in multiple firmnesses
  • Good for fans of innerspring mattresses

Doesn't expire

If you’re looking for a more affordable option, read our Brooklyn Bedding Bowery mattress review. Those looking for a luxury mattress should check out our Brooklyn Bedding Bloom mattress review.

Purple And Brooklyn Bedding Performance Differences

It’s always important to learn about a mattress’s firmness level and feel, but it’s also helpful to learn about how well it performs. Let’s see how each bed-in-a-box stacks up in terms of edge support, motion transfer, durability, and off-gassing.

Sleeping Hot or Cold

The Original Purple mattress is a great fit for those who tend to sleep hot at night. The gel grid and breathable cover should promote airflow and prevent heat buildup.

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature also does a great job of dissipating heat. The TitaniumGel helps draw heat away from the body, and the individually wrapped pocketed coils promote airflow.

Motion Transfer

When shopping for a new mattress, it’s a good idea to learn about its motion transfer. Couples who share a bed may not want to be disturbed by their partner changing sleeping positions in the middle of the night. If that’s the case, they’ll want to find a new mattress that ranks high in motion isolation.

Neither the Original Purple nor Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattresses perform well in terms of motion transfer. If motion isolation is a top priority, you may want to look elsewhere.

Edge Support

We found the Original Purple mattress has better edge support than the Brooklyn Bedding Signature. When lying near the edge of the Brooklyn Bedding mattress, we notice the sides collapsing in a bit.

Durability

When it comes to durability, both mattresses should last a long time. They are both made with high-quality materials, but we think the Purple mattress will have a longer lifespan.

Off-Gassing

Off-gassing is another name for the slight chemical smell that’s common when opening a bed-in-a-box. We noticed a faint odor when unboxing the Brooklyn Bedding Signature, but the smell completely faded after 48 hours. We did not notice any off-gassing when opening the Purple mattress.

Noise

While testing the new mattresses, we did not notice any significant noise. It’s possible the Brooklyn Bedding’s pocketed coils could create sound over time, but we do not anticipate that being a huge issue.

Sex

Couples looking for one of the best mattresses for sex will want to keep responsiveness top of mind. That way, it’s easy to move around on the bed, and it won’t make partners feel “stuck” inside it. Both the Purple and Brooklyn Bedding mattresses have a bouncy and responsive feel, so they should be good options for sex.

Company Policies

It’s always a good idea to read up on the fine print before buying a new mattress. Let’s take a look at Purple and Brooklyn Bedding’s warranties, sleep trial periods, and return policies.

Warranty Info

Purple and Brooklyn bedding both offer a 10-year warranty.

Sleep Trial

Purple offers customers a 100-night sleep trial, and Brooklyn Bedding’s sleep trial period is 120 nights.

Return Policy

If you aren’t satisfied with your Purple mattress during the 100-night sleep trial period, you can return it for a full refund. Purple does require customers to sleep on their mattress for 21 days before returning, though, because it can often take people a few weeks to break in a new mattress.

During the 120-night sleep trial period, Brooklyn Bedding offers free exchanges and no-fees returns. Like Purple, Brooklyn Bedding asks its customers to try out the mattress for a few weeks before returning. If a customer still isn’t satisfied after 30 days, they can reach out to Brooklyn Bedding’s customer service team to return or exchange.

Gravatar for Marten Carlson

Marten Carlson

Marten is Senior Editor at Mattress Clarity. He covers the mattress industry as well as sleep science news. He is specifically interested in the connection between sleep and overall health. Marten has written for media publications like Consequence of Sound and received a master’s degree in Film Studies from Emory University. He comes from Franklin, Indiana, and spends all the time he can writing, directing, and acting in films. He has directed genre short films and features. His newest film, Starlets, recently premiered at the River Town Film Festival in Clinton, NJ. He also stars in the upcoming thriller, Sour Bear. His next film, At The Hop, is a hot rod actioner with a horror twist.