If you’re looking for the best hybrid mattress on the market, you might have heard of the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and the Saatva. These mattresses have some differences in their construction and feel. In this Brooklyn Bedding Aurora vs Saatva mattress comparison, we’ll look at these key differences. By the end, you’ll know which mattress is right for you.
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora vs Saatva Overview
Brooklyn Bedding is known for making quality mattresses. This company has a variety of models, including the Brooklyn Bedding Titan, the Plank mattress, and the Aurora. Beyond having a variety of models, most of their mattresses have three firmness options, demonstrating their commitment to customizing their mattresses for individual sleep preferences.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora is a luxury mattress that’s sold at an affordable price. It’s a great mattress for a variety of sleepers, including hot sleepers and those looking for a responsive, slow-moving mattress.
Saatva is another well-known company in the mattress space — and for good reason. Each Saatva mattress is designed for optimal comfort and support. The Saatva original, the model we’re looking at today, is no exception. As one of the most popular mattresses on the market, it has a traditional, springy feel.
Who Should Get The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Mattress
- Folks who want a bouncier, foam feel
- Hot sleepers
- People looking for a more budget-friendly option
Who Should Get The Saatva Mattress
- Sleepers who love a traditional spring mattress
- Heavier sleepers
- Folks searching for a soft, plush pillow top mattress
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora vs Saatva Mattress Video Comparison
Take the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva mattresses for a virtual test drive in our video comparison.
Similarities Between The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva?
- They are both hybrid mattresses and feature coils in their construction.
- Both have a springy feel and are bouncy, making them easy to move around on.
- Both mattresses should sleep cool throughout the night.
- Both are firmer than average mattresses.
To see how the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora stacks up against other popular models, check out our Brooklyn Bedding mattress comparisons.
Key Differences Between The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva?
- The Aurora will have more of a responsive memory foam feel when compared to the pillow top feel of the Saatva.
- While they are both breathable mattresses, the Aurora should sleep cooler.
- The Aurora will be more affordable than the Saatva.
For even more great info, check out our Saatva mattress comparisons.
Firmness and Feel Differences
Firmness and feel should be a key consideration when determining which mattress is right for you. While feel is a personal preference, certain firmness levels are better for stomach, back, and side sleepers. Check out the firmness and feel of these two mattresses.
How Firm Are The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva?
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress feels like a 6.5/10 on our firmness scale, which is also the industry standard for medium firm beds. However, it’s important to note that the Aurora comes in three firmness options: soft, medium and firm. The one we ranked was the medium option.
The Saatva is also available in three firmness levels: Plush soft, Luxury Firm, and and Firm. In this review, we’ll focus specifically on the Luxury Firm model. This bed comes in at a 7/10 on our scale, or slightly firmer than average.
Sleeping On the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva
Back sleepers should find the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress to be supportive. Back sleepers’ hips should align with their spines, creating a supportive sleeping experience. Because the Aurora is not a plush mattress, side sleepers might develop some pain on their hips and shoulders on this mattress. Stomach sleepers should find good support, especially if they get the firmest option for their Brooklyn Bedding Aurora. The Aurora will elevate stomach sleepers’ hips so they’re in alignment with their spines, making this one of the best mattresses for stomach sleepers.
The Saatva mattress is also a great choice for back sleepers. The combination of the plush pillow top and firm feel provide excellent lumbar support. In fact, this is one of the best mattresses for arthritis, joint pain, and sciatica. Side sleepers should feel pressure relief on this mattress, but lighter side sleepers could develop some pain in pressure points on the hips and shoulders over time. Stomach sleepers will find the Saatva to be a great match. Its firm feel will provide excellent spinal alignment in this sleeping position.
What Do The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva Mattresses Feel Like?
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress has a responsive, bouncy feel. You shouldn’t feel stuck in this mattress and it should be easy to move around on it. While it is a hybrid mattress, the top foam layers give this mattress a responsive, foam feel.
Few mattresses embody the traditional spring feel more than the Saatva. It is bouncy, but also soft and plush on the top. Similar to the Aurora, you won’t sink super far into this mattress.
Average Weight Sleepers – 130lbs – 230lbs
Average weight back sleepers should feel supported on the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora. Side sleepers under 200lbs should feel good support, but those over 230lbs might notice some pain along pressure points when resting on the medium and firm options. Stomach sleepers should find this mattress to be supportive, especially the firmer model.
Average weight sleepers should enjoy the Saatva whether they sleep on their back, stomach, or side. Back sleepers will feel optimal support while stomach sleepers’ spines should stay in alignment to protect against lower back pain. Side sleepers should feel good pressure relief, thanks to the Saatva’s plush pillow top feel.
Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs
Heavier back sleepers should get plenty of supportive on the Aurora. Heavier stomach sleepers should feel supported on this mattress as well. For heavier side sleepers, this mattress will be too firm and they might instead consider an option with a more plush comfort layer. However, those closer to 300lbs might want to consider getting one of the best mattresses for heavy people instead.
Heavy back sleepers should feel supported on the Saatva mattress. Stomach sleepers should feel a similar balance of support and comfort. Heavier side sleepers might actually feel more pressure relief than lighter side sleepers as they’ll press further into the mattress and better compress the coils. Those on the heavier end might want to consider the Saatva HD which was specifically made with larger people in mind.
Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora is a perfect match for lightweight back sleepers. Side sleepers could feel some pressure, especially if they choose one of the two firmer options. When considering this option, lighter side sleepers may need the softest option to feel sufficient pressure relief. Lightweight stomach sleepers will feel supported on this mattress.
Lightweight back and stomach sleepers will feel supported on the Saatva mattress. However, this medium firm and firm options might be too firm for lighter side sleepers. Lighter side sleepers might not sink far enough into the mattress for adequate pressure relief.
Mattress Construction Differences
Still deciding which should be your new bed? Check out these key construction differences.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora’s TitanCool cover feels soft and breathable. It includes Phase Change Material which absorbs body heat and promotes temperature regulation to help you sleep cool.
Saatva features an organic cotton cover. This makes it soft and breathable. It’s also quilted with soft foam to give it a pillow top feel.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora has three comfort layers. The first layer is 1.5” of the brand’s patented CopperFlex Foam which creates body contouring and pressure relief. The copper infusion helps with cooling the mattress. The next layer contains 2” of hyper-elastic TitanFlex foam. It’s bouncy, responsive, and infused with TitaniumGel for additional cooling. Finally, there’s 1” of a transition layer. This transition layer of swirl visco-elastic memory foam provides additional body contouring.
The Saatva features two comfort layers. The first comfort layer is the pillow top. In fact, the Saatva is easily one of the best pillow top mattresses on the market. Below that is a thin layer of memory foam that offers pressure relief.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora features 8” tall coils in its support layer. These are individually wrapped to minimize motion transfer. Underneath is a base layer made of high-density polyfoam for structure and support.
The Saatva also features a coil system and a supportive core. Saatva, however, has a dual set of steel coils. It has a supportive micro coil layer that are supportive and provide contouring. Its thick coils provide excellent support and can carry heavier weights than the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora mattress is 12” tall.
The Saatva mattress is about the same height at 11.5” tall.
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva Mattress Size Options and Price
Check out the most up-to-date pricing and sizing information for these mattresses in the charts below.
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora
|Twin||38″ x 75″ x 12″||$749.25|
|Twin XL||38″ x 80″ x 12″||$936.75|
|Full||53″ x 75″ x 12″||$1199.25|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 12″||$1311.75|
|Short Queen||60″ x 74″ x 12″||$1311.75|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 12″||$1649.25|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 12″||$1649.25|
|Split California King||36″ x 84″ x 12″||$936.75|
|Twin||38″ x 75″ x 11.5″||$887|
|Twin XL||38″ x 80″ x 11.5″||$1087|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 11.5″||$1474|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 11.5″||$1574|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 11.5″||$2147|
|Split King||76″ x 80″ x 11.5″||$1974|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 11.5″||$2174|
To get the best deals on these mattresses, use our exclusive coupons.
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva Performance Differences
Performance differences should be a huge factor in which mattress you purchase. Whether you’re a hot sleeper, looking for a mattress with a partner, or searching for a mattress that will last for years to come, there’s a lot to consider. Let’s go over those considerations and more for the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva mattresses.
Sleeping Hot or Cold
While Saatva’s cover will help make it cooler, the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora will be the better choice for hot sleepers. Thanks to its TitanFlex and CopperFlex foam and the Phase Change material in its cover, it’s one of the most breathable hybrid mattresses on the market.
The Saatva, however, still promotes airflow, particularly because of the coils in its design. The organic cover should also make the mattress more breathable than other mattresses on the market.
Motion transfer is particularly important for couples to consider because it determines whether you’ll feel your partner tossing and turning during the middle of the night or sleep undisturbed.
Since Aurora is a firm, bouncy mattress, it doesn’t do the best job at isolating motion. However, the coils are individually wrapped so it isolates motion better than other mattresses with coils.
On the Saatva, there is a lot of motion transfer and couples might be disturbed while sleeping. If this is especially important to you, take a look at our top picks for the best mattresses for couples.
Another important consideration for partners is edge support, or how secure you feel when lying or sitting near the edge of the bed. The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora has decent edge support. You should feel secure when sitting or sleeping on the edge of the bed. However, there might be some give if you were to bend down and tie your shoe.
However, Saatva wins out on edge support. The firm edges provide optimal security while sitting or sleeping on the edge of the Saatva, no matter how far you bend down.
Thanks to the high quality materials in its construction, especially the individually wrapped coils, the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora is an extremely durable mattress.
The Saatva has a similar story. It also features high quality coils, so it will be an extremely durable mattress. You can expect both mattresses to last 7 – 10 years.
Because the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora is a bed-in-a-box mattress, there could be some off-gassing when you first get your bed. However, this should dissipate within 24-48 hours.
The Saatva does not arrive compressed inside a cardboard box, so it doesn’t have an off-gassing period.
Neither of these mattresses make noise upon first purchasing. However, since they both have coils in their constructions, it’s possible they may begin to squeak over time.
Since the Brooklyn Aurora mattress is a bouncy mattress, it should be easy for couples to move around on during intercourse. It’s a good mattress for sex.
The Saatva is also a responsive mattress which partners won’t sink into. In fact, it’s one of the best mattresses for sex. Partners looking for a mattress for intercourse can’t go wrong with either mattress.
Check our Brooklyn’s Bedding and Saatva’s warranties, sleep trials, and return policies.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora has a 10-year warranty.
Saatva’s warranty is slightly longer at 15 years.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora’s 120-night sleep trial period gives you more than enough time to try out your mattress from the comfort of your own home.
Saatva offers an 180-night sleep trial, so you can try out your mattress for many nights after purchasing.
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora offers free exchanges and no return fees if you don’t like your mattress. However, they ask you to sleep on your mattress for 30 days before returning or exchanging. The no-return fees do not apply to those in Hawaii, Canada, or Alaska.
If you aren’t satisfied with your Saatva mattress, you can return it during the sleep trial for a $99 transportation fee. Other than this fee, they offer a full refund.
Still deciding which should be your new mattress? Check out the answers to the most frequently asked questions about the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora and Saatva mattresses.
Which Brooklyn Bedding Mattress is best for side sleepers?
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora comes in three firmness options. Because side sleepers often prefer a softer mattress, the softest firmness level should be a good fit for side sleepers.
Do Saatva mattresses sag over time?
Due to its high quality construction and the coils, the Saatva mattress should not sag over time. In fact, it’s an extremely durable mattress.
Which Saatva is best for side sleepers?
The Saatva Classic is a great option for side sleepers. Because it’s a firm mattress but has a plush pillow top layer, it should provide excellent pressure relief.
Does the Saatva sleep cool?
While hybrids usually sleep warmer than other mattresses, the Saatva was designed to combat this and sleep cool. Due to the coils in its construction, it should sleep relatively cool.
Angela is a staff writer at Mattress Clarity. She analyzes sleep products and appears in review videos. She is passionate about how a good night’s sleep contributes to better physical and mental health. Angela earned her B.A. in Professional Writing and Rhetoric at Elon University. When not writing about sleep health, she can usually be found running, whether to the bookstore or to train for her next half marathon.