The Puffy and Nectar are both popular mattresses that are sold online, and the similarities don’t end there. They’re also both all-foam mattresses, and there’s some overlap in their materials.
So how do you choose between the Puffy and the Nectar mattress? Well, we’ve got you covered! Read on for our in-depth comparison of these two mattresses, including overviews of their construction, performance, firmness, and feel.
Puffy Vs Nectar Mattress Overview
Both the Puffy and Nectar are high-quality mattresses, but they’re best suited to different types of sleepers. Here’s a quick overview of who might prefer the Puffy and who might prefer the Nectar mattress.
Who Should Get The Puffy?
- Light- and average-weight stomach sleepers, who need plenty of support
- Folks who prefer a firmer mattress with less give
- People who want a balanced foam feel with a bit of memory foam on top
To learn more about this mattress, check out our in-depth Puffy mattress review.
Who Should Get The Nectar?
- Side sleepers, particularly lightweight and average-weight people
- People who prefer a mattress with a softer feel
- Folks who like a slow-moving memory foam feel that lets them sink in
Learn everything you need to know about this mattress with our comprehensive Nectar mattress review.
Puffy Vs Nectar Mattress Video Comparison
Dive deep into the Puffy and Nectar mattresses with our in-depth video review! Our reviewer, Marten, will assess each bed’s construction and share his experience with sleeping in all positions on these mattresses.
Similarities Between The Puffy And Nectar?
Even though the Nectar and Puffy are produced by different brands, they have several things in common. Here’s a quick overview of their similarities:
- The Puffy and Nectar are both popular bed-in-a-box mattresses
- Both mattresses come with excellent customer service terms
- Both of them have slow-moving memory foam in their top layers
- They both feature a similar base foam in their support layers
- These mattresses are almost the exact same price
Key Differences Between The Puffy And Nectar?
While the Puffy and Nectar have a lot in common, they also differ in several notable ways.
- The Nectar is thicker than the Puffy mattress
- They incorporate some different materials, especially in their transition layers (more on that below)
- They feature different feels: The Puffy has a balanced foam feel, while the Nectar has a slower-moving memory foam feel
- The Nectar mattress is softer than the Puffy
Firmness And Feel Differences (Including Firmness Rating)
No matter which mattress you’re considering, it’s important to think about firmness and feel. These factors have a big impact on whether a mattress will be well-suited to your preferred sleep position and other sleep needs. So let’s take a look at the firmness and feel on the Puffy and Nectar mattresses!
How Firm Are The Nectar And Puffy Mattresses?
We ranked the Puffy around a 7/10 on the firmness scale, and we ranked the Nectar around a 6.5/10. The industry standard for medium firmness is 6.5/10, so this suggests the Nectar is right around medium-firm while the Puffy is a touch firmer.
Note that firmness is a bit subjective: Depending on your body weight, you might perceive these mattresses to be a touch softer or firmer than our rankings.
RELATED: Best Soft Mattress
Sleeping On The Nectar And Puffy Mattresses
We slept on both mattresses and tried them out in all three positions- let’s discuss how they performed when we were back sleeping, side sleeping, and stomach sleeping.
We enjoyed a pleasant balance of comfort and support while back sleeping on the Puffy; our hips and spine felt well-aligned in this position.
While side sleeping on the Puffy, our heavier-weight reviewer noticed some pressure around the shoulder and hip. Lighter people should experience better pressure relief than we did, but heavyweight sleepers might not obtain enough pressure relief in this position.
Our heavier-weight reviewer found the Puffy a bit too soft for stomach sleeping; our hips bowed in a bit, which pulls the spine out of alignment. That said, the Puffy is more supportive than the Nectar in this position, and it’s better suited to light- and average-weight stomach sleepers.
We enjoyed good overall support while back sleeping on the Nectar. The foam pressed into our lumbar area to keep the spine supported and, at the same time, we enjoyed plenty of pressure relief from the memory foam comfort layer.
We experienced better pressure relief while side sleeping on the Nectar than we did on the Puffy. Light- and average-weight sleepers should enjoy the pressure relief in this position, but note that heavyweight sleepers might press through the comfort layer into the firmer support layer underneath, causing pressure around the shoulder and/or hip.
In our experience, the Nectar felt too soft for stomach sleeping, and we didn’t feel that our spine was properly aligned in this position. Strict stomach sleepers will want to look for a firmer mattress.
What Do The Nectar And Puffy Mattresses Feel Like?
The Puffy has a balanced foam feel with just a touch of body-contouring memory foam on top. Overall, it’s easy to move around on top of this mattress.
The Nectar features more of a classic memory foam feel – it contours the body and has a slow response to pressure.
Average-Weight Sleepers – 130 lbs – 230 lbs
The Puffy should offer average-weight back sleepers a nice blend of pressure relief and spinal support, but it will probably feel too firm for most average-weight side sleepers. That firmer feel is good news for average-weight stomach sleepers, who should enjoy adequate spinal support in this position.
Like the Puffy, the Nectar balances comfort and support for average-weight back sleepers (though note that the Puffy is a bit more supportive). The Nectar is definitely the better choice for average-weight side sleepers, as its memory foam comfort layer offers decidedly more pressure relief. However, the Puffy mattress is probably too soft for average-weight stomach sleepers.
Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230 lbs
Heavyweight back sleepers who weigh close to 230 pounds should find adequate support on the Puffy, but folks who weigh much more than that will probably need to look for a more supportive mattress. Heavyweight side sleepers are likely to experience too much pressure around the shoulder and hip on this mattress; they’ll want to look for a plusher mattress for side sleepers. The Puffy could be supportive enough for heavyweight stomach sleepers who weigh closer to 230 pounds; again, much heavier people will want to look for a more supportive mattress.
The Nectar will probably not be supportive enough for most heavyweight sleepers. One possible exception? Heavyweight folks who weigh closer to 230 pounds might find adequate pressure relief while side sleeping on the Nectar. But folks who weigh more than that could press through the comfort layers into the firmer support layer underneath.
Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130 lbs
The Puffy should offer a balance of spinal support and pressure relief to lightweight back sleepers, but most lightweight side sleepers will probably find that the mattress feels too firm in this position. That firmness could be a boon for lightweight stomach sleepers, who should enjoy plenty of spinal support on the Puffy mattress.
Like the Puffy, the Nectar could be well-matched to lightweight back sleepers because it offers a blend of pressure relief and support. This mattress is also a great option for lightweight side sleepers, who should enjoy plenty of pressure relief thanks to the Nectar’s memory foam comfort layers. The Nectar might be too soft for lightweight stomach sleepers, who could feel that their hips bow into the mattress and pull the spine out of alignment.
Mattress Construction Differences
Now that you have a sense of what it feels like to sleep on top of the Nectar and Puffy mattresses, let’s take a look inside of them! We’ll review each mattress’s construction layer by layer and assess how different materials influence performance.
The Puffy mattress has a polyester cover that’s thin, stretchy, and breathable.
The Nectar mattress features a cover made from Tencel fabric, which helps with cooling.
The Puffy’s main comfort layer is a Cooling Cloud layer that features soft memory foam – it has a bit of a slow-moving feel and is infused with gel to help with cooling. Below this layer, there’s a Climate Comfort transition layer that’s firmer, bouncier, and more responsive; this helps ensure that sleepers don’t feel stuck in the mattress.
The Nectar’s primary comfort layer is made from a slow-moving, pressure-relieving gel memory foam that’s infused with gel to help with cooling. Beneath this layer, there’s a transition layer made of hi-core memory foam; this material is firmer and higher-density than the memory foam above, and it provides some support so sleepers don’t drop through the top comfort layer into the base layer underneath.
The Puffy’s base layer is a Firm Core Support base layer that’s made from a firm-set foam. The Puffy brand claims this material isn’t found in other mattresses and that it’s especially durable and supportive.
The Nectar’s support layer is made from a high-density base foam that’s very supportive and provides overall structure for the mattress.
The Puffy mattress is 10” thick, while the Nectar mattress is a touch taller at 11”.
Puffy And Nectar Mattress Size Options And Price
To see the most up-to-date size and pricing information for the Puffy and Nectar mattresses, check out the charts below.
|Twin||39″ x 75″ x 10″||$795|
|Twin XL||39″ x 80″ x 10″||$825|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 10″||$995|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 10″||$1150|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 10″||$1350|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 10″||$1350|
|Twin||39″ x 75″ x 11″||$798|
|Twin XL||39″ x 80″ x 11″||$868|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 11″||$1098|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 11″||$1198|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 11″||$1498|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 11″||$1498|
Puffy Vs Nectar Performance Differences
Before we finish off this review, let’s take a look at some key performance indicators for the Nectar and Puffy mattresses. We put each mattress through a range of tests to evaluate their performance with regard to temperature regulation, edge support, motion transfer, and more. To see how they stack up against other brands, check out our Puffy mattress comparisons and Nectar mattress comparisons.
Sleeping Hot Or Cold
The Nectar and Puffy are both all-foam mattresses, which are known for trapping heat. To help counteract this issue, both beds feature breathable covers and gel infusions in their comfort layers. However, it’s possible that both of these mattresses might still trap some heat.
The Nectar is the winner here. Its two layers of memory foam help absorb motion and prevent movement transfer across the mattress. Because the Puffy is bouncier, it doesn’t perform as well when it comes to isolating motion.
The Nectar wins here. We felt a touch more secure while sitting and lying down near the edges of this mattress.
We called this a tie. Both of these all-foam mattresses should last for approximately the same number of years, which is reflected in the fact that they both come with similar warranty terms.
We observed about the same amount of off-gassing from both the Puffy and the Nectar. Any off-gassing should dissipate within a couple of days.
Another tie! Neither one of these is a noisy mattress, probably because they’re made exclusively from foam.
People who want a mattress for sex generally want a bed that makes it easy to move around and change positions. The Puffy is the winner in this case because it’s bouncier and more responsive than the Nectar. Couples shouldn’t feel stuck in this mattress.
The Puffy comes with a 101-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty. The Nectar comes with a 365-night sleep trial and a Forever Warranty.