These days, many mattress brands offer models that are specifically tailored to the needs of heavier-weight folks. The Big Fig and Saatva HD are two such mattresses. But even though they fall under the same category, these beds differ in some significant ways.
Which one of these mattresses is the right fit for your sleep? Find out in this detailed Big Fig vs. Saatva HD comparison! We’ll review these beds’ similarities and differences as well as their construction, firmness, feel, and performance. Let’s pit these mattresses head to head!
Big Fig Vs. Saatva HD Mattress Overview
Both the Big Fig and the Saatva HD are specifically designed for heavier-weight sleepers, and both of these mattresses should be able to support weights between 300 and 500 pounds. The Big Fig features a complex construction made up of seven different layers. It uses latex foam, high-density polyfoams, and individually wrapped coils to create a responsive and highly supportive sleeping surface. It’s also made in the USA.
Much like the Big Fig, the Saatva HD incorporates latex and highly supportive coils in its construction. Unlike the Big Fig, it also includes some memory foam. This helps explain why the Saatva HD is a bit plusher and more pressure-relieving than the Big Fig. The differences in these beds’ feels mean they’re better suited to different types of sleepers. Here’s a quick overview.
Who Should Get The Big Fig?
- Those who need one of the best mattresses for stomach sleepers
- Folks who are looking for a relatively more affordable mattress
- Hot sleepers who need a mattress that sleeps cool
Learn more about the Big Fig mattress in our comprehensive Big Fig review.
Who Should Get The Saatva HD?
- Side sleepers
- People who want (and have the budget for) a luxury mattress
- Folks who enjoy a pillow-top feel
Get more info about the Saatva HD in our detailed Saatva HD mattress review.
Big Fig Vs. Saatva HD Mattress Video Comparison
Want to see the Big Fig and the Saatva HD in action? Then check out our in-depth video review! Our reviewer, Marten, will reveal each layer of these beds’ constructions and share his experiences with sleeping in every position on both of these mattresses.
Similarities Between The Big Fig And The Saatva HD?
At first glance, the Big Fig and the Saatva HD are very different mattresses. But they do still have a few things in common.
- Both mattresses are made specifically for heavier-weight people.
- These are both very supportive mattresses.
- Both of these beds should be very durable.
- They are around the same firmness.
- Both mattresses should do a decent job of sleeping cool.
Key Differences Between The Big Fig And The Saatva HD?
As we’ve noted above, these beds are generally suited to distinct types of sleepers. That’s largely because of these key differences.
- The Saatva HD has more of a pillow-top feel, while the Big Fig has less “give”.
- The Saatva HD is more of a luxury mattress.
- The Saatva HD is taller than the Big Fig.
- The Saatva HD is designed to offer zoned support, while the Big Fig is not zoned.
- At full price, the Saatva HD costs significantly more than the Big Fig. (A Queen-size Big Fig costs $1,799 at full price, while the same size Saatva HD costs $2,599 at full price)
Firmness And Feel Differences
To get to know these mattresses better, let’s take a look at their firmness and feel. These factors will tell you a lot about which mattress is best suited to your preferred sleep position(s) and other sleep needs.
How Firm Are The Big Fig And Saatva HD Mattresses?
We ranked both the Big Fig and the Saatva HD around an 8 out of 10 on the firmness scale. The industry standard for medium-firmness is 6.5/10, so this suggests both beds are significantly firmer than average. They are both designed to be highly supportive, and they use sturdy and durable materials such as latex, high-density foams, and coils.
Note that firmness is slightly subjective. For instance, folks who weigh well over 300 pounds might find that both mattresses feel a touch softer, while someone who weighs 230 pounds or less will probably perceive them as a bit firmer. That said, it’s safe to say that both of these beds are on the firmer side.
Sleeping On The Big Fig And Saatva HD Mattresses
We personally tested each of these mattresses. Here’s how we felt while sleeping on the Big Fig and the Saatva HD.
While back sleeping on the Big Fig, the mattress felt a bit too firm for our reviewer, who weighs around 230 pounds. His hips didn’t really sink into the mattress to receive any pressure relief. Folks who weigh more shouldn’t have this issue.
The Big Fig also felt significantly too firm for side sleeping. Our reviewer experienced some serious pressure around the shoulder and hip. Again, folks who weigh between 300 and 500 pounds might experience a bit more pressure relief on this bed, although folks who spend all night on their side might want to check out a mattress for side sleeping.
We felt very well supported while stomach sleeping on the Big Fig. Our hips stayed elevated and aligned with the spine.
The Saatva HD felt like a great match for back sleeping. The pillow-top allowed our hips to sink in just a touch for some pressure relief, while the coils ensured that the spine stayed supported. There’s also extra zoned support from the latex and coil layers.
Overall, we experienced nice pressure relief while side sleeping on this mattress. Our reviewer felt just a bit of pressure around the shoulder and hip, but folks who weigh more than 230 pounds should obtain even more pressure relief.
The Saatva HD proved to be a viable match for stomach sleeping; we felt decent support overall, and our hips didn’t bow too far into the mattress. That said, strict stomach sleepers will probably prefer the more supportive Big Fig.
What Do The Big Fig And Saatva HD Mattresses Feel Like?
The Big Fig has a hybrid feel with a good amount of bounce. Its use of latex foam makes the mattress very responsive, so it’s easy to move around on top of this bed.
Much like the Big Fig, the Saatva HD also has a hybrid feel. And it also incorporates latex, which makes this mattress fairly bouncy and responsive. That said, the Saatva HD feels a bit plusher than the Big Fig thanks to its pillow-top.
Average Weight Sleepers – 130lbs – 230lbs
Average-weight back and side sleepers will almost certainly find that the Big Fig feels too firm. They won’t press into the top layers to obtain any notable pressure relief. Average-weight stomach sleepers who like a very firm feel could enjoy sleeping on this mattress.
The Saatva HD could be a decent match for average-weight sleepers who like a very supportive mattress. Back and stomach sleepers should feel well-supported on this bed. Side sleepers will probably experience too much pressure, however.
Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs
Heavyweight back sleepers who weigh less than 300 pounds might find that the Big Fig feels too firm, while folks who weigh more than that should enjoy spinal support with a touch of pressure relief. Heavyweight side sleepers will almost certainly find that the Big Fig feels too firm. Heavyweight stomach sleepers should find the Big Fig to be a great match; it’s very supportive and promotes neutral spinal alignment in this position.
Heavyweight back sleepers should enjoy a blend of spinal support and pressure relief on the Saatva HD. Heavyweight side sleepers who weigh more than 300 pounds should enjoy plenty of pressure relief, while folks who weigh less than that might experience just a bit of pressure around the shoulder and hip. Heavyweight stomach sleepers could obtain adequate support, but they might want to consider the even more supportive Big Fig.
See our best mattresses for heavy people for more like the Big Fig and Saatva HD.
Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs
Lightweight sleepers of all stripes (back, side, and stomach) will almost certainly find that the Big Fig feels much too firm in all positions. They simply won’t press into the mattress to obtain any pressure relief.
While the Saatva HD is a bit plusher than the Big Fig, it’s still not the best match for lightweight sleepers. Lightweight back and side sleepers will most likely find that the mattress feels much too firm. Lightweight stomach sleepers who like an extra-firm feel might do okay here.
Mattress Construction Differences
Just as it’s important to know what the surface of a bed feels like, it’s also critical to know what lies beneath that surface. Let’s peel back the covers on these beds and take a close look at their constructions. We’ll also consider how different materials affect each bed’s feel and performance.
The Big Fig’s cover consists of 1” of quilted ThermoGel foam to provide cooling, softness, and just a hint of pressure relief.
The Saatva HD features a cover that’s made from organic cotton and is tufted and quilted with 3” of comfort foam. This Euro-top lends a plusher feel to the top of the mattress. The cover also contains Guardin, a fabric treatment that is antimicrobial.
The first comfort layer on the Big Fig is made from ½” of a gel-infused latex foam, which is bouncy, responsive, durable, and breathable. This is followed by three, 1” layers of polyfoam that serve as transition layers between the comfort and support sections of the mattress. These foams are also very bouncy and responsive. See our best latex mattresses to learn more.
The Saatva HD’s first comfort layer is made from ventilated, zoned Talalay latex, which is bouncy, responsive, and naturally breathable. Below the latex, there’s a layer of memory foam, which helps explain why the Saatva HD offers more pressure relief than the Big Fig. Finally, there’s a layer of support foam that serves as a transition from the comfort layers to the steel coils underneath.
The Big Fig’s primary support layer is made from 7” of individually wrapped coils, which are very supportive and durable and allow for plenty of airflow throughout the center of the mattress. The coils’ perimeter is reinforced to enhance the bed’s edge support. Underneath the coils, there’s a 1.5” layer of high-density polyfoam that provides overall structure for the mattress.
The support layer on the Saatva HD is made from 12.5 gauge tempered steel coils, which are highly supportive and durable.
The Big Fig is 13” tall, while the Saatva HD is taller at 15.5”.
Big Fig And Saatva HD Size Options And Price
Curious about the size and pricing info for the Big Fig and/or the Saatva HD mattress? Then take a peek at the chart below! We’ve put together the most up-to-date information for each of these mattresses.
|Twin||39 ” x 75″ x 13″||$1,299|
|Twin XL||39″ x 80″ x 13″||$1,399|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 13″||$1,499|
|Queen||60” x 80” x 13”||$1,699|
|King||76” x 80” x 13”||$1,999|
|California King||72” x 84” x 13”||$1,999|
|Twin||38″ x 75″ x 15.5″||$1,574|
|Twin XL||38″ x 80″ x 15.5″||$1,687|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 15.5″||$2,074|
|Queen||60” x 80” x 15.5”||$2,674|
|King||76” x 80” x 15.5”||$2,974|
|Split King||76” x 80” x 15.5”||$3,374|
|California King||72” x 84” x 15.5”||$2,974|
Make sure to check out our Saatva coupons for the best deal.
Big Fig And Saatva HD Performance Differences
So now you know about the construction, firmness, and feel on both the Big Fig and the Saatva HD. Next up? We tested each of these mattresses to assess their performance with regard to temperature regulation, motion transfer, edge support, and more!
Sleeping Hot Or Cold
While both of these beds should do a decent job of sleeping cool, the Big Fig should be the best choice for hot sleepers. In addition to ventilated latex foam and airflow-promoting coils, the mattress also features gel in the latex layer and Thermogel in the cover. The Big Fig should be the better mattress for hot sleepers.
In our experience, the Saatva HD performs a bit better than the Big Fig when it comes to motion transfer. The plusher comfort layers and the layer of memory foam help the Saatva HD absorb movement and minimize disturbances. Because the Big Fig doesn’t have as much “give,” it doesn’t do quite as good a job at cutting down on motion transfer. If you want the best mattress for couples, consider the Saatva HD.
Both the Big Fig and the Saatva HD feature great edge support. These are both supportive mattresses, and that holds true all the way to their edges. We felt very secure while sitting and lying down near the edges of both mattresses.
These are both highly durable, supportive mattresses. That said, the Saatva HD should be the longer-lasting mattress. It uses higher-end materials that are likely to last for a long time. For more like the Big Fig and Saatva HD, check out our best mattresses that won’t sag.
It’s possible you might notice some off-gassing from both of these mattresses. That should dissipate within a few days.
At the time of our review, we didn’t observe any notable noise from either of these beds. However, note that each of these mattresses incorporates coils. It’s possible the coils could start to squeak a bit over the long-term.
A sound mattress for sex enables partners to change positions easily. Because the Big Fig and the Saatva HD are both responsive mattresses, either one should be a great choice. Sexual partners shouldn’t feel stuck in either of these beds.
If you choose to purchase the Big Fig or the Saatva HD mattress, here’s a quick look at the company policies that you’ll encounter.
The Big Fig mattress comes with a 20-year limited warranty. You can read the full terms of the warranty on the Big Fig site.
The Saatva HD comes with a 20-year, non-prorated warranty. For the first two years after purchase, the brand will replace the mattress at no charge if it’s found to be defective. Between years 3 and 20, the company will repair and re-cover the mattress for a transportation cost of $99 each way. Learn more on Saatva’s site.
The Big Fig comes with a 120-night sleep trial.
The Saatva HD comes with an extra-long 180-night sleep trial.
If you test out a Big Fig mattress and find that it’s not to your liking, you can return the bed free of charge so long as it’s within the 120-night trial period. To initiate the return process, call or email the brand’s customer service team at 888-344-6547 or [email protected] The brand asks that people try out the mattress for at least two weeks before requesting a return.
If you are not satisfied with the Saatva HD mattress, you can return the mattress at any point during the 180-night trial for a single charge of $99. The Saatva brand will coordinate pick-up of the returned mattress and will donate it to a veterans’ shelter or offer it to company employees or associates.
Now, we’d like to answer some frequently asked questions about the Big Fig and Saatva HD mattresses.
Which is better, the Big Fig or the Saatva HD?
We wouldn’t say one mattress is better than the other. It’s more about what you are looking for in particular. The Big Fig should be better if you are a stomach sleeper and want something more affordable. The Saatva HD will work better if you are a side sleeper or want something more luxurious.
How long will the Big Fig and Saatva mattresses last?
The Big Fig and Saatva are both mattresses made with heavier people in mind. They are extremely durable and should last for at least 10 years each.
Can you flip the Big Fig and Saatva mattresses?
No, you cannot flip the Big Fig and Saatva mattresses. They are only designed to rest with the base layer on the bottom and comfort layer on top.