In this post, I’ll compare the hybrid model from Walmart’s new mattress brand, Allswell, and the original all-foam model from Purple. These mattresses have different feels and price points but also some similarities. I’ll address these similarities and differences below in this Allswell vs. Purple mattress comparison.
Allswell Vs Purple Overview
As Walmart’s bed-in-a-box brand, Allswell is an affordable and high-quality option. There are several models available, including the Allswell Luxe and Allswell Supreme. In this mattress comparison, we’ll be taking a looking at their baseline model.
Known for its proprietary gel grid, The Purple is a unique online mattress brand. It feels both squishy and firm at the same time, and it provides a good balance of comfort and support.
But which bed-in-a-box mattress is the right one for you? Below, we’ve outlined who might prefer each brand.
Who Should Get The Allswell?
- People who like a classic memory foam feel
- Stomach sleepers
Who Should Get The Purple Mattress?
- Hot sleepers
- Side sleepers
Similarities Between The Allswell And Purple?
The Allswell and Purple mattresses look very different at first glance, but they do share some similarities.
- Both have responsive surfaces.
- Both are suitable for side sleepers.
- Both offer 100-day trials and offer free shipping.
Read our full Allswell mattress review.
Key Differences Between The Allswell And Purple?
Now, let’s dive into the distinct differences between the Allswell and Purple mattresses.
- Purple is more expensive.
- Allswell is more of a budget option.
- Purple uses a unique, hyper-elastic foam as its top layer.
- Purple uses materials that are more temperature-neutral.
- Allswell has a quilted top and contains memory foam.
- Allswell is thicker overall.
- Allswell uses CertiPUR-US certified foams, which means its materials are considered more eco-friendly than typical mattress materials.
- Allswell has more of a traditional memory foam feel, especially when compared to the Purple.
Read our Purple mattress review.
Firmness and Feel Differences
When comparing mattresses, we always take a close look at firmness and feel. Let’s see who the Allswell and Purple mattresses may be best for!
How Firm Are The Allswell And Purple Mattresses?
The Allswell mattress is on the firmer side, coming in at a 7.5/10. It has soft foam layers and strong coils underneath. Overall, it should give sleepers a good balance of comfort and support.
The Purple mattress feels like a 6.5/10, or medium firm. The gel grid collapses when you lay on it, but stays upright everywhere else.
Sleeping On the Allswell And Purple Mattresses
The Allswell is a very supportive mattress, but it does have a nice layer of plush comfort on top. Because of this, it’s a great pick for back sleepers. People who prefer this sleeping position should feel a great balance of comfort and support.
Side sleepers, however, may find this mattress doesn’t provide enough pressure relief. In this sleeping position, people may feel additional pain along shoulders and hips. For stomach sleepers, the Allswell is a fantastic choice. Its firm feel will help keep the body in alignment throughout the night.
The Purple is also a great match for back sleepers. The gel grid provides ample support for the lumbar area. It’s also a great pick for most side sleepers. In this position, people should feel a good amount of pressure relief along shoulders and hips.
Stomach sleepers also should find the Purple is very comfortable. The mattress helps to prevent hips from sinking out of alignment, so it should feel very comfortable for the spine.
What Do The Allswell And Purple Mattresses Feel Like?
The Allswell mattress has an innerspring feel, even though the top layers are made of foam. People will feel themselves lying on top of the mattress, rather than inside of it.
The Purple mattress has a truly unique feel that’s both squishy and firm. The brand’s hyper-elastic gel polymer grid collapses when pressure is applied and stays upright everywhere else.
Average Weight Sleepers – 130lbs – 230lbs
On the Allswell, average weight back sleepers should feel comfortable and supported. The supportive coils at the bottom, combined with the comfort layer on top, gives this mattress a balanced feel. Average weight side sleepers, however, may feel a bit of strain along their shoulders and hips. The top comfort layer is on the thin side, so it may not provide the right amount of pressure relief. Stomach sleepers in this category should feel quite comfortable on the Allswell. This bed is slightly firm, so it should help sleepers keep their bodies in alignment in this sleeping position.
The Purple is one of the best mattresses for back sleepers, especially for people of an average weight. The gel grid collapses under the lumbar area and provides plenty of support everywhere else. Average weight side sleepers should also find the Purple mattress is a good match. People in this weight range will be able to activate the gel grid and feel its support underneath them. Even average weight stomach sleepers should feel well supported on the Purple mattress. This mattress is firm enough to keep the body in alignment, and comfortable enough to provide pressure relief.
Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs
Heavier back sleepers should find the Allswell is a great match. The coils at the bottom are strong enough to support the lower back, and the comfort layers should cushion the body. Heavier side sleepers, however, may find the Allswell isn’t soft enough. Many people could feel significant pressure along shoulders and hips. Because it’s a firmer mattress, the Allswell is a good pick for heavier stomach sleepers.
The Purple mattress is a great pick for heavier sleepers, no matter the sleeping position. Back sleepers should feel the supportive gel grid surround their lower backs, and side sleepers should feel a good balance of comfort and support. Stomach sleepers will find the Purple is firm enough to promote the proper spinal alignment. However, those who weigh more than 300lbs may find this mattress isn’t quite supportive enough. People in this weight range will want to check out the best mattresses for heavy people.
Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs
The Allswell is a great pick for lightweight back sleepers. People who weigh less than 130lbs should feel the pressure relief from the comfort layers and support from the coils. The Allswell isn’t a great pick for lighter side sleepers, though. People in this category will most likely feel a bit of pressure along their shoulders and hips. For lightweight stomach sleepers, the Allswell is a great pick. The mattress’ firm construction makes it supportive enough for this sleeping position.
In general, lightweight sleepers may feel the Purple mattress feels too firm. People who weigh less than 130lbs won’t press into the gel grid very far, so they won’t feel the same pressure relief that heavier people get. Because of this, it’s not a great pick for lighter back and side sleepers. Lightweight stomach sleepers, however, should find the bed is a great fit.
Mattress Construction Differences
When comparing online mattresses, we always look closely at what they’re made out of. Let’s check out the Allswell and Purple’s construction!
The Allswell mattress has a quilted cover with a touch of foam sewn in. This results in a soft surface that relieves pressure.
The Purple mattress has a SoftFlex cover that’s thin, breathable, and stretchy. Because it can easily move with the gel grid, it doesn’t get in the way of the mattress’ comfort features.
The Allswell’s comfort layer is made with open-celled memory foam. This material is infused with copper and charcoal gel, which is meant to aid in cooling. Although the foam layer offers pressure relief, it’s a bit thinner than what you’ll find on other mattresses.
In the Purple’s first comfort layer, you’ll find 2″ of their proprietary gel grid. Made of hyper-elastic polymer, this material feels both squishy and firm at the same time. The mattress has a foam encasement around the sides, which helps with edge support. Under the gel grid sits a layer of responsive foam for extra pressure relief.
In Allswell’s support layer, you’ll find individually-wrapped coils. In addition to providing support, these coils help eliminate motion transfer.
The Purple’s support layer is made out of firm and supportive foam.
The Allswell is 10″ tall.
The Purple mattress is 9.5″ tall.
Allswell And Purple Mattress Size Options and Price
Curious about size options and price? Check out our charts below!
|Twin||38.5 ” x 74.5″ x 10″||$265|
|Twin XL||38.5″ x 79.5″ x 10″||$295|
|Full||54″ x 74.5″ x 10″||$345|
|Queen||60” x 79.5” x 10”||$375|
|King||75.5” x 79.5” x 10”||$465|
|California King||72” x 84” x 10”||$465|
|Twin||38″ x 75″ x 9.25″||$599|
|Twin XL||38″ x 80″ x 9.25″||$799|
|Full||54″ x 76″ x 9.25″||$999|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 9.25″||$1,149|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 9.25″||$1,449|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 9.25″||$1,449|
|Split King||76″ x 80″ x 9.25″||$1,598|
Allswell And Purple Performance Differences
Now, let’s see how the Allswell and Purple mattresses stack up when it comes to motion transfer, edge support, durability, and more.
Sleeping Hot or Cold
Overall, the Allswell is a good pick for hot sleepers. The charcoal and copper-infused memory foam helps dissipate heat, and the coils promote airflow.
The Purple has a temperature-neutral surface, so it’s great for people who tend to sleep hot at night. Additionally, the stretchy cover and gel grid creates plenty of airflow.
Motion transfer is an important element to consider when shopping for a new mattress, especially for couples. If your partner shifts sleeping positions in the middle of the night, will you feel it on your side of the bed?
Because of the coils in the support layer, the Allswell mattress doesn’t isolate motion very well. The memory foam comfort layer helps to cut down on motion transfer a bit, but you’ll likely still feel some movement on the opposite side of the bed.
The Purple has a bouncy and responsive feel, so it’s not great at isolating motion. If motion transfer is especially important, we recommend looking at the best mattresses for couples.
If you share a bed with a partner, or just like to sleep near the edge of the bed, you should also make sure your mattress has good edge support.
The Allswell has excellent edge support. When sitting along the side, the strong coils prevent the mattress from collapsing too much. When you lie near the edge, you should feel very secure and supported.
Because of the Purple’s foam encasement around the sides, the mattress has good edge support. When sitting or lying near the edge, most people shouldn’t feel like they will roll off.
The Allswell mattress is made with high-quality materials, but it has a simpler construction. Because of this, we expect this mattress to last between 7 and 10 years.
The Purple’s gel polymer grid should give the mattress a long lifespan. We expect it to last at least 10 years.
When opening a new bed-in-a-box mattress, it’s common to notice a chemical smell. Both the Purple and Allswell mattresses had a bit of off-gassing, but the odor completely faded after 48 hours.
The Allswell is a very quiet mattress. It’s possible the coils could squeak over time, but we do not anticipate this becoming a noisy bed.
Sleepers also shouldn’t notice any noise coming from the Purple mattress.
Couples looking for the best mattresses for sex typically want a bed that’s responsive and easy to move around on.
Because of the Allswell’s springy coils, it’s very easy to shift positions on this bed. Also, the surface is very responsive. Because of this, the Allswell mattress should be a good pick for those wanting to get intimate.
The Purple has a bouncy and responsive feel, so it’s a great mattress for sex.
We always recommend shoppers thoroughly read the fine print before purchasing a brand new mattress. Below, you’ll find information about Allswell and Purple’s warranties, sleep trials, and return policies.
The Allswell mattress is backed by a 10-year limited warranty.
The Purple has a 10-year warranty.
Both the Allswell and Purple mattresses have a 100-night sleep trial period.
If you aren’t happy with your Allswell or Purple mattress within the 100-night sleep trial, you can return it for a full refund.
If you want to learn more about these two mattresses, check out our answers to the most frequently asked questions.
Which mattress is better, Allswell or Purple?
The answer to this question really depends on what you’re looking for. Allswell is a great pick for stomach sleepers who want to save money. Purple is a better pick for combination sleepers who want a bed with a unique feel.
How long will the Allswell and Purple mattresses last?
We expect the Allswell to last 7-10 years, and we think the Purple will last at least 10 years.
Can you flip Allswell and Purple mattresses?
No, you cannot flip an Allswell or Purple mattress. These beds are designed with support layers on the bottom and comfort layers on top, so flipping them just wouldn’t work.
Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.
He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 250 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 5 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.
Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.