Best Innerspring Mattress (2026)

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site. See our disclosure page for more information.

If your childhood bed had a bouncy feel and maybe a little creaking when you climbed in, youโ€™re familiar with the classic innerspring mattress. Known for its signature bounce and excellent support, the coil-based innerspring has been around for decades. 

Todayโ€™s innerspring mattresses have a lot of modern upgrades that translate to improved motion isolation, edge support, and durability. But with most brands offering at least one innerspring model, how can you choose the best mattress for your sleep needs? The Mattress Clarity team is here to help. We did the testing to pinpoint the best innerspring mattresses on the market today.

Our team has tested over 500 mattresses in our sleep lab and helped more than 40,000 people find the bed of their dreams. That means weโ€™ve done a lot of research on all kinds of mattresses, including memory foam mattresses, hybrid mattresses, and innersprings. We used the collective experience of our team of certified sleep science coaches and sleep experts to find the innerspring models that stand far above the rest of the pack.

One quick noteโ€”most of todayโ€™s innersprings technically qualify as hybrids because they include more generous layers of foam than this bed type used to have. But rest assured, all of the picks on our list have that classic innerspring bounce. 

And while traditional innerspring mattresses provide firmer support and arenโ€™t known for their motion isolation, improvements in materials mean modern innersprings offer more firmness options and upgraded performance than ever. If youโ€™re interested in a classically bouncy bed that doesnโ€™t skimp on comfort, youโ€™re in the right place.

Clarityโ€™s Clear Winner

The Helix Dusk Luxe earned our pick as the best innerspring mattress. During testing, it impressed us with its outstanding responsiveness and edge support, performance features we prioritized as indicators of an excellent innerspring mattress.

The Best Innerspring Mattresses

Top Deals

Several of our top picks are currently available at a discount. See the details below to save on your next mattress.

How We Tested and Selected the Mattresses

The best innerspring mattresses have an excellent balance of support from the coils and cushioning from comfort layers. Itโ€™s a combination that helps evenly distribute body weight across the sleep surface so that certain parts of the body donโ€™t bear too much force, which can lead to pressure points and pain as the night goes on.

Our testers use both subjective and objective tests to evaluate pressure relief on both their sides and their backs. Every bed on this list earned an above-average score for pressure relief, with two exceptions that impressed us in other ways. One is an extra-firm flippable model and the other comes in a choice of different firmness levels, including a softer option for upgraded pressure relief.

Generating pressure maps of the Saatva Solaire Mattress

In an innerspring mattress, edge support affects comfort and durability alike. We looked for models that have strong edges, which helps prevent premature sagging and means more room to comfortably spread out. All of the mattresses we recommend here showed above-average support and overall quality materials during our tests.

To earn a high rating for edge support, the bed must perform well when our testers are both seated and lying down at the perimeter of the bed. It may also excel in our weighted test, where weight plates are stacked at the edge of the bed to see how far the bed sinks with different-sized bodies.

Measuring the sinkage from weight plates along the edge of the Saatva Loom & Leaf Mattress

People are generally drawn to innerspring mattresses because of their bounce, so we prioritized quick response times as we assembled this list. Most of the models earned full marks for response, and those that didnโ€™t still offered plenty of spring.

A responsive mattress is easy for our testers to move around on. It snaps back into place quickly when you press down on it. This means you shouldnโ€™t feel โ€œstuckโ€ in the mattress.

Nectar Luxe Memory Foam Switch Test 2

Our team of Certified Sleep Science Coaches selected the best innerspring beds by looking for top performers in the categories above: spinal support, pressure relief, edge support, and responsiveness.

But our full process involves testing several aspects of a bedโ€™s performance, including cooling, motion isolation, and more. We evaluate and score these factors using specialized technology as well as firsthand accounts of how a bed feels to testers with different body types.

An infographic showing how different performance categories are weighted when calculating an overall score for a bed on Mattress Clarity. The bed is split into 6 bars to show the relative percentages of each category.

Once we have all those scores, we calculate the bedโ€™s overall score using a weighted formula. This overall score is a good indicator of a mattressโ€™s general quality, and is always a number out of 5.

As we decide which mattresses to feature on any roundup, we only include beds with an overall score of 3.5 out of 5 or higher. Even if a mattress does certain things well, we wonโ€™t point you towards it if it falls below this baseline.

Learn more about how we test mattresses at Mattress Clarity.

  • 500+ mattresses tested in person
  • 30+ data points collected for each bed
  • Certified Sleep Science Coaches on staff
  • Expert input from our Chief Medical Product Tester Dr. Hannah Habeeb (DPT)
  • 43,000+ readers who bought a new bed based on our recommendations

Learn more about Mattress Clarity.

Mel and Livvi pose for photos with the Nectar Luxe Memory Foam Mattress

Need help finding the right mattress?

Compare the Best Innerspring Mattresses

Helix Dusk Luxe MattressNectar Classic HybridWinkBed MattressSaatva ClassicBrooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe MattressNolah Evolution Hybrid MattressBrooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe Mattress
Helix Dusk Luxe MattressNectar Classic HybridWinkBed MattressSaatva ClassicBrooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe MattressNolah Evolution Hybrid MattressBrooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe Mattress
Rating
4.7
4.3
4.1
4.6
4.4
4.6
4.4
FirmnessMedium-Firm: 6.5/10Soft: 5.5/10Multiple Firmness OptionsMultiple Firmness OptionsMedium-Firm: 7/10Multiple Firmness OptionsMultiple Firmness Options
MaterialHybridHybridHybridInnerspringHybridHybridHybrid
Coolingโ€”โ€”โ€”โ€”โ€”
Best For
Side Sleepers,
Back Sleepers,
Stomach Sleepers
Side Sleepers,
Back Sleepers,
Stomach Sleepers
Side Sleepers,
Back Sleepers,
Stomach Sleepers
Back Sleepers,
Stomach Sleepers,
Hot Sleepers
Back Sleepers,
Stomach Sleepers,
Hot Sleepers
Side Sleepers,
Back Sleepers,
Hip Pain
Side Sleepers,
Back Sleepers,
Stomach Sleepers

Our Best Innerspring Mattresses Video Review

Read about our testing experience with each of the beds on our list below.

Helix Dusk Luxe โ€“ Best Innerspring Mattress Overall

Best Overall
Mattress Clarity Score
We rate each mattress on a scale from 1 to 5 to reflect its overall quality. This number is comprised of individual scores from hands-on testing of materials, firmness, pressure relief, motion transfer, cooling, responsiveness, and more.
4.7
Helix
Helix Dusk Luxe
Medium-Firm Feel
Lumbar Support
Pressure Relief
Mattress Clarity Deal
27% Off Sitewide with Code CLARITY27 See Details
Brand Icon 31
Material
The Helix Dusk Luxe is a hybrid mattress. This means it has both cushioning foam and supportive coil layers.
Brand Icon 14
Firmness
being the softest, we rated the Medium model a 6.5/10, which is the industry standard for medium-firm.
Brand Icon 42
Price
$1,373-$2,873 (before discounts)
Brand Icon 13
Size
Twin, twin XL, full, queen, short queen, king, California king, RV king
Brand Icon
Side Sleepers
This mattress should offer plenty of pressure relief for side sleepers.
Brand Icon 11
Hot Sleepers
This bed shouldnโ€™t trap heat thanks to the coils. You can also opt for a cooling cover.
Brand Icon 10
Heavyweight Sleepers
This mattress has a thick comfort layer and sturdy coils that can handle heavier weights.
Pros of the Helix Dusk Luxe
This is an upgraded version of the Helix Dusk. It offers a thicker comfort layer which can offer more pressure relief for side sleepers.
The coils are zoned, meaning itโ€™s firmer in the center to offer more lumbar support for back sleepers.
The medium-firm feel to this mattress makes it a great choice for a variety of body types.
Cons of the Helix Dusk Luxe
Because this is a luxury version of the base model, it might not fit everyoneโ€™s budget.
This mattress is too soft to offer support for stomach sleepers.
Brand Icon 39
Shipping
Free shipping
Brand Icon 40
Trial Period
100 nights
Brand Icon 41
Warranty
15-year warranty
Brand Icon 38
Returns
Free refunds during the trial period.

If you like the sound of the Helix Dusk, but want a more luxurious version, the Helix Dusk Luxe is the perfect upgrade. Itโ€™s a bit softer than the base model, and has a few more features to elevate your sleep. The coils are zoned for extra lumbar support, and the comfort foam is thicker for some added pressure relief.

Testing Highlights

  • Pressure relief. The mattress ended up with 4/5 stars for its pressure relief, an average score based on feedback from three testers of different weight ranges.
  • Cooling. The Helix Dusk Luxe also earned an impressive 5/5 rating for its temperature regulation.
  • Responsiveness. This bedโ€™s springy feel received another perfect score for responsiveness.

Why the Helix Dusk Luxe is the Best Innerspring Bed Overall

The Helix Dusk Luxe earned high marks across the board, with an overall score of 4.7/5 stars. But it earned our nod for best innerspring mattress overall because it really delivered on the classic innerspring experience and scored very high in responsiveness, edge support, and pressure relief.

Helix mattresses are designed to accommodate the needs of specific sleep styles. The Helix Dusk Luxe is geared toward stomach and back sleepers with what the brand calls a medium firmness, but our mattress tester found it a little firmer than average. She rated it a 7/10 in all positions and preferred it more on her stomach than on her back, though back sleepers who prefer a firmer feel may find it quite comfortable.

Get the full story on this high-quality mattress in our Helix Dusk Luxe mattress review.  

What Our Tester Says

I love this on my back! Itโ€™s the perfect combo of plush and contouring, with excellent support. It fills in the gap on my lower back nicely, and my shoulders feel fantastic. I donโ€™t feel my body dipping anywhere or more than another area.

Sosha Lewis, Certified Sleep Science Coach
Construction of the Helix Dusk Luxe Mattress

Firmness: 8/10

The Helix Dusk Luxe has a firm feel.

Pressure Relief: 4/5

Pressure Relief: 4/5

Average. Back sleepers will like the Dusk Luxeโ€™s firmer feel.

Measuring weight plates on the edge of a Helix Dusk Luxe Mattress

Edge Support: 4.6/5

Above-average. You should be able to rest on the far reaches of the Helix Dusk Luxe.

A woman looks over her shoulder at a glass of water while sitting on a Helix Dusk Luxe Mattress

Cooling: 5/5

Exceptional. The Helix Dusk Luxe feels cool to the touch.

Partner test on the Helix Dusk Luxe Mattress

Motion Isolation: 4/5

Average. Our testersโ€™ could feel a little bit of their partnerโ€™s movements on this bed.

Front view of the Helix Dusk Luxe Mattress

Response: 5/5

Exceptional. You should be able to move around easily on the surface of this mattress.

Who Might Like the Helix Dusk Luxe

  • Hot sleepers. Our testers thought the bed felt cool throughout testing, which should benefit folks who overheat at night.
  • Combination sleepers. Moving around on the Dusk Luxe is easy, so these folks should be able to change positions on the surface with ease.
  • Most back sleepers. The Helix Dusk Luxeโ€™s slightly firmer feel was a bit of a hit for our lightweight and average-weight testers when they rested on their back. 

Who Might Not Like the Helix Dusk Luxe

  • Budget shoppers. The Dusk Luxe is on the higher end of the price spectrum, with a queen-size mattress retailing for close to $2,400 before sales pricing.
  • Side sleepers. For all its strengths, the firmer feel means the Helix Dusk Luxe probably isnโ€™t the best choice for dedicated side sleepers. If you sleep in this position and have sensitive shoulders or hips, I recommend the Nectar Classic Hybrid.

Doctorโ€™s Note

โ€œThe mattress keeps you in a neutral position, but itโ€™s still soft enough to prevent pressure from building on your hips or chest. I think strict stomach sleepers will be able to enjoy this bed without back pain occurring.โ€ โ€“ Dr. Hannah Habeeb, DPT

Other User Reviews

On Helixโ€™s website, the Dusk Luxe mattress has an overall customer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars. Most consumers are satisfied, citing pain relief in the lower back and hips. Others mention that the mattress is softer than expected, which is creating unwanted indents in the surface. 

Nectar Classic Hybrid โ€“ Best Value Innerspring Mattress

Best Value
Mattress Clarity Score
We rate each mattress on a scale from 1 to 5 to reflect its overall quality. This number is comprised of individual scores from hands-on testing of materials, firmness, pressure relief, motion transfer, cooling, responsiveness, and more.
4.3
Nectar
Nectar Classic Hybrid
Medium-Firm Feel
Cooling
Pressure Relief
Summer Spectacular
Save Up to 50% on Mattresses + 66% on Bundles See Details
Brand Icon 28
Material
The Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress is a hybrid mattress mattress.
Brand Icon 14
Firmness
On a scale from 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest, we rated the Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress a 6.5/10, which is the industry standard for medium-firm.
Brand Icon 42
Price
$749-$1,998 (before any discounts)
Brand Icon 13
Size
Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king
Brand Icon 7
Couples
This mattress isolates motion well, which means couples shouldnโ€™t feel movement come over to their side of the bed.
Brand Icon 1
Back Sleepers
The Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress offers plenty of support for most back sleepers under 230 lbs.
Brand Icon 11
Hot Sleepers
The Nectar Classic Hybrid earned a 4 out of 5 during our cooling tests.
Pros of the Nectar Classic Hybrid Mattress
The mattress excels at providing support for back sleepers due to its contouring layers.
The Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress isolates motion well, which is helpful for people who share a bed with a partner or a pet.
Cons of the Nectar Classic Hybrid Mattress
This bed has a medium-firm feel. If youโ€™re used to a firm mattress, this may not be the bed for you.
Itโ€™s not supportive enough if youโ€™re a strict stomach sleepers.
Brand Icon 39
Shipping
Free shipping
Brand Icon 40
Trial Period
365 nights
Brand Icon 41
Warranty
Forever warranty
Brand Icon 38
Returns
Youโ€™ll receive a full refund if you return your mattress within the trial period.

The Nectar Classic Hybrid is an affordable hybird mattress that offers lots of pressure relief and supportive contouring. It works well for most side and back sleepers, because it helps cushion shoulders and hips. However, the Nectar mattress isnโ€™t supportive enough for most stomach sleepers. Watch our full Nectar Classic Hybrid video review.

Testing Highlights

  • Pressure relief. Overall, the mattress earned 4/5 stars for its pressure relief, with testers giving it high marks for both back and side sleeping.
  • Firmness. At a 5.5/10 on our firmness scale, the Classic Hybrid has a softer feel.
  • Cooling. Thanks to the bedโ€™s cooling cover, it earned an impressive 4.5/5 rating for temperature regulation.

Why the Nectar Classic Hybrid is the Best Value Innerspring Bed

The Nectar Classic Hybrid combines memory foam layers with innerspring coils, striking a nice balance of pressure relief and responsiveness โ€” and thatโ€™s hard to do! But the best part might be the price tag. A queen-size mattress retails for under $1,000.

It boasts a soft, surprisingly slow-moving feel up top, while the coils below give the mattress its support. On top of that, the bed features a cool-to-the-touch cover, balancing out the heat-trapping nature of foam. It should be a great pick for fans of memory foam, cooling mattresses, and budget buys.

Learn more in our full Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress review.  

What Our Tester Says

Sleeping on my back is actually really comfortable, which Iโ€™m surprised about after thinking it was a bit too soft on my side. The foams on top really conform to my body, filling in the gap near my lower back and relieving pressure where my shoulders and lower half really start to sink into the bed. I think the coils are doing their work better in this position than on my side. It may be a bit too soft for some, especially if you weigh a bit more.

Livvi DiCicco, Certified Sleep Science Coach
The Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress tag

Firmness: 5.5/10

The Nectar Classic Hybrid has an in between soft and medium feel.

Pressure map results for an average back sleeper on the Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress.

Pressure Relief: 4/5

Average. This bed offers decent pressure relief for both side and back sleepers.

A woman sits on the edge of the Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress.

Edge Support: 3.8/5

Below average. We noticed quite a bit of sinkage when seated on the Nectar Classic Hybridโ€™s perimeter.

Cooling: 4.5/5

Cooling: 4.5/5

Above average. This bedโ€™s cooling cover helps to keep temperatures low.

A man and a women testing couples motion isolation on the Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress.

Motion Isolation: 4/5

Average. Our tester didnโ€™t feel too jostled by their partnerโ€™s movements, but they could feel them.

A woman shows switching positions on the Nectar Classic Hybrid mattress.

Response: 4/5

Below average. The Nectar Classic Hybrid has a softer feel up top, but its coils allow for some ease of movement.

Who Might Like the Nectar Classic Hybrid

  • Side and back sleepers under 230 pounds. These sleepers should benefit most from the Nectar Classic Hybridโ€™s soft upper layers and supportive coils.
  • Sleepers prone to overheating. Despite its heat-trapping nature, the memory foam in this mattress is balanced out by a cooling cover that keeps temperatures low.
  • Couples. The Nectar Classic Hybrid earned good marks for responsiveness, motion isolation, and cooling, all of which should benefit folks who share the bed. 

Who Might Not Like the Nectar Classic Hybrid

  • Sleepers who want strong edge support. We noticed quite a bit of sinkage when seated at the edge of the bed, which could cause problems for folks who use their bed as a second chair.
  • Stomach sleepers. These folks need a firmer surface to keep their hips elevated, preventing lower back pain. 

Doctorโ€™s Note

โ€œOn this mattress, Iโ€™m in a neutral position, and itโ€™s doing a good job supporting my back. Iโ€™m not sinking into an awkward position, and I donโ€™t feel my spine being compressed. For those with back pain, I think the support and pressure relieving aspect will be a great match.โ€ โ€“ Dr. Hannah Habeeb, DPT

Other User Reviews

With thousands of reviews, the Nectar Classic Hybrid has a 4.5-star rating on the brandโ€™s site. Customers praise the bedโ€™s quality for its price. However, many complain that the bedโ€™s edges donโ€™t offer much support, with a few saying the bed has already started to sag on one side.

WinkBed โ€“ Best Innerspring Mattress for Back Sleepers

Best for Back Sleepers
Mattress Clarity Score
We rate each mattress on a scale from 1 to 5 to reflect its overall quality. This number is comprised of individual scores from hands-on testing of materials, firmness, pressure relief, motion transfer, cooling, responsiveness, and more.
4.1
WinkBeds
The WinkBed
Multiple Firmnesses
Zoned Support
Breathable
Summer Sale
30% Off All Mattresses See Details
Brand Icon 31
Material
The WinkBed is a hybrid mattress. This means it has both cushioning foam and supportive coil layers.
Brand Icon 14
Firmness
Multiple firmness options: Softer, Luxury Firm, and Firmer. On a scale from 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest, we rated the Luxury Firm model a 7/10, which is slightly firmer than the industry standard for medium-firm.
Brand Icon 42
Price
$1,149-$2,049 (before any discounts)
Brand Icon 13
Size
Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king
Brand Icon
Side Sleepers
Great pressure relief for side sleepers over 130 lbs.
Brand Icon 1
Back Sleepers
Great support for back sleepers under 230 lbs.
Brand Icon 11
Hot Sleepers
This bedโ€™s cooling features can help keep you from overheating at night.
Pros
It has a bouncy, responsive feel. This is great for combination sleepers who benefit from a bed that makes it easy to change positions at night.
The WinkBed features zoned support. With firmer foam at the top and bottom and more cushioning foam in the middle, this bed has excellent lumbar support.
This bed sleeps cool. Thanks to the breathable coils and gel-infused memory foam, hot sleepers can expect a cool nightโ€™s rest.
Cons
This isnโ€™t the best option for motion isolation.
The WinkBed doesnโ€™t have a traditional โ€œsink-inโ€ memory foam feel.
Brand Icon 39
Shipping
Free shipping
Brand Icon 40
Trial Period
120 nights
Brand Icon 41
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Brand Icon 38
Returns
Youโ€™ll receive a full refund if you return your mattress within the trial period, but after a 30-day โ€œbreak-inโ€ period.

The WinkBed is a versatile mattress that provides zoned support and cooling comfort for a fair price. This bedโ€™s excellent responsiveness makes it a good fit for combination sleeper that want a bed thatโ€™s easy to move around on. For couples looking for motion isolation, though, this probably isnโ€™t the best choice. Instead, check out the Nectar Premier Copper. Learn more in our video review.

Testing Highlights

  • Pressure relief. Our heavy and lightweight sleepers scored the bed full marks in the back sleeping position, and our average-weight sleeper wasnโ€™t far behind with 4/5 stars.
  • Edge support. We found the WinkBedโ€™s perimeter remained sturdy when we were both seated and lying down, earning 4.4 stars in this category.
  • Cooling. The WinkBed remained temperature-neutral throughout testing, which led us to award it a 4/5 score for cooling.

Why the WinkBed is the Best Innerspring Bed for Back Sleepers

The WinkBed has a classic innerspring construction, with its supportive coil layer crowned by a tufted pillow top. The bed comes in four firmness options to accommodate different needs and preferences, and itโ€™s surprisingly well priced given its high-quality construction and materials. You can snag a queen on sale for under $1,800.

We tested the most popular model, the Luxury Firm, and found it true to form at 6.5/10 on the firmness scale. It features robust edge support, strong coils, and breathability that makes it a good pick for hot sleepers who want added support. It earned a 4.7-star rating for back-sleeping pressure relief, specifically. 

Read our full WinkBed mattress review for more details.

What Our Tester Says

The WinkBed has a very interesting feelโ€”the pillow top is lovely and plush, but you can feel an extremely sturdy and dense base underneath it. On my back, I wasnโ€™t sinking as much, so I got the full plushness of the pillow top from head to toe, plus a reassuring sense of stability from the base of the bed.

Melanie Kassel, Certified Sleep Science Coach
Our testers cut open the Winkbed to evaluate the materials to ensure they meet manufacturer's specs.

Firmness: 6.5/10

The Luxury Firm model of the WinkBed has a true medium-firm feel.

Pressure map imagery from a lightweight back sleeper on The WinkBed

Pressure Relief: 3.8/5

Below average. Back sleepers gleaned the most pressure relief on the WinkBed.

A man sits on the edge of the WinkBed mattress and measures how much the border sinks

Edge Support: 4.4/5

Above average. We only noticed some minor sinkage when seated on the edge of the mattress.

The WinkBed cooling test being done with the temperature gun

Cooling: 4/5

Average. As we used our thermal gun to record the bedโ€™s surface temperature, we could see the number going down, even after someone lay on it for seven minutes.

Tester performing the ripple test on The Winkbed luxury firm model

Motion Isolation: 3.7/5

Below average. The WinkBed has just-alright motion isolation, as we could feel our partnerโ€™s movements. However, they werenโ€™t too egregious.

Tester tries out The WinkBed in the stomach sleeping position

Response: 3/5

Below average. The WinkBedโ€™s thick pillow top impeded our ability to seamlessly move around on the bedโ€™s surface.

Who Might Like the WinkBed

  • Heavyweight sleepers. Though the Luxury Firm and Firm models of the WinkBed should easily accommodate sleepers over 230 pounds, thereโ€™s even a WinkBed Plus model specifically designed for these sleepers.
  • Older adults. The WinkBedโ€™s sturdy perimeter makes it easier for seniors and those with mobility concerns to transfer in and out of bed.
  • Hot sleepers. When we performed our cooling test, we could see the temperature going down as we took our second thermal gun readingโ€”this means the WinkBed should help dissipate excess heat as you lie on it.

Who Might Not Like the WinkBed

  • Most lightweight sleepers. Those who weigh less than 130 pounds, especially those who rest on their side, may want to opt for the softer model of the WinkBed or another mattress that better suits their needs. 
  • Combination sleepers. Despite its coils, we didnโ€™t find the WinkBed very responsive, which means you might feel โ€œstuckโ€ in its cushy pillow top as you attempt to move around. 

Doctorโ€™s Note

โ€œI think back sleepers can enjoy this mattress, especially if they prefer a firmer feel. It provides a lot of support and lift, placing the spine in neutral alignment. Since the spine remains neutral, thereโ€™s not too much sinkage anywhere along the body. Someone with back pain (degenerative disc disease especially) will find lots of support to prevent pain. Anyone who gets flares from lifting can also find relief from muscle spasms.โ€ โ€“ Dr. Hannah Habeeb, DPT

Other User Reviews

Out of over 8,000 reviews, the WinkBed earned a 4.8-star rating from customers. A few customers complain that the mattress was too firm or soft for their preferences. But the majority of reviews are positive, with many couples praising the bedโ€™s edge support and responsiveness, specifically.

Saatva Classic โ€“ Best Innerspring Mattress for Back Pain

Best for Back Pain
Mattress Clarity Score
We rate each mattress on a scale from 1 to 5 to reflect its overall quality. This number is comprised of individual scores from hands-on testing of materials, firmness, pressure relief, motion transfer, cooling, responsiveness, and more.
4.6
Saatva
Saatva Classic
Multiplem Firmnesses
Durable
Responsive
Special Offer
$300 Off Orders of $1,000 or More See Details
Brand Icon 31
Material
The Saatva is a hybrid mattress. This means it has both cushioning foam and supportive coil layers.
Brand Icon 14
Firmness
Multiple firmness options: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. On a scale from 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest, we rated the Luxury Firm model a 7/10, which is a bit firmer than average.
Brand Icon 42
Price
$1,295-$2,790 (before any discounts)
Brand Icon 13
Size
Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king, split king, split California king
Brand Icon 2
Stomach Sleepers
Supportive enough for stomach sleepers under 230 lbs.
Brand Icon 1
Back Sleepers
Great support for back sleepers under 300 lbs.
Brand Icon 11
Hot Sleepers
This bedโ€™s cooling features can help keep you from overheating at night.
Pros
The Saatva mattress is a great option for combination sleepers. It is available in multiple firmness options, but the Luxury Firm model works well for multiple sleeping positions.
The Luxury Firm model of the Saatva will work well for most back sleepers. Its balance of comfort and support and zoned construction ensure youโ€™ll sleep in good neutral alignment.
Shoppers looking for a long-lasting mattress will love the Saatva. It feature high-density foam and durable coils that should ensure it lasts for over 10 years.
Cons
If you like the feel of a memory foam mattress, youโ€™re not going to love the feel of the Saatva.
Lightweight side sleepers might not get the best pressure relief, even on the softest Saatva model.
Brand Icon 39
Shipping
Free white glove delivery
Brand Icon 40
Trial Period
365 nights
Brand Icon 41
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Brand Icon 38
Returns
Youโ€™ll receive a full refund if you return your mattress within the trial period, but after a 30-day โ€œbreak-inโ€ period. A removal fee of $99 will be deducted from your refund.

The Saatva is a luxurious hybrid innerspring mattress that should be a great long-term investment. It is available in multiple firmness options, so it should work for the majority of sleeping positions, and its Luxury Firm model is one of the best mattresses for back sleepers. However, lightweight side sleepers and fans of memory foam should look elsewhere. Learn more in our video review.

Testing Highlights

  • Edge support. The Saatvaโ€™s perimeter is rock-solid, earning a perfect 5/5 rating in this category.
  • Responsiveness. The bed also received another perfect score for responsiveness, as itโ€™s one of the bounciest beds weโ€™ve tried.
  • Firmness. The Luxury Firm model of the Saatva Classic feels a bit firmer than advertised at 7.5/10 on our scale.

Why the Saatva Classic is the Best Innerspring Mattress for Back Pain

Innerspring mattresses can be a good choice for people who regularly navigate back pain because they tend to deliver strong support and a more responsive โ€œliftedโ€ feel. Zoned support is worth prioritizing in a mattress for back pain, and thatโ€™s exactly what youโ€™ll find in the Saatva Classic. Overall, we gave this luxury innerspring 4.6/5 stars, and it earned perfect or nearly perfect marks for pressure relief, responsiveness, and edge support.

The Classic comes in a choice of heights (11.5 inches and 14 inches) and firmness options (Plush Soft, Luxury-Firm, Firm). This way, you can tailor the mattress to your needs and ensure itโ€™s perfect for your back. It also comes with free white glove delivery and a generous 365-night sleep trial.

Learn more in our full Saatva Classic mattress review.

What Our Tester Says

I feel really good. I actually physically felt the pressure relief on my lower back, which is rare. I feel quite aligned in my hips and shoulders. I didnโ€™t feel any pressure on my neck either. I feel well-supported overall.

Our Heavyweight Tester
A cut out innerspring mattress showing its inner layers

Firmness: 7.5/10

The Luxury Firm model of the Saatva Classic feels pretty firm.

A pressure map from an average-weight back sleeper on the Saatva Classic. It's largely blue and low-pressure

Pressure Relief: 4.5/5

Above average. Even with its firmer feel, the Saatva offers great pressure relief.

A woman sitting on the side of the Saatva Classic

Edge Support: 5/5

Exceptional. You can sit and lie down on the edges of the Saatva Classic with minimal sinkage.

A temperature gun aimed at the Saatva Classic

Cooling: 4/5

Average. The Saatva Classic has a comfortable, temperature-neutral feel.

A woman gives the thumbs-up to indicate that she felt movement while testing motion isolation on the Saatva Classic

Motion Isolation: 2.7/5

Below average. We could feel every little movement our fellow testers made on the Saatva.

A woman pushes herself up change sleeping positions on the Saatva Classic

Response: 5/5

Exceptional. Thanks to its two innerspring layers, the Saatva Classic is plenty bouncy.

Who Might Like the Saatva Classic

  • Combination sleepers. Itโ€™s easy to launch yourself across the surface of the Saatva Classic, making it the perfect profile for sleepers who frequently change positions. 
  • Older adults. The Saatvaโ€™s super-sturdy edges donโ€™t budge when you sit on them, which should help these folks transfer out of bed and onto their feet.
  • Fans of a firmer bed. Even the mid-range model of this bed skewed a bit firmer, and its on-top feel means you wonโ€™t sink very far into its pillow top.

Who Might Not Like the Saatva Classic

  • Light sleepers who share the bed. You can feel every little twitch on the Saatva Classic, which will likely disturb folks who sleep alongside a restless partner or pet. 
  • Budget shoppers. As itโ€™s a luxury bed, a queen-size Saatva typically retails for over $2,000, which may be out of some folksโ€™ price range.

Doctorโ€™s Note

โ€œI feel very comfortable on my side. Itโ€™s very plush and adds a lot of contouring at my hips and shoulders. I feel no pressure at my joints, and itโ€™s a good match for these sleepers. It might be a little soft to be a complete cure for back pain, but Iโ€™m still finding enough support to keep my spine mostly aligned. I think it could help depending on your body type.โ€ โ€“ Dr. Hannah Habeeb, DPT

Other User Reviews

After over 6,000 reviews, the Saatva Classic earns a 4.8-star rating from consumers. Reviews praise the bedโ€™s quality and the brandโ€™s above-and-beyond customer service. Those that are negative reference the bed feeling too soft or too firm for individual preferences, even after an exchange.

Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe โ€“ Best Cooling Innerspring Mattress

Best Cooling
Mattress Clarity Score
We rate each mattress on a scale from 1 to 5 to reflect its overall quality. This number is comprised of individual scores from hands-on testing of materials, firmness, pressure relief, motion transfer, cooling, responsiveness, and more.
4.4
Brooklyn Bedding
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
Multiple Firmnesses
Breathable
RV Compatible
Summer Sale
25% Off Sitewide with code SUMMER25 See Details
Brand Icon 31
Material
The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe is a hybrid mattress. This means it has both cushioning foam and supportive coil layers.
Brand Icon 14
Firmness
Multiple firmness options available.
Brand Icon 42
Price
$1,199 โ€“ $2,665 (before discounts)
Brand Icon 13
Size
Twin, twin XL, full, queen, short queen, king, California king, split California king, RV king, RV bunk
Brand Icon 1
Back Sleepers
Great support for back sleepers under 230 lbs.
Brand Icon
Side Sleepers
Great pressure relief for side sleepers over 130 lbs.
Brand Icon 11
Hot Sleepers
This bedโ€™s cooling features can help keep you from overheating at night.
Pros of the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
Available in a large variety of sizes. Whether youโ€™re looking to add this to your bedroom or fit it in your RV, you should be able to find the right size.
This bed performed well on our cooling tests, making it a good fit for hot sleepers.
Cons of the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe
This bed isnโ€™t supportive enough for stomach sleepers.
Heavyweight sleepers who weigh more than 230 lbs wonโ€™t find enough support on this bed.
Brand Icon 39
Shipping
Free shipping
Brand Icon 40
Trial Period
120 nights
Brand Icon 41
Warranty
10-year warranty
Brand Icon 38
Returns
Youโ€™ll receive a full refund if you return your mattress within the trial period, but after a 30-day โ€œbreak-inโ€ period. A removal fee of $99 will be deducted from your refund.

The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe offers a responsive surface great for combination sleepers. Itโ€™s also a good choice for hot sleepers looking for a bed that can keep them cool but thatโ€™s available in a wide array of sizes. Learn more in our video review.

Testing Highlights

  • Cooling. The Aurora Luxe only earned a 3.5/5 in this category on paper, but our tester believed the cover felt cold to the touch and that the bed maintained a comfortable temperature throughout testing.
  • Edge support. Sitting and lying down along the perimeter of the mattress felt secure and steady, so we awarded the Aurora Luxe a 4.6 in this category.
  • Pressure relief. The bed earned a 4.5 for overall pressure relief, thanks to its performance for both back and side sleepers.

Why the Aurora Luxe is the Best Cooling Innerspring Bed

Innerspring mattresses do a better job of promoting airflow than all-foam beds, but the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe goes a step further. It comes standard with a cooling cover that feels crisp and slippery, making it great for hot sleepers. On top of that, it still delivers on responsiveness, edge support, and pressure relief. Overall, we gave the Aurora Luxe 4.4/5 stars.

When seated and lying on the side, we found the Aurora Luxe incredibly stable. This support excelled when it came to resting on our side and back, with fans of the latter position finding the Medium model of this bed a match made in heaven. 

Get more details on this bed in our full Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe mattress review

What Our Tester Says

I enjoyed the cover of the Aurora Luxe a lotโ€”itโ€™s super cooling. Itโ€™s more crisp and cool to the touch. As I lay there, I felt like I was heating up just a tiny bit, but overall my temperature was regulated. I never felt too warm or like I was overheating. 

Our In-House Tester
Firmness: 7/10

Firmness: 7/10

The Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe Cooling has a firmer feel.

The pressure map readings for an average-weight back sleeper on the Aurora Luxe mattress.

Pressure Relief: 4.5/5

Above-average. Back sleepers who love a firmer sleep surface will glean the most pressure relief.

A woman seated on the edge of the Aurora Luxe mattress

Edge Support: 4.6/5

Above average. The edges of the Aurora Luxe felt solid, only dipping slightly when we were seated at the perimeter.

A thermal gun aimed at the surface of the Brooklyn Bedding Aurora Luxe mattress

Cooling: 3.5/5

Below average. The Aurora Luxe feels cool and crisp, but it did hold onto some heat during our temperature test.

A water glass perched on the surface of the Aurora Luxe Cooling while a tester rests on the other side

Motion Isolation: 3.8/5

Average. We felt our fellow testersโ€™ movements when they were closer to our side of the bed.

A woman lies on her side on the Aurora Luxe mattress

Response: 4/5

Average. The Aurora Luxe has decent responsiveness, but itโ€™ll likely require some effort to move around on top of.

Who Might Like the Aurora Luxe

  • Combination sleepers. The Aurora Luxe has a versatile, if slightly firm, feel that can accommodate multiple sleeper types, and itโ€™s responsive enough to make switching positions easy.
  • Dedicated back sleepers. Our testers awarded this position a 5/5 for pressure relief. Regardless of body type, these sleepers should feel comfortably supported and aligned on the Medium or Firm model of the Aurora Luxe.
  • Folks with mobility concerns. The Aurora Luxeโ€™s rock-solid edge support means getting in and out of bed feels secure, while the bed is also responsive enough to help sleepers and caretakers make the transfer.

Who Might Not Like the Aurora Luxe

  • Light sleepers. We thought the Aurora Luxeโ€™s motion absorption was just average; youโ€™ll likely feel some of your partnerโ€™s movements transfer across their side of the bed to yours.
  • Fans of a soft mattress. While the Aurora Luxe relives quite a lot of pressure, we still thought it had a firmer-than-expected feel at 7/10 on our scale.

Doctorโ€™s Note

โ€œI would recommend the Aurora Luxe to people with hip pain. It does a good job dispersing weight around the bony part of your hip. Sleepers with hip arthritis especially could benefit from pressure relief in this area.โ€ โ€“ Dr. Hannah Habeeb, DPT

Other User Reviews

On Brooklyn Beddingโ€™s website, the Aurora Luxe has more than 4,000 reviews, helping it to earn a 4.6-star rating. Customers love the bedโ€™s ability to provide support and relieve pain, but a few note it doesnโ€™t feel as cool as advertised.

Nolah Evolution โ€“ Best Innerspring Mattress for Side Sleepers

Best for Side Sleepers
Mattress Clarity Score
We rate each mattress on a scale from 1 to 5 to reflect its overall quality. This number is comprised of individual scores from hands-on testing of materials, firmness, pressure relief, motion transfer, cooling, responsiveness, and more.
4.6
Nolah
Nolah Evolution
Multiple Firmnesses
Cooling
Motion Isolation
Summer Sale
30% Off Sitewide, Additional $50 Off with Code CLARITY50 See Details
Brand Icon 31
Material
The Nolah Evolution is a hybrid mattress, which means it has coils at the bottom and memory foam on top.
Brand Icon 14
Firmness
Multiple firmness options: Plush, Luxury Firm, and Firm. On a scale from 1 to 10, with 1 being the softest, we rated the Luxury Firm model a 6.5/10, which is the industry standard for medium-firm.
Brand Icon 42
Price
$1,499-$3,198 (before any discounts)
Brand Icon 13
Size
Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king, split king
Brand Icon 1
Back Sleepers
The Nolah Evolution Hybrid offers great lumbar support for most back sleepers under 300 lb.
Brand Icon 11
Hot Sleepers
This bed has graphite-infused foam, which helps dissipate body heat. It also has coils that promote airflow.
Pros of the Nolah Evolution
It has great cooling features, such as graphite-infused foam and airflow-promoting coils.
Even though it has coils, it isolates motion well. This makes it a great mattress for couples.
Itโ€™s available in three firmness levels, so it works for a variety of people.
Cons of the Nolah Evolution
It lacks a slow-moving feel.
Itโ€™s not supportive enough for most people who weigh more than 300 lb.
Because itโ€™s a luxurious mattress, it might be too pricey for some people.
Brand Icon 39
Shipping
Free shipping
Brand Icon 40
Trial Period
120 nights
Brand Icon 41
Warranty
Lifetime warranty
Brand Icon 38
Returns
Youโ€™ll receive a full refund if you return your mattress within the trial period, but after a 30-day โ€œbreak-inโ€ period.

The Nolah Evolution Hybrid mattress is available in three firmness levels. The Luxury Firm model works well for many back and side sleepers. This mattress has many cooling features, and it isolates motion well. Itโ€™s not a great option for most people who weigh over 300 lb, though. If you fall in this category, you may need more lumbar support. Watch our Nolah Evolution mattress review video to learn more.

Testing Highlights

  • Edge support. Despite its softer top layers, the edge support for this mattress is excellent, scoring 4.6/5.
  • Pressure relief. The Luxury Firm model of the Nolah Evolution earned a 4/5 for side-sleeping pressure relief.
  • Motion isolation. The Evolution earned a rare perfect score for motion absorption, thanks to stellar performance in our coupleโ€™s evaluation.

Why the Nolah Evolution is the Best Innerspring Bed for Side Sleepers

Side sleepers need a mattress with a supportive core that prevents excessive sinking, so innersprings are usually a good option. The Nolah Evolution has a zoned support system and contouring foams that work really well for cushioning and pressure relief in the hips and shoulders. Itโ€™s available in three firmness options, and weโ€™d recommend the Luxury-Firm model for most side sleepers.

During testing, we rated this model a true medium-firm, or 6.5/10 on the firmness scale. It worked well in all sleep positions, especially for those who rest on their side. The Evolution earned scores of 4 and 5 from all of our testers when they assessed it on their sides and backs, with an overall pressure relief rating of 4.5/5.  

Learn more in our detailed Nolah Evolution Mattress review.

What Our Tester Says

It feels good overall. Itโ€™s super-plush and contouring due to the pillow-top. I feel some slight pressure in my hip, but nothing that would sway me from this mattress entirely. In my neck and shoulders, the pressure is slight, if any. I feel super-cradled by this mattress. Itโ€™s so soft but supportive at the same time. 

Our In-House Tester
Construction of the Nolah Evolution Mattress

Firmness: 6.5/10

The Luxury Firm Nolah Evolution has a true medium-firm feel.

Back-sleeping pressure map of our average weight tester on the Nolah Evolution mattress.

Pressure Relief: 4.5/5

Above average. Both side and back sleepers should get pressure relief from the Evolution, but the latter will feel much more contouring.

A close look as our tester pushes on the edge of a Nolah Evolution Mattress

Edge Support: 4.6/5

Above average. When sitting on the edge of the Nolah Evolution, the pillow top compressed a bit but otherwise remained stable.

Thermal imaging after sleeping on the Nolah Evolution Mattress

Cooling: 4/5

Average. The Evolution isnโ€™t actively cooling, but it should provide a comfortable temperature-neutral feel.

Our tester performing a motion isolation test with a glass of water on a Nolah Evolution Mattress

Motion Isolation: 5/5

Above average. This mattress has exceptional motion absorption, so you shouldnโ€™t feel any movement from your side of the bed.

Our tester drops a ball from a ladder during a bounce test on the Nolah Evolution Mattress.

Response: 4/5

Below average. The doughy pillow top might slow down some sleepers as they switch positions on the Evolution.

Who Might Like the Nolah Evolution

  • Couples. The Nolah Evolutionโ€™s near-perfect motion isolation, excellent edge support, and relative responsiveness will benefit sleepers who share the bed, especially those who are easily woken by their partnerโ€™s movements.
  • Back sleepers. Alongside side sleepers, these folks should also enjoy the Evolutionโ€”our testers loved how it contoured to the lumbar spine and filled in the gap there.
  • Folks who like to spread out on their bed. If you sleep along the edge of your mattress, itโ€™s unlikely youโ€™ll slide off, as we noticed very little sinkage at the Evolutionโ€™s perimeter.

Who Might Not Like the Nolah Evolution

  • Those after a super-bouncy bed. This mattress isnโ€™t as springy as some of the others on this list. While you wonโ€™t feel โ€œstuckโ€ when moving, we noticed a bit of pushback from the plusher top layers.
  • Budget shoppers. Though we think itโ€™s worth every penny, the Evolution is priced a bit high. A queen-size will run you more than $1,000, even with sales or coupons.

Doctorโ€™s Note

โ€œIโ€™m finding a lot of sinkage on this bed, which is contouring my body really nicely. This is really helpful for relieving pressure at the hips and shoulders. However, Iโ€™m finding enough support to prevent me from sinking too much, and itโ€™s helping promote spinal alignment. I would definitely recommend this to side sleepers.โ€ โ€“ Dr. Hannah Habeeb, DPT

Other User Reviews

On Nolahโ€™s site, the Evolution earned a customer rating of 4.6 stars out of more than 1,000 reviews. Most reviews highlight the bedโ€™s pressure relief and overall comfort. Some said they found the bed softer than expected, with others adding it affected their experience when seated on the edge of the bed. 

Plank Firm Luxe โ€“ Best Firm Innerspring Mattress

Best Firm
Mattress Clarity Score
We rate each mattress on a scale from 1 to 5 to reflect its overall quality. This number is comprised of individual scores from hands-on testing of materials, firmness, pressure relief, motion transfer, cooling, responsiveness, and more.
4.4
Brooklyn Bedding
Plank Firm Luxe
Firm Feel
Flippable
Supportive
Summer Sale
25% Off Sitewide with code SUMMER25 See Details
Brand Icon 31
Material
The Plank Firm Luxe is a hybrid mattress, meaning it contains both coil and foam layers.
Brand Icon 14
Firmness
The Plank Firm Luxe is flippable, offering an 8/10 (firm) firmness on one side and 9/10 (ultra-firm) on the other.
Brand Icon 42
Price
$693-$1,299 (before any discounts)
Brand Icon 13
Size
Twin, twin XL, full, queen, short queen, Olympic queen, king, short king, California king, split California king, RV king
Brand Icon 1
Back Sleepers
Great support for back sleepers under 230 lbs.
Brand Icon 2
Stomach Sleepers
Provides lots of support under hips for stomach sleepers.
Brand Icon 11
Hot Sleepers
This bedโ€™s optional cooling panel can help keep you from overheating at night.
Pros of the Plank Firm Mattress
The mattress is flippable, giving you two different firmness options (firm and extra-firm) in one bed.
You can add a cooling cover to each side for a modest fee.
Cons of the Plank Firm Mattress
It doesnโ€™t offer a slow-moving memory foam feel. Youโ€™ll feel more on-top of the bed, than sunken in.
Side sleepers may not be able to get enough pressure relief, even on the bedโ€™s less firm side.
Brand Icon 39
Shipping
Free shipping except for HI and AK
Brand Icon 40
Trial Period
120 nights
Brand Icon 41
Warranty
10-year warranty
Brand Icon 38
Returns
$99 return fee

The Plank Firm Luxe is a versatile ultra-firm mattress for sleepers who may typically struggle to find a bed that offers the level of firmness they need (heavyweight, stomach, and back sleepers in particular). Moreover, the bedโ€™s dual firmness levels, and cozy, cool, yet durable construction, make the Plank Firm Luxe our favorite firm mattress for back pain.

Testing Highlights

  • Responsiveness. Both sides of the Plank Firm Luxe earned a 4/5 or higher for responsiveness, as its super-firm feel means you wonโ€™t sink into the surface very far.
  • Motion Isolation. For a firm, responsive hybrid, the Plank Firm Luxe also earned high marks for its motion absorption, with the extra-firm side coming in at a 5/5.
  • Cooling. Each side of the mattress earned a 4/5 for cooling; though it didnโ€™t feel icy-cold, our testers thought it remained temperature-neutral throughout testing.

Why the Plank Firm Luxe is the Best Firm Innerspring Bed

Old school innerspring mattresses were mostly coils with very thin comfort layers on top. The Plank Firm Luxe is reminiscent of thatโ€”it has a flippable design with firm and extra-firm sides that are ultra springy. 

Fans of a bouncy bed with little to no contouring should be pretty happy on the Plank. But fair warningโ€”itโ€™s quite firm on both sides. We gave it firmness scores of 7.5/10 and 8/10, respectively, so you can expect pretty great spinal alignment but minimal cushioning. During testing, it also scored a 4/5 or higher in the responsiveness, motion isolation, and cooling categories.

Read more in our Plank Firm Luxe mattress review.

What Our Tester Says

On the extra-firm side, you are squarely on top of the bed. Since there is no sinkage at all, thereโ€™s no quicksand feeling as you change positions. While there is thicker foam on the regular-firm side, it is still pretty easy to move around on. I didnโ€™t feel stuck at all on this side of the bed, either.

Sosha Lewis, Certified Sleep Science Coach
Logo on the Plank Firm Luxe Mattress

Firmness: 7-8/10

The Plank Firm Luxe is flippable, featuring a traditionally firm-feeling side and extra-firm side.

Pressure map of a lightweight tester side sleeping on the Extra Firm side of the Plank Firm Luxe

Pressure Relief: 4.2/5

Average. The traditional firm side of the Plank Firm Luxe will be better for relieving pressure.

Seated edge support test on the Plank Firm Luxe Mattress

Edge Support: 3.2/5

Below average. Despite its extra-firm feel, the Plank Firm Luxe had some lackluster edge support on both sides.

Thermal imaging of the Plank Firm Luxe Mattress after being rested on

Cooling: 4/5

Average. Both sides of the Plank Firm Luxe feel relatively cool and performed well in our temperature test.

Partner test on the Plank Firm Luxe Mattress

Motion Isolation: 4.7/5

Above average. We could only feel very slight motion from our fellow testers on the traditional firm side of the bed.

Our tester stomach-sleeping on the Plank Firm Luxe Mattress

Response: 4.5/5

Above average. Itโ€™s very easy to switch positions on either side of the Plank Firm Luxe, though the traditional firm side is slightly less responsive.

Who Might Like the Plank Firm Luxe

  • Back and stomach sleepers. This bedโ€™s firmer feel is best suited to these positions, as it should give them the support and spinal alignment they need.
  • Heavyweight sleepers. In a similar feel, most of the Plank Firm Luxeโ€™s firmness will be wiped out by a sleeper over 230 pounds, making it feel a bit softer.
  • Fans of a bouncy bed. Moving around during sleep or sex will feel seamless, regardless of which side of the mattress you choose.

Who Might Not Like the Plank Firm Luxe

  • Sleepers with joint pain. Sleepers with sensitive hips, shoulders, wrists, or other troublesome joints should opt for a more pressure-relieving mattress.
  • Some lightweight sleepers. Lightweight sleepers, especially those that sleep on their side, will want a softer bed for better contouring.

Doctorโ€™s Note

โ€œThe traditional firm side of the Luxe does allow for great contouring around the lower back. I like this for a back sleeper. It keeps you in a fairly neutral position, yet itโ€™s still very comfortable. This is true for most sleeping positions, so Iโ€™d recommend it for back pain.โ€ โ€“ Dr. Hannah Habeeb, DPT

Other User Reviews

On the Plank Line as a whole has earned a 4.6-star overall rating from customers. Fans of the Plank Firm Luxe praise its supportive feel, which has helped many address their back pain. But a few complain that the bed isnโ€™t as firm as they expected.

Latest Updates: In July of 2026, we updated this page to reflect recent re-testing of these beds by our experts, including chief medical product tester Dr. Hannah Habeeb. We also gave this page a mini-facelift with a more digestible format, so you can find the best innerspring mattresses for your needsโ€”faster and easier.

Other Innerspring Mattresses We Researched

We considered dozens and dozens of innerspring mattresses to compile this list. Hereโ€™s what else we reviewed and why they didnโ€™t make our top picks.

  • Helix Midnight โ€“ The Helix Midnight is a true medium-firm mattress, and it scored reasonably well in our testing. But the Dusk Luxe edged it out in responsiveness.
  • Birch Natural โ€“ While we appreciated the natural and organic materials in this latex bed, its firmer feel means itโ€™s not ideal for side sleepers. We also prioritized beds with longer sleep trials than the Birch Naturalโ€™s 100 nights.
  • Bear Elite Hybrid โ€“ This affordable mattress impressed us overall, and we think it offers excellent durability and support. It scored well for edge support, but like the Helix Midnight, itโ€™s lacking a little in responsiveness.

How We Tested These Innerspring Mattresses

Letโ€™s take a closer look at the categories we prioritized in our search for the best innerspring mattresses.

Support & Pressure Relief

Support and pressure relief are arguably the standout features in a really great innerspring mattress, and that calls for responsive steel coils and cushioning comfort layers. Supportive coils support a straight spine, while cushioning foams help absorb excess pressure on vulnerable areas like the hips, shoulders, and lumbar region. 

We prioritized innerspring models with individually pocketed coils, zoned coil systems for upgraded lumbar support, and adaptive comfort layers that add cushioning without sacrificing pressure relief.

To test pressure relief, we have sleepers of each type lie down on the mattress on their back and side. These are the positions that require the most pressure relief. They give their opinion on how comfortable they feel, also rating each position out of 5. By the end, we have an overall score that attempts to reflect every body type, showing how well the bed should relieve pressure for most sleepers.

We also use a specialized mat, which is placed on the surface of the mattress. It measures the overall pressure in pounds per square inch, giving an idea of how much resistance youโ€™ll feel as you rest on the bed. The mat also uses thermal imaging to record where pressure builds up along the body. This creates a color-coded pressure map, where red and yellow mean high pressure, while blue and green indicate low. We want to see more of the latter.

For reference, the average pressure-relief rating for all mattresses weโ€™ve tested is 3.8/5 for side sleepers and 4.1/5 for back sleepers, leading to an overall rating of 4/5. 

Edge Support

Edge support describes the stability of a bedโ€™s sides when theyโ€™re bearing weight. Because of how body weight is distributed, edge support can vary when someone sits on the edge versus lies near the side. Since the bulk of an innerspring mattress comes from its coils, these beds often have fairly stable edges, but some do the job better than others.

We test edge support by assessing stability in a seated position, in all three sleeping positions along the edge of the bed, and with an objective test that involves a weighted stack to represent sleepers in different weight classes. 

Out of the hundreds of beds weโ€™ve tested, the average edge support score is a 4.1. A bed that earns higher than this is considered to have strong edges, which means little chance of the perimeter collapsing or sagging.

Responsiveness

Responsiveness describes how quickly a bed returns to its original shape when pressure is released. The faster this happens, the quicker the response time. It contributes to the sensation of bounce or springiness โ€” a hallmark of innerspring mattresses. 

To evaluate response time, we use a switch test to observe how easy or challenging it is for the uppermost layers to support changing from one sleep position to the next. We also measure bounce using a weighted ball, which we drop from about six feet in the air. A yardstick measures how high the bed bounces up. Oftentimes, a bouncy mattress is also a responsive mattress.

The average responsiveness score of all the beds weโ€™ve tested is 4.3, surprisingly high. Most beds with springs earn at least 4/5, with many scoring 4.5 or 5/5 if theyโ€™re especially bouncy.

What Else Is Important When Buying an Innerspring Mattress

Beyond the categories weโ€™ve emphasized above, there are other factors to consider when youโ€™re shopping for a new mattress.

Firmness

Firmness is personal and directly related to body weight and sleep style. Many innerspring models come with multiple firmness options so you can choose what works best for you. We recommend medium-firm mattresses as a great place to start. These beds balance softness and support, creating the perfect profile to align the spine and reduce the risk of back pain.

mattress firmness options on a scale of 1 to 10

Of course, this recommendation is tempered by your body type or preferred sleeping positions. In general, side sleepers do better with a slightly softer mattress feel to cushion the hips and shoulders, while back and stomach sleepers do better with medium-firm and firm feels. 

Sleepers over 230 pounds tend to sink further into a bed, so they might want to go for a firm or even extra-firm bed. Those under 130 pounds have the opposite problem, meaning a softer mattress could help them get the sinkage and pressure relief they need.

Durability

Material quality, particularly in the coil layer, plays a big role in how well a mattress will retain its shape and support in the years to come. According to Dr. Raj Dasgupta, edge support can also be a helpful indicator of overall durability. If the edges of a mattress donโ€™t collapse or sink when bearing weight, the rest of the mattress should follow. 

An innerspring mattress made with high coil counts and denser comfort layers should deliver more longevity. You can also take a look at the brandโ€™s warranty. We take longer warranties as the manufacturerโ€™s confidence in the product.

Cooling

Thermoregulation is a natural part of the sleep process. Body temperatures fluctuate as we move through sleep cycles, and itโ€™s important to have a mattress that supports this process instead of disrupting it. Coils allow for better airflow than layers made entirely of foam, so innerspring mattresses generally sleep cooler than all-foam beds.

If youโ€™re a very hot sleeper, you might consider a mattress made with breathable and temperature-regulating materials, like wool and latex. Active cooling technology, like covers made with phase-change material or performance fabrics, can also be worth exploring.

We qualify a bedโ€™s cooling ability by using a thermal gun to record the increase in surface temperature before and after our tester rests on the bed for 5 minutes. Oftentimes, a bed that rises less than 8 degrees after 5 minutes is considered suitable for hot sleepers. Our testers will also note whether the bed felt cozy, cool to the touch, or stuffy as they lay on it.

Motion Isolation

Traditionally, sleepers had to sacrifice decent motion isolation on a bouncy innerspring mattress. That meant a lot of movement rippling through the bed, which isnโ€™t ideal for couples. Modern innersprings have really improved in this performance category, thanks to individually pocketed coils that move independently and comfort layers made with motion-isolating materials. If you share your bed with a restless sleeper, this can be an important feature to consider. Thatโ€™s why we test every mattress alongside a partner to ensure we can give it an accurate motion isolation rating.

Company Policies

Even if youโ€™ve researched your options carefully, the true test of a mattress is sleeping on it. Thatโ€™s why mattress companies offer sleep trials that range anywhere from a 100-night trial period to a full year. It gives you a risk-free way to determine if a particular mattress really meets your needs in all the ways that matter. 

Before checking out, make sure youโ€™re clear on return policies. Some brands charge restocking or shipping fees for returned beds, while others offer refunds in full as long as the bed is returned during the trial period window. 

Take a moment to scan the warranty details. While a lifetime warranty may sound great, there can be a lengthy list of issues that arenโ€™t covered. Whatโ€™s more, many lifetime warranties only offer replacements for the first 10 years, with prorated fees applying in the years after that. To avoid unpleasant surprises, read the warranty so you know exactly what to expect in the event of a defect.

Best Innerspring Mattress FAQs

What is the highest rated innerspring mattress?

We were impressed by the Helix Dusk Luxe, which delivers on the traditional innerspring experience with excellent responsiveness, sturdy edge support, and cushioning pressure relief. The highest-rated innerspring may not be the one for your needs, though, so be sure to consider it fits your preferences and needs.

What is the difference between an innerspring mattress and a hybrid?

Innerspring mattresses have a coil support system with thinner comfort layers on top, so they have a springier, more lifted sensation. Hybrid mattresses combine coils with thicker comfort layers, which can mean more pressure relief and contouring.

Do people still buy innerspring mattresses?

Innerspring mattresses remain popular for their responsive, lifted feel. Plus, modern innerspring mattresses offer upgrades like zoned support, individually wrapped coils (or pocketed coils), and plush comfort layers.

Which mattress does a 5-star hotel use?

Many 5-star hotels partner with brands like Serta, Beautyrest, and Simmons to make hotel-exclusive luxury mattress models. Generally, these beds are medium or medium-firm innerspring or hybrid models to suit the widest range of sleep needs and preferences and offer long-term durability.

Recap: Best Innerspring Mattresses

MattressAward
Helix Dusk LuxeBest Innerspring Mattress Overall
Nectar Classic HybridBest Value Innerspring Mattress
WinkBedBest Innerspring Mattress for Back Sleepers
Saatva ClassicBest Innerspring Mattress for Back Pain
Brooklyn Bedding Aurora LuxeBest Cooling Innerspring Mattress
Nolah EvolutionBest Innerspring Mattress for Side Sleepers
Plank Firm LuxeBest Firm Innerspring Mattress

References

Subscribe to Mattress Clarity!

Get special coupons, discounts, and giveaways!

Jessica Timmons

Jessica Timmons

About Author

Jessica Timmons has been a freelance writer and editor since 2007. In that time, sheโ€™s written extensively about health, wellness, fitness, sleep and beauty, among other topics. Her byline can be found at Forbes Vetted, Fortune Recommends, mindbodygreen, Everyday Health and other popular outlets. When sheโ€™s not working, she enjoys spending time with her husband and four active kids, lifting weights and getting better at rock climbing one route at a time.