Best Mattress For The Money

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site. See our disclosure page for details.

It’s very difficult to know if you’re actually getting a good deal when shopping for a mattress. The salesperson interaction always feels like an intricate dance (and like the salesperson is much more prepared for that dance than you are).

After personally reviewing over 70 mattresses, plus looking at their specs and speaking with a lot of the companies that make them, we finally feel comfortable putting together a list of mattresses that (in our opinion) are the best mattresses you can buy for your money.

Note that there is a lot of variation based on your sleeping preferences and budget, and just because a mattress doesn’t end up on this list doesn’t mean it’s not a good deal. (We may be missing a couple of good options, but we wanted to keep this list short.)

Use this list as a starting point, and feel free to ask any clarifications in the comments section at the bottom of the page. Now, without further ado…

Overall Picks

Read on below for specific category selections based on a few different criteria. But first, let’s kick this list off with our overall picks:

  • Nectar (quality memory foam at a low price)
  • Amerisleep (luxury memory foam line at a very affordable price)
  • Ghostbed (latex over memory foam)

Nectar

A mattress is cut open to show its design.

Nectar is a great value for the money because it has the same memory foam feel as mattresses that cost $2,000 to $3,000, but it’s priced at about $700 for a Queen (after incorporating discounts).

It’s really hard to find a better value out there, especially within the memory foam category. We can’t test for durability, so we don’t know how long the mattress will last, but to be able to get a mattress of this quality at this price point is quite a steal.

What Makes Nectar Stand Out?

  • You can get a Queen for about $700, even though it has a premium, memory foam feel.
  • It’s a very comfortable mattress that melts away pressure on your hips and shoulders.
  • It is a pretty good fit for all three sleeping positions, making it a very versatile mattress.
  • The mattress comes with a very friendly trial and warranty policy.

Read our full Nectar Review HERE.

Amerisleep

Amerisleep AS4 layers
Amerisleep AS4

Amerisleep offers a line of memory foam mattresses ranging in price and quality. Looking at the specs at each price point and drawing from our own personal experience, this is definitely one of the best mattresses you can buy, dollar for dollar. (Check out the Amerisleep promo code for more savings as well.)

What Makes Amerisleep Stand Out?

  • They have a line of five memory foam mattresses that are built with different firmnesses. They don’t believe there is one best mattress for everyone.
  • The mattress is one of the very best memory foam mattresses at addressing the issue of sleeping cool.
  • The mattresses should be very durable, which increases the value of the mattress.
  • Overall, the memory foam in the mattresses is very comfortable and relieves pressure very well.

For more information on this line, check out our Amerisleep mattress reviews.

Ghostbed

A mattress is opened to show its construction.

Ghostbed sports the now popular latex-over-memory-foam construction that many bed-in-a-box companies like, but it really delivers on specs. We really like the durability of this mattress because it uses higher-density foams than many of its competitors. That means the value of this mattress will be that much higher.

What Makes Ghostbed Stand Out?

  • The mattress is offered at a lower price point than many of its online-only competitors.
  • The mattress should be more durable than many of its all-foam competitors.
  • This is a highly supportive mattress that should be a great fit for back and stomach sleepers.
  • The mattress should sleep cool thanks to the use of aerated latex in the top layer.

Read our full Ghostbed review HERE.

Best Mattress For Side Sleepers

There are a lot of side sleepers out there with shoulder and hip pain, so it is one of the most frequently asked questions on our site: which mattress can help? Of course, value plays a role in any mattress selection, but I suggest you really focus on our best mattress for side sleepers page if you’re in this category.

As a recap, our picks for best mattress for the money for side sleepers are:

  • Amerisleep (luxury memory foam)
  • Layla (innovative memory foam)
  • Nolah (soft and highly pressure-relieving)

Why Amerisleep For Side Sleepers?

  • They offer two mattresses (the AS4 and AS5) that are built specifically for side sleepers.
  • The AS4 does an extremely good job of relieving pressure when on your side.
  • The mattresses will not sleep hot.
  • The mattresses are more durable than many competitors’ mattresses.

Check out our full Amerisleep AS4 Review HERE.

Why Layla For Side Sleepers?

  • The memory foam is extremely comfortable and performed very well on our pressure map testing.
  • The mattress is priced lower than many of its competitors.
  • The memory foam is copper-infused, which can potentially bring certain health benefits.
  • The mattress is flippable, meaning it has a firm and a soft side. The soft side is especially good for side sleepers.

Check out our full Layla Review HERE.

Why Nolah For Side Sleepers?

  • The mattress contains a proprietary AirFoam that relieves pressure as well or better than memory foam.
  • The mattress was built with side sleepers in mind.
  • The mattress is priced lower than many of its competitors.
  • The mattress is temperature-neutral, meaning you will not sleep hot.
  • Overall, it’s one of the most comfortable mattresses that we’ve ever slept on.

Check out our full Nolah Review HERE.

Best Innerspring Mattress

Though foam mattresses are becoming more popular, innerspring mattresses still account for the majority of mattress sales. Durability is a huge factor when determining the “best” of these types, because when an innerspring mattress goes bad, it can be really bad for your comfort.

The best innerspring mattress for the money goes hand in hand with our best innerspring mattress page, with a slight re-ordering that prioritizes value over anything else:

Why Aviya?

  • The mattress gives you a lot of the benefits of much more expensive spring mattresses but at a much lower cost.
  • The mattress uses more durable foams than many other spring mattresses do. That will make the mattress more durable and a better value overall.
  • The mattress is very supportive overall and should be a great fit for stomach and back sleepers.

Why Brentwood Home Oceano?

  • The mattress provides a luxury innerspring experience at an affordable price.
  • The mattress consists solely of high-quality, durable components.
  • The Oceano is a very comfortable mattress overall.

Why Winkbeds?

  • The mattress is one of the more comfortable mattresses out there.
  • The mattress is overall a great value and would cost at least twice as much if found in a retail store.
  • They also have a Plus model available, which is a great option for heavier-weight sleepers.

Best Mattress By Budget

While some people prefer to choose a mattress based on their sleep style or feel preferences, others prefer for their budget to dictate their mattress hunt. Check out the budget picks below, and let us know if more specific categories would be useful!

Under $1,000

Our picks for best mattress for under $1k (in addition to the mattresses already mentioned) include:

Why Saatva?

  • You can get a Queen for just under $1,000, even though a comparable mattress found at a retail store would cost two or three times that amount.
  • The mattress is a great fit for all three sleeping positions, which makes it very versatile.
  • Overall, the mattress uses quality components that should be durable for the long haul.

Why Bear?

  • The mattress is a great fit for all three sleeping positions.
  • The cover has celliant fibers woven into it, which can provide a cooler night of sleep and potentially help athletes recover faster.
  • The mattress is perhaps the best memory foam mattress at addressing the issue of sleeping hot.

Why Helix?

  • Helix allows you to customize a mattress based on your preferences and answers to a customization quiz.
  • Because of the customization, Helix can be a great fit for any type of sleeper.
  • The mattress can be an excellent choice for couples because you can customize two sides of the mattress.

Under $2,000

Our picks for best mattress for under $2k (in addition to the general picks) include:

Why Loom & Leaf?

  • The mattress uses premium components yet is priced lower than many other memory foam mattresses.
  • The mattress is a great fit for all three sleeping positions, making it widely appealing.
  • The mattress should be more durable than a lot of its competitors.
  • Even though it’s a memory foam mattress, you shouldn’t sleep hot in it.

Why Winkbeds?

  • The mattress is one of the most comfortable spring mattresses available.
  • They have a Plus model that is a great fit for heavier-weight sleepers.
  • A comparable mattress found at a retail store would cost roughly twice as much.

Why PlushBeds?

  • The mattresses have natural latex in them, which can be extremely durable.
  • The company has a lot of options available for all types of sleepers.
  • The mattresses are more affordable than many of its latex competitors.

How To Get The Most For Your Money

Watch Out For Deals And Sales

Mattress retailers are known for having sales at fairly predictable times of the year. President’s Day, for example, is a pretty common time for there to be lots of sales going on in the mattress world. A good portion of the sales also fall around holiday times such as the Fourth of July, Thanksgiving, and Memorial Day.

If you are looking to purchase a mattress in a store or online, take a look at when the standard mattress sales are happening and consider waiting until then to get that extra value from your purchase.

Also, keep an eye out for bundles. Many retailers offer pillows, sheet sets, and even foundations with the purchase of your mattress. If you are in need of a full bedroom set, you should factor this kind of deal into your decision-making process.

Think About The Durability Of Each Mattress

The phrase “you get what you pay for” is especially true when it comes to mattresses. The range in durability from one mattress to the next can be pretty substantial. If you save $300 on a mattress, but it wears out in five years, are you really getting a better value than a mattress that costs $300 more but wears out after 10 to 12 years?

Before purchasing a mattress, consider how long you want to have the mattress and then read reviews to make sure you know how long you can expect the mattress to last.


In addition, different materials are going to affect the life of your mattress differently. For example: Some types of foam sag over time, while others are more responsive. Latex foam, while usually more expensive, can add a few years to your mattress. Some mattresses even incorporate “sag-proof” foam to fight the long-term aging of a mattress. 

You may be paying more for certain materials up front, but the mattress will pay for itself with its extra years of use.

Doing The Work To Make Your Mattress Last

Once you’ve purchased your mattress, the work does not stop there. There are several steps you can take to ensure you get to use your mattress for a long time.

  • Buy a mattress protector. It may seem like more money, but a mattress protector could add years to your mattress. It protects against stains and messes. In addition, many warranties require you to use a mattress protector.
  • Make sure your mattress is supported. The majority of mattresses require a box spring, foundation, or bed to ensure your mattress wears evenly. Also, some warranties may be voided if you don’t use the correct foundation.
  • Don’t bounce on the bed. If you have kids, they may enjoy jumping on the bed. However, this can damage your mattress, especially if it has innersprings.
  • Keep food out of the bed. It may be nice to eat a few cookies in bed, but those crumbs could attract bugs. If you are going to eat in bed, change your sheets frequently.
  • Flip your mattress regularly. While many online mattresses are not flippable, there are still some mattresses that benefit from regular flipping. This cuts down on the wear and body indentation that can affect sleeping surfaces.
  • Spot-clean any messes immediately. Accidents do happen. If you make a mess, carefully clean it at once. Take a look at your mattress’s materials and use cleaners that won’t damage the mattress. Learn more about cleaning your mattress here.

Consider Where You Purchase Your Mattress

A vast majority of people now buy their mattresses online. That’s largely because online shopping offers greater convenience, and many brick-and-mortar mattress stores can be confusing when it comes to their models, pricing, and firmness scales.

While you can’t try out an online mattress the way you can in a mattress store, they often come with sleep trials. These allow you to try out the mattress for a few months (100 days is a common trial length) and return it if you are unhappy.

In addition, many online mattresses are more affordable than their in-store counterparts. They have less overhead and have cut out the middlemen to pass savings directly to you. In addition, some companies own their own factories, which allows them to keep prices even lower.

There are also a few hidden-gem companies out there that spend very little on marketing, and they pass on the savings to the customer in the form of a lower price. This is a subtle nuance, but there are definitely extra savings to be had if you can find a company with a great product that doesn’t spend a lot on marketing.

A woman looks at a bed.VGstockstudio/Shutterstock

Take A Close Look At Trial Periods And Warranties

Most mattress companies (both online and brick-and-mortar) offer warranties. In addition, most online mattresses come with a sleep trial.

While these can be very helpful and save you money if you have problems, make sure you have a firm understanding of the fine print. Some warranties will be voided without the proper foundation or care. Also, some trial periods don’t include free shipping. If you don’t like the product, you may have to pay to return it.

Watch Out For Shipping / Taxes

If you purchase online, you should check to see if you will have to pay for shipping or not. A lot of the new companies offer free shipping, but not all do. You may think you’re getting a great deal, but it never feels good to get hit with unexpected shipping costs during the checkout process.

Similarly, depending on where you live, you may have to pay sales taxes as well. It’s another cost that you probably don’t think about but that you may or may not be responsible for paying.

Also, keep a lookout for companies that offer “White Glove Delivery.” With this option, movers will bring the mattress to your door, set it up, and take away the trash. This can be very worth it, especially if you are dealing with a heavy mattress or your bedroom is not on the first floor.

These extra costs probably shouldn’t make or break your decision, but it’s an added bonus if you don’t have to pay them.

Overall

Buying a mattress can be quite intimidating. There are so many things to think about in order to ensure your money is well spent. Using this guide, you should be able to find the right mattress for you (and at the right price). Just relax, follow these steps, and you’ll be able to enjoy a great value with your next mattress.

The following two tabs change content below.

Joe Auer

Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site. He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 100 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 4 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications. When he isn't testing sleep products, he enjoys working out, reading both fiction and non-fiction, and playing classical piano. He enjoys traveling as well, and not just to test out hotel mattresses! Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.

Latest posts by Joe Auer (see all)

526 thoughts on “Best Mattress For The Money”

  1. Hello! 🙂

    My husband is 6’3″ at 180lb and I’m 5’3″ at 160lb.
    We both toss and turn and are combination sleepers. We’re not sure if we’re disturbing one another. We usually wake up (frequently), scootch/smoosh back into the other person, and then fall back asleep, so I’m not sure if motion isolation/lack thereof is at fault there.

    Currently, our mattress is making our arms fall asleep, my lower back hurt and feel unsupported, and our hips and shoulders hurt. We’re sinking in, but it doesn’t feel like it’s doing us any good. We have a Serta iComfort Blue Touch Memory Foam, but I forget the plush-vs.-firm factor that we got.

    What would you recommend for us?

  2. I am deciding between the Cedar and Oceano. We are lightly built side and back sleepers. My husband has a very sensitive nose and cannot stand the chemical smells of our previous memory foam mattress and wants an all natural mattress but I worry that it does not suit side sleepers as well as the Oceano. Would the Cedar suit our sleep styles? Has anyone experienced notable off-gassing or a lingering poly-urethane foam smell with the Oceano?

  3. I just bought the newest Tuft and Needle Mint mattress. I am a side sleeper and don’t feel it’s quite soft enough. Was reading that the Layla is one of the top picks for a side sleeper. I saw your video review of the original T&N and Layla and how the Layla was softer. Would you still say it’s softer than the Mint? Or any other softer recommendations than the Layla?

  4. I have not seen any comments on a defect in mattress like body impressions.
    We dumped a $2200.0 Serta King firm and replaced it with a Sapria king. After 30 days it developed body impressions. Of course, Leesa is refunding our money so no problem except now we will have to scramble and buy another one. These impressions are unsightly, to say the least. Have you run on to this problem?

  5. Hello,

    I am a side/back-sleeper. I have had lower-mid back pain for years (though I am only 23), but, more recently I have had upper back pain… I am thinking from pressure on my shoulders? I can afford to purchase a $600-700 mattress (I am thinking the Nectar or Layla). Could you please let me know which you recommend of the two? and what major differences I would feel from purchasing the Zinus memory foam? Since I am purchasing a full, I do not plan on needing it for over 5-7 years since I will likely upgrade to a Queen. For that reason, I am wondering if the Zinus is a better value. Thanks so much!

  6. Hey guys, I have been reading through a ton of your reviews and I need some personalized advice. I am 5’5 115 and we are trialing the Original Purple Mattress. I am in love with it for back sleeping, but I like to roll onto my side and there I am getting virtually no pressure relief on my shoulder because I’m not heavy enough to push into it. (My husband is 6’2 170 and isn’t bothered by it) We both sleep hot, so the temperature neutral aspect of Purple is great, but since we are in a king size, the price for the Purple 4 is much too high.
    Could you give me your #1 and #2 recommendations for a king sized mattress, with great pressure relief for a light weight side sleeper, but still supportive for back sleeping, temperature control and as close to $1,500 as possible? I know it’s a long list, but I would so appreciate your advice! Thank you!

  7. I have health issues and spend 99% time in bed laying down or using my adjustable bed for sitting up. My height is 6ft and weight is 290 and I’m a side sleeper except when I’m sitting up in bed. The mattress would be used on an adjustable base. Could you recommend a few choices? Helix nightfall was one i was looking at. I have a latex mattress now but its in need of replacing.
    Thanks

  8. My husband I have had a Tuft and Needle since 2012 and LOVE it. It still looks and feels new and it’s the best mattress we’ve ever had. But when we went to upgrade to a king size of the same thing, we learned that T&N changed their mattress in 2015 to be less firm in response to customer feedback. I tried one of the newer T&Ns and hated it, it was so soft I sank into it, and felt so cheap compared to ours, with a lot less edge support. My question is, what current mattress is most similar to the original (2012-2015) T&N in terms of firmness?

  9. Hi Team,
    This is my third attempt to get help!! Hope you can see this comment and reply with guidance. 😊

    I saw Joe’s review of the Saatva…which was just delivered to my home 6 days ago. I chose the FIRM mattress as I was accustomed to a Shifman firm mattress for over 15 years. (As you may know, Shifman’s had lots of cotton padding, some foam and a strong coil system).

    However…I am finding the Saatva firm TOO firm. Typically I find mattresses too soft and i sink in…especially if they are old..but this FIRM seems firmer than even I expected. Have you guys checked out the firm?

    I am wondering if I should exchange this for the Luxury firm…or whether that would be too soft? I thought perhaps I might buy the luxury firm initially but as the sarrva compans firmness rating was on the low side and there was no way to try it….i decided to go for the REAL firm.

    it was helpful for me to see your video and review…as u note that the Luxury firm seems firmer than most…which maybe would have led me to choose that one from the start.

    Anyway…what’s your recommendation?

    BTW this is my 4th mattress replacement since my old Shifman was donated. in the last four months, I have tried two all latex mattress (SleeponLatex) –excellent but which were not supportive enough for me….and one Avocado (also not supportive enough). now the Saatva FIRM…which is too firm.

    Ideas??

    Thanks — love your videos!! Please write back — I need help!

    Best regards,

    Ursula Rudd

  10. I have an individual who weighs 454 lbs. We are wondering what the weight capacity is for the Purple 4 mattress? Also, can this come in 60″ width and 80″ length?

  11. My wife and I purchased a dream cloud sleep about two months ago and have found that it is already sagging. I am a side sleeper and my wife is a back sleeper. We are not too concerned about price but don’t want to spend more than $1500 on a king mattress. I am 6’3” and 210 and my wife is 5’2” and 120. She hates the “tufts” in the DreamCloud. Any suggestions? She’s also looking for good side support.

    Thanks!

  12. Hi there,

    I was hoping you could provide some insight on mattresses that would best suit me. I’ve watched at least a dozen mattress reviews from you and others and I am still not sure what mattress will be right for me. Here’s some info:

    I’ve been sleeping on memory foam beds for the last 15 years. I do enjoy the feel of memory foam but I have been suffering from back pain for at least half of that time (7-8 years) and am looking for a mattress that will help me address that pain. I’m a side sleeper mostly (I’d say 60-70% of the time) and otherwise I sleep on my back. I bought a Nectar around August of 2017 and slept on that for nearly a year. Unfortunately, it never really felt like the bed for me. I then bought a Nolah, which I’ve been sleeping on for a little over two months, and it too just doesn’t feel quite right… I want to love it because I love the idea of foam that isn’t memory foam but preforms similarly, but it still feels a bit too firm for me. It’s comfy at first but I feel like I sink through the comfort layer and I am still waking with back pain. For reference, I am about 5’8″ and 195 lbs.

    Based on all my past experiences with memory foam and the two online bed in a box mattresses that I’ve tried, I’m starting to think maybe a hybrid mattress is a better option for me? I’ve looked at a few so far… Tomorrow Sleep, Crystal Cove by Brentwood, and the DreamCloud are the ones that stand out most to me. What are your opinions of these mattresses? Does my past experience tell you anything about my needs? Clearly I am missing something.

    I’d love to hear your thoughts. I am feeling a bit desperate!

    Thanks!

  13. Can you help me, please. My husband and I are just 60 and looking to move to our new home to start our retirement. A new bed is in the picture and we are leaning to an adjustable as we both have arthritis and other health problems. But cannot decide on split king or two twins- together or separated – because my arthritis is mostly in my hands and the thought of changing the sheets on a split king sound painful – but would pushing apart two twins be any easier. Any comments or thoughts would be helpful.

  14. Hi joe,
    I am primarily a side sleeper but occasionally sleep on my stomach but have never slept on a foam mattress. I have done some research and am thinking about getting either Casper, Layla, or Nolah. Which would you recommend or if you have any other I should look into? I’ve been dealing with occasional neck and shoulder pain too. Thanks.

    • I would say the Casper because it has a zoned construction. It will be softer under you shoulders when you sleep on you side but also firm and supportive enough for when you sleep on your stomach.

  15. We are looking for a new mattress. We currently have a traditional mattress. My husband is 6’4″ 265-275. and I am 5-8 140-150. We are interested in trying one of the foam type mattresses. He is a stomach/back sleeper and I am a mostly side but some stomach sleeper. He prefers medium to firm and I like a firm mattress. I am concerned that any of these foam mattress may not be suitable for our combined weight. We have looked at temperpedic ( concerned about heat), Puffy (concerned about firmness) and purple (concerned about durability). What are your thoughts given the above details. Thank you

  16. I am looking to buy a new king size mattress. Price is not an issue. What would you recommend as the best mattress fro some who tends to like a firmer bed with a very luxurious top fee/?

  17. Hi I was wondering if you could give me your opinion of the Puffy Luxe? We are looking for a new mattress and were leaning toward the Nectar, but after seeing lots of negative customer service reviews we became hesitant. The Puffy Luxe looks like a good alternative. We are both primarily side sleepers and are on the lighter side. Thanks for any help.

  18. I am wondering what your opinion of the Puffy Lux mattress is? My wife and I are looking for a new mattress and are thinking about the Nectar, but seeing some negative reviews about customer service is making us nervous so we are looking at the Ghostbed luxe, Nolah 12″, and the Puffy Lux. (Nectar is still an option because the price is great). We are both primarily side sleepers and on the smaller/lighter side. Any help would be great. Thanks

  19. Hello, I spent a ton on a natural latex mattress (45th Street Bedding), but it was not the right mattress for me. I assume it was because it was too firm, no springs, and/or too thin for me. (I am 6 feet tall, curvy, and weigh around 200 pounds. I am also mostly a sidesleeper, while sleeping on my back a bit.) Now I don’t know what to choose. I have limited funds because I am stuck with the latex mattress. I don’t know how worried I should be about off gassing, but I was looking at a Tuft & Needle, mainly because I can look at it in store in Seattle. How much thought/stress should I put into worrying about off gassing in these type of mattresses? Do I need to try to save up for an Avocado mattress?

  20. I need a few suggestions for a new mattress. I sleep very hot and on my stomach. I like my current memory foam mattress as it is very firm and I don’t ever feel my wife on the other side.

  21. I have purchased a couple of mattresses over the years due to lower back pain and while the current mattress
    , Serra perfect sleeper-Serra mentor has helped with the severe lower back pain, both my husband and I noticed an increase in shoulder numbness and neck pain. I know back sleeping is best -I am a side sleeper. I am 5’5 169 and my husband is 5’10 185. We need a pain free/good night sleep and just can not seem to get. We were looking at your reviews and would like guidance . When I went to NY and stayed at Hilton- I had a good nights sleep,and was thinking of purchasing a Hilton bed. I came across your website and noticed reviews on Saatva. I thought of purchasing Saatva -then I started looking at all your bed reviews. Can you please help advise- help us find the needle in the haystack 😁

    • If you really liked the Hilton one then you might want to give that a try. If you are worried about shoulder numbness then I would maybe take a look at a memory foam mattress or the Nolah or Purple.

      • I have read a number of your mattress reviews and wondered if you could make a suggestion. I’m 180lb. 5’5″ female side-sleeper with some hip pain and some issues with arm numbness. Looking for a twin size mattress. I’ve tried out a Tuft & Needle (much too firm) and the Nolah 10 (original). The Nolah 10 is “okay”–I have to add a couple of toppers to make it soft enough (I’m using 1″ of memory foam, and then a 1″ eggshell foam on top of that to make it not quite so hot.) Without the toppers, my hips do fairly well but my shoulders/arms still get tingly. I’m debating getting the Nolah Signature, but I’m not sure if that will be enough softer to get rid of the toppers (and of course, I can only return one of them!) I’m also debating the softest WinkBed or Saatva (I don’t really love “sinking down” into the mattress but prefer that to the arm tingling–so that’s why I’m considering an inner spring/hybrid type. I also like the idea of the hips being better supported while having plenty of cushioning for the shoulders, which it seems like they might offer). But Maybe the Amerisleep or Helix would do a better job?

        I can’t do the Purple because they only have a twin XL and not just a twin. Otherwise that would be on my list too!

        I know you can’t know for sure obviously, but I’m curious your analysis. Thanks for any help!

      • I would maybe consider the Amerisleep AS4. It will have 4 inches of memory foam, which should be enough where you wouldn’t need a topper. Pressure relief will be solid and overall it sounds like it would be a good fit for you.

  22. We have a Tempurpedic that is awful! It is sooo hard. I woke up the other day with my hip and arm totally asleep and the hip is still sore! It’s also very hot. Really haven’t liked it for several years now but after the other night/am, I’m pretty much done with it. Any ideas? Thanks!!!

  23. I am a large person 360# who sleeps on her side. I have seen your recommendations for side sleepers, but which mattress do you recommend for the large person who sleeps in a side lying position?

  24. Hi Joe,
    I’m confused as to why you have Casper in the hybrid category. Everything I see on your website and their’s seem to make it a memory foam mattress. Great website, by the way.
    Thanks,
    Mike

  25. Hi, Joe,
    Thanks for your great website and services ! I see in the past you were asked this question, but I will ask it again: have you reviewed (or heard anything) re: M Lily products? My friend is working for them and I would like to help him by buying one of these mattresses, but you haven’t reviewed it yet that I can tell. Have you heard anything about them? Thanks !

  26. Hi Joe — I recently bought the Tuft & Needle Mint, and my Fiance and I are in a rough spot. At first it was super comfortable and we loved it, but about a month in, we’re both experiencing back pain in different ways.

    My lower back, right above my buttocks, is killing me. I have to get up and bend over to touch my toes to stretch it out constantly, and can’t lie in the bed for more than a few hours, and I’ve had to get out of bed earlier than I want to because of this. Side sleeping only temporarily relieves that, but it starts to hurt again. I prefer to try to sleep on my back, and usually transition to my side at some point (so I’m a side/back sleeper). I’m 6’1 215 pounds.

    My Fiance sleeps in all sorts of positions — back, side, stomach. She’s been having neck pain and middle of the back pain develop from sleeping on this bed. She’s 5’6 155 lbs.

    We both very active and weight lifters, in good shape.

    Trying to find a recommendation for a bed, because the T&N bed isn’t doing it for us, and we’re going to return it. To me, it just feels too firm, it’s like my buttocks isn’t sinking in far enough, so my lower back is floating and not being supported. Maybe I’m wrong… but I’ve heard T&N runs on the firmer side — something people say should be good for a back sleeper, apparently not though.

    Any recommendations would be great. Thanks!

  27. Lower back pain. The numb shoulder pain went away when we switched from a firm traditional spring mattress to Nectar, but the back pain didn’t.

  28. Hi Joe,

    I’m 130 lbs and start sleeping on my side but roll over and switch to my stomach and back throughout the night. My husband and I got a Nectar a few months ago, our first memory foam mattress, and I love how it isolates motion and he’s comfortable (145 lb side sleeper), but I hate how hot it is and wake up in pain in every position. I’m thinking I need a softer mattress so I sink in more, but maybe I need a firmer one to support my back better? (Our initial firm spring mattress with a pillow top was even worse, though.) Or maybe the foam construction doesn’t lend itself well to multiple sleep positions?

    We’re at a loss for what type of bed to try next, so any suggestions would be great. I’m looking at a Tomorrow as a low-risk way to try a hybrid since it’s cheaper and has a long return period. I’m also open to Amerisleep AS3 or 4, or Loom and Leaf Relaxed Firm, but I’m not convinced the higher price tag means better construction, especially in terms of sleeping cool, since the whole bed in a box industry is based on the premise that mattress companies lie and inflate prices. 🙂

    Thanks in advance for any suggestions you have!

  29. Hi Joe,over the last two weeks I have looked at numerous mattress review sites and I am somewhat confused. I have always wanted a Tempurpedic. I do not think I can tolerate coils much longer. Now I have the opportunity to buy one and also have been dealing with a lot of upper back shoulder, & neck pain. of course I was intrigued in learning about all these new companies that were of high quality but less expensive. I am also a side sleeper. So anyway I found your site two days ago after I had already decided to purchase the tempurpedic. I read your review and comparison to the Purple which I thought might be the right one for me then I saw your review of the Amerisleeep which I have never heard of and thought WOW! this sounds like the mattress I need. So anyway I was just wondering what is your opinion? I am side sleeper but now also on my back due to the shoulder pain. What do you think, I made the tempurpedic purchase but I can cancel as they are not being delivered until Friday. Anyway, I apologize for rambling on. I look forward to hearing from you. Val Schuster

  30. Hello. I’m currently considering buying a Sheex mattress (they only sell one as of now). I looked throughout your website, including Slumber Sage, and did not find any results, but maybe I was looking in the wrong spot. Do you have any reviews on Sheex? If not, do you plan on checking them out in the future? Thanks.

  31. Looking for recommendations for a new mattress. I’m 65, have lower back issues, and am interested in a memory foam or combo type mattress. I’d prefer to stay close to or under $1000.00 as well.

    Thanks!

    • You can check out the Tomorrow Sleep Medium Firm mattress. It has memory foam and a spring system that is very supportive. It’s also under $1,000 for a Queen.

  32. My wife and I are both side sleepers, I am 235#, she is 110#. We have a king size bed. We tried the Tuft and Needle that our kids recommended but it is too firm. I would sink through the adaptive foam layer and could feel the foundation foam, both still having hip and shoulder pain. We actually moved the tuft and needle out and put our 20 year old Simmons Beautyrest back on the bed. Not sure whether to try a different foam mattress (Leesa, Casper or Amerisleep) or continue the search for a innerspring with more comfort layers. (i.e. cotton batting with additional layers of different foam. I realize the Tuft and Needle is least expensive, the Leesa and Casper a little higher priced and the Amerisleep significantly more but am concerned we would have the same problems with another foam matress. Even looking at Winkbeds. Any thoughts or suggestions?

  33. Thanks for sharing your opinions on mattresses. It’s been very helpful and I am more familiar with some of the terminologies now after reading your posts.

    I am looking to buy a mattress after a really long time. I prefer mattresses that are on the bouncy and firm end of the spectrum (one having good support and that doesn’t sink much). I sleep in a variety of positions. From a budget standpoint, I could spend between $800 and $1300 for a queen. What would you recommend?

    Thanks a ton!

  34. What are your thoughts on the new T & N Mint vs the L & L. In reading your reviews and recommendations the L & L compares favorably to a Tempur-Pedic at a much better price point. Looking at the spec the L & L is a 12″ with foam density ranging between 4 – 5 lbs/cubic feet vs the new T & N is a 12″ with foam density ranging between 2 – 3.5 lbs/cubic feet. Although the T & N is about $200 cheaper than the L & L. What’s your take on which one is the better deal long term? Considering I am heavy set at about 290 lbs. Thanks

  35. Your reviews are extremely helpful. Have you ever published a list ranking memory foam mattresses in order of firmness: softest to the most firm? That would be extremely helpful as well. Even a partial list based on what you have seen so far would really help.

    Thank you so much.

  36. Hey Joe, thanks for sleeping on all these mattresses for us! What is your recommendation for soft mattresses? Currently I am sleeping on a Nectar & with being so skinny & a side sleeper it leaves my sides hurting in the morning. Around the same price range would be great, TIA!

  37. I keep buying mattresses and they develop body impressions within a week. The first was Beautyrest World Class Keaton. Second was Loom & Leaf. I LOVED how both of these felt when I got them, but the impression that develops makes them uncomfortable. I assume this is normal, since it’s within a week or two, rather than years of use. I also tried Tuft and Needle, but that was too firm. Do you have any recommendations for beds that won’t develop an impression? Or do I just need a firmer version? Many thanks.

  38. My husband and I have a Temperpedic bed with moderate firmness. We got it because his back was always hurting and he doesn’t have that issue now. However, I have hated the smell from the very beginning (it doesn’t smell now after 3 years), but I have had alot of problems with night sweats and waking up with migraines otherwise it is comfy. I started sleeping on an old matress in our spare bedroom to see if my problems were the bed and my migraines and night sweats have almost gone away. So, I want a new bed, but I am afraid he won’t be comfortable (he is a side sleeper and I am a back sleeper). I have looked into the Naturepedic, Avacodo and Zenhaven so far. I just don’t know what to do. We haven’t even paid off the Temperpedic yet so I’m not thrilled about spending alot of money, but I will if I have to. Can you help?

    • Sounds like you want a mattress with a similar feel but without sleeping hot. I would take a look at Amerisleep. They have a line of mattresses with a similar feel to the Tempur-Pedic mattresses. They do an excellent job of addressing the issue of sleeping hot in their construction.

  39. My husband and I start out sleeping on our sides and occasionally I wake up on my back. He tends to move around a lot at night and sleeps mostly on his side. We are both in our 50’s. He weighs ~230 and I weigh ~155. I usually go to bed “cold” but my husband “sleeps hot” and it balances things out for me. We currently have a regular “too hard” spring mattress with a memory foam topper (from WalMart) that has surprisingly worked well for 9 years. I am starting to have some shoulder pains so looking for a new mattress. I have done some research and read /viewed all your reviews. I have narrowed it down to Nolah & Amerisleep (was considering Leesa, but feel these other 2 might work better for us?). An additional question about a base. We have an antique 4 poster rice bed so we would need a box spring. (We will move the old mattress to guest bedroom once we buy an a new one for the master.) So, do we just go to another store or Amazon to buy a box spring? I am used to these being in sets so purchasing just a box spring seems unusual.
    What is your direct comparison of AS3 and Nolah? It seems Nolah may be the best considering all things. Also looking to take advantage of Cyber discounts today if you are able to reply.
    Thank you for all your research to help consumers narrow down all the choices!

    • I would say the Nolah is a little softer, so if you just sleep on your side it would probably be the better choice. As far as a box spring, you can put these mattresses on any flat surface. I personally am a big fan of the platform beds that Zinus has available. Check those out.

  40. We have a 40’ sailboat and looking for a 6-8 inch Mattress. We need firmness and back support. My husband weighs 240 and I weigh 115 . The base is wood. Mildew is always a challenge for boaters. Any recommendations for a new Mattress would be greatly appreciated!

  41. I’m trying to get an opinion on the indigo mattress…there seems to be no reviews other than the site thats selling it…it looks unique in the send that the top can be flipped and rotates and cleaned.

  42. I recently purchased a Bear mattress and have been sleeping on it for about a month. I sleep on my back and side. I really want to love it but it feels too firm for me and my arms are going to sleep at night (while sleeping on my back). It is better than my old mattress because it supports my back, but I don’t love it. Is it the firmness level that is causing my arms to go to sleep? Do I need a softer mattress? If I go softer, will this comprimise back support? I have been looking at Loom & Leaf, Ghostbed (because I like the idea of natural latex, but prices are generally high), or a medium or medium soft Intellibed. Any thoughts on this? Thanks so very much.

  43. Hi Joe! I have a quality/longevity question. I built my own mattress six years ago by ordering high density foam from any upholstery shop. My husband & I are heavy sleepers, but not giant people. We have already worn out the upper 3 layers. I want a new matress with a warranty this time. Our experience is that the upper softer layers invariably begin to compress & dip & sag over a year or 18 months. That results in a loss of pressure point relief since the foam compresses & you can feel that hardness of it compacting on itself, and also the sag results in lack of proper support, which hurts our necks & backs. In your research, experience, & word through the grapevine, which matress(es) have a longer life in this regard? We just bought the Helix and it is terrible: the “soft” side is incredibly firm & cuts off the circulation in my hips. I’m not picky about the “hug” you mention in your reviews, but I do need a plush/soft feel WITHOUT the dip that seems to happen because the manufacturers typically use lower density upper layers, which degrade & compact pretty quickly. Help!

  44. Hi! I am a petite 40 yr old woman. I am a side sleeper with a lot of joint/body pain. I am trying to train myself to be a back sleeper to alleviate the pressure on my neck/shoulders/arms from sidesleeping. My husband is 6’2″ and a crazy, hot, sweaty sleeper. He prefers a firm bed. What mattress would you recommend? We would like to spend less than $1000 and prefer a king size bed. Thanks so much!

    • If getting too hot is a concern, then innerspring would be a good choice. Saatva could be a good match, although it’s going to be a little over $1,000 for a king. You might also want to take a look at Purple, which is completely temperature neutral.

  45. What else would you recommend for someone who prefers a softer mattress that is not too expensive, i.e. under $850ish? The first one you recommend is what I’m trying out and it’s too firm for me so it will be going back. The Purple sounds like it also runs firm from reviews, or is it just a different feel? Because 5 was too firm for me, something in the 3 range on the firmness scale may work. Thank you!

  46. I ordered a foam bed-in-the-box mattress that is 10″ thick after comparing reviews for some time, and it’s too firm for me. It was rated about a 5 on the firmness scale, but some reviewers said it was too soft so even though I like softer beds I thought it might be fine. I tried it for 8 nights to adjust and my hip, neck, and back pain and general nerve pain increased so that I couldn’t sleep so I’m back on my old bed, a 15yr old sealy innerspring plush.

    I am a back and side sleeper who is on the high side of average weight. I like a cloud feel like I’m softly floating above the mattress, I usually like the beds at Hilton hotels.

    I’m not sure a foam mattress is for me, what do you recommend? I’m thinking about a hybrid maybe. Thanks!

  47. Hi Joe. We are in need of a new mattress, despite the fact that our current one is less than 2.5 years old. And it is our 4th mattress in under 10 years. (The one before that was a Scandinavian foam one that we had for 30+ years before moving to a king bed.) All quite expensive, I might add. All developed the same issues. We have tried latex, spring, memory, combination, you name it, we’ve tried it.
    We are not tiny people, but neither are we overly large. However, I am disabled. I suffer from chronic pain due to advanced arthritis and severe spinal & foraminal stenosis. Throw in a little avascular necrosis, numerous tendon tears and just plain old aging, and you start to get the picture. Because of this, I spend a fair amount of time in the supine position. To complicate matters, my internal thermostat is broken and I seriously overheat above 70F.
    These are our 2 main problems:
    1: Overheating. Every mattress (with the exception of a bamboo one (in which we sank through to the box support very quickly) have caused almost unbearable overheating. Actually, lately it has been unbearable.
    2: Body impressions. They have all formed significant body impressions in an inordinately short period of time. Usually this impression is apparent even when the bed is made and has been unoccupied for several hours. Unfortunately, the current mattress ‘bounces back’ fairly quickly, but the material in the impression area is weakened and, within 5 minutes of lying back down, the rut is back. My pressure points are screaming. And it is excessively difficult to change positions. (Those ruts have walls!?)
    Neither of us sleep in just one position. My husband switches from back to side. I switch from side to back to the other side – often.
    One other thing. My hearing is working overtime. Why would that matter? Believe it or not, I can actually hear the springs in a mattress within a very short period of time.
    And … we (I) are desperate! Can you, would you make a suggestion?
    Thanks in advance for your efforts on our behalf.

    • You might want to take a look at Purple. The gel layer on top allows air to pass through freely. That makes it basically temperature neutral. It won’t develop a body impression very easily at all either.

  48. Great resource, thank you. I’m shopping for a memory foam mattress for my 4-year-old and wondering if you have an opinion on one that is better for smaller people/children. I’d ideally like to have this bed until she is a teenager or goes off to school. Lull, Leesa and Ghostbed seem like great options and affordable in the twin size.

  49. Hey Joe the first mattress I stumbled upon was the lull and you didn’t mention it all what do you know about the lull I have neck and back injuries I like a firm sleep my girlfriend has a cloud are any of these comparable to a cloud or better than a cloud? Thank you so much Joe

  50. Joe,

    I have narrowed my choices to Sapira and Zenhaven. My typical preference is a firm mattress. I am in my late 50’s, with the usual aches and pains that come with that time of life, so I am looking to upgrade my mattress support. We have a king bed, split as 2 twin xl’s (my wife has a Sapira), so I can select an option unique to me. Cost is a secondary issue, I want to get the best option. One other variable is that I have an adjustable base, so that’s why Zenhaven is an option. Your thoughts?

    How would you compare the Sapira and Zenhaven in terms of firmness?

    • I think the Sapira and the Zenhaven firm side are about the same (firmness is subjective, so keep that in mind). Both are highly supportive mattresses that are firmer than average.

  51. Trying to decide between Brooklyn Bedding and Alexander signature ( both soft versions as I am aside sleeper). Any thoughts? I know Brooklyn Bedding is cheaper

  52. Hi! I currently have a low quality memory foam mattress that I am looking to replace. I like memory foam, but in the summer when the house heats up (no AC) it gets soft and doesn’t support my back and causes pain. In the winter it is nice and firm and supports my back fine. I know all memory foam is affected by temperature to some degree, but do you think I should stay away from memory foam altogether? Or would a higher quality mattress not suffer from this problem as much? I’ve been looking at the loom & leaf. Or maybe one of the firmer amerisleep beds. Thanks!

    • There are some mattresses like the Bear mattress that have memory foam that roughly keeps the same performance no matter what the temperature is. That might be an interesting one for you to take a look at. If you sleep on your back/stomach the Amerisleep AS2 could be a good option for you as well.

  53. I tried Lull. Fantastic customer service (crazy good) but just too firm. Bought a Nola. Initially it was so soft and comfy but over the past couple of weeks it too has gotten increasingly firm. I have pressure points in my hips. I keep waking up in pain, rolling over and trying to go back to sleep. Through this experience I’ve learned that I LIKE the memory foam, squishy, get stuck in it feeling. Being cradled in softness is what my body craves. Which is the softest, squishiest, help I’m stuck mattress you’ve reviewed?

  54. Joe – My wife and I are finishing our 100 day trial of the Purple mattress, and find it a tad too soft, waking up each morning with sore shoulders/hips. Besides the lack of support, we love the feel of the Purple Mattress. We are thinking of purchasing the Amerisleep AS2 to provide more support. Is this what you would recommend as a next step, or is there another mattress we should be considering? We are both side/back sleepers, 135 & 190lbs.

    • The AS2 is best for back/stomach sleepers. If you sleep on your side much at all, then you’ll probably find it too firm. In that case, the AS3 might be a better choice.

  55. I am wondering if you know anything about beds by design out of Sioux falls SD or fargo nd. Was looking at the serinty or prestige bed which on the web site says one price and when you go to the store it is another. they seem high but it is local do you have any idea’s or suggestions?

  56. My husband has restless leg syndrome and periodic limb movement disorder. Need less to say, I am exhausted! By reading your reviews, I feel like you are recommending the Loom and Leaf. I searched other comments on motion transfer with RLS and PLMD and wasn’t very successful. Please help!!! Thank you so much.

  57. I currently have a Sealy cushion firm mattress that sleeps hot (probably because of the memory foam). I’m looking at the Aviya mattress because of the 9.7 rating given on your webpage for not sleeping hot. This is a better rating than Saatva and Aviya also costs less. I don’t believe your review discusses the Aviya’s high rating for sleeping cool. I wasn’t sure for the reason it is rates well in this category. Is it because of the polyurethane foam? And, do you agree that the Aviya mattress does not sleep hot? I also like the totally free return policy of Aviya. Thanks for your help. Great website.

  58. Excellent job on the articles/reviews! I’m trying to decide on a mattress, but I keep on ruling out one and finding another one. Any help would be greatly appreciated. I tend to sleep hot, I weight 280, average height, and I mostly sleep on my stomach and sometimes on my sides or back. I have been looking at loom & leaf, lessa, purple, helix, sleep number, etc. I would appreciate any help.

  59. I’ve just ordered a Murphy / Wall bed for our guest room. The mattress will be used infrequently (holidays, etc.) by guests. What recommendations would you have? Should we go cheap because all vertical mattresses will break down or slump in that position? Should we go moderate because the mattress will not be used much and will last a long time? What sort of materials – springs, foam, air, etc. And general firmness for guests. Thoughts?

  60. I’m trying to decide between a Ghostbed (Queen, $850) and Loom and Leaf Memory Foam (Queen, $1099). Money is a big concern! But I want a very solid, long lasting, FIRM, supported bed. (No indenting in foam where body lies!) Does the Ghostbed deliver? Or is there considerably more quality with the Loom and Leaf? I welcome your recommendation as well as suggestions of other brands that fit the bill. THANK YOU! I LOVE YOUR SITE!

  61. My husband and I are seeking out the ideal mattress. We threw away our old Sleep Number and tried a Helix last year; it was too firm. We have been sleeping on a Saatva intercepting for 9 months; now we’ve decided it’s also too firm or just doesn’t give pressure point relief like we need. We are over 40, 5’9″ 175lbs and 6’3″ 210lbs, side and stomach sleepers, and sleep very light. My husband turns a lot and we wake each other up (probably due to pressure points and some minor back and hip issues). He would like to try a split cal king (not easy to find). I was keen on latex, but maybe too firm. Can you recommend a mattress with minimal motion transfer, that is made for side sleepers and doesn’t sleep hot? At this point, we aren’t worried about cost. We just want to be able to sleep next to each other. Thank you! Ann

  62. Hi Joe-
    I have a simmons worldclass trident luxery pillowtop that I think is about to be warranty replaced because it is indented. It was $1900 in 2013 when I bought it. It seems that that model is gone- what do you recommend as a replacement from Simmons?
    Thanks!
    Wendy

      • They are doing a warranty replacement. They just delivered the Queen Beautyrest Platinum Spring Grove Luxury Firm Pillow Top yesterday. I found it significantly harder and after only one night- my lower back is killing me.

  63. Help!! I bought A Brooklyn Bed and woke up stiff. Returned it got a Leesa which I liked even less then the Brooklyn (mells horrible months later). Im a bit heavy and a side sleeper. I don’t want to keep buying beds and returning beds (returning beds is a pain!) I want the next bed to be ‘the one’ . I have read so many reviews my head is spinning: Ghostbed, Bear, Helix, Purple….go back to Brooklyn Bed? We are buying a King and I would like to not spend more then $1000. Besides the smell of the Leesa I didn’t like how low the edge support was. Also did not find it comfortable. Thought I wanted firmer but not sure anymore that that is the answer. Thanks

    • If you are a side sleeper and feel uncomfortable, you should want something softer, right? If you want good edge support and don’t want any smell, then something like the Saatva would be good. If you want more pressure relief, the Purple should be a good choice.

  64. Joe, I have been looking at the Brentwoodhome line of mattresses, specifically the innerspring hybrids Oceano and Del Mar. Do you have any info on these?
    Thanks.

  65. I am buying a new king size mattress and need help. I usually sleep alone. I am 44 years old and I’m in half decent shape from the gym. 5’6″ and 130 lbs. I sleep on my stomach (can’t fall asleep any other way) and sleep very hot. I suffer from insomnia and have chronic lower back pain, likely due to muscle tightness. Please recommend the best mattress for me as I am overwhelmed with the choices. Thanks!

  66. I’m an unhappy other of a serta icomfort (either savant or revolution can’t remember now) split king on adjustable base. I LOVED my bed the first year (tops!) And then it had severe sagging near shoulder area from my butt (where I sat up in the bed and read at night) I’ve since married and now wish I didn’t have the split as most nights I end up in the crack. I finally paid off my bed and am looking for replacement. My husband and I both have back and neck pain that’s relieved when traveling so I know it’s our bed. I’m considering a spring hybrid. I just want suffering to last around ten years (ive had my serta about five years) I’d prefer spending around $1000 but would spend more if they financed the difference (don’t have good credit btw) please help! Also my husband and I sleep “spoon” style. I’m 5-4/ 140 he 5-6/ 200.

  67. Debating between the loom and leaf and the Amerisleep LIberty. Slept on an Angel bed at a friends house one night. Awesome! I have never had a memory foam bed though and have heard mixed reviews from friends. I am a stomach/side sleeper.

  68. Hi Joe-

    Wanted to get your thoughts on sealy posturepedic aldercrest plush euro pillowtop available at Costco. I am a side sleeper and they have a deal right now for mattress and foundation (queen) at $574.99. Do you think it is a good buy? I was reading your section on mattresses for side sleepers and looks like this deal is better than the 4-5 companies you have listed.

    Thank you!
    Meha

  69. How does the new titanflex compare to latex? If it were a blind test would you be able to tell there differences in general feel? Im currently sleeping on a latex mattress at my parents house that is 3inches 22 ild over 3inches 30 ild of blended talalay latex. I find it on the true medium size of plushness and was curious if the new titanflex medium would offer similar feel or if I would have to go to the soft option to get a similar feel.

    Let me know what you think, just basing it off people saying the new titanflex is stiff.

    Thanks!

  70. Hi there…thank you for all the reviews. I am a side sleeper, at least that is how I always prefer to fall asleep, but I don’t really know what happens to my position when I’m not awake so I may end up on my back, but definitely not my stomach.
    I also have significant lower back pain (L4/L5 disc trouble) and want to get a mattress that provides decent lower back support. Not sure how this affects the question about side vs back sleeping.
    Lastly, my bedroom tends to get pretty warm in the summer months to the point where I just sleep with a top sheet and no blanket/comforter. So would prefer a bed that does not run hot. I worry a bit about a foam solution, and have read about hybrids potentially as an answer, or just sticking with an innerspring. I realize some foam options like the Layla are not as hot as other foams, but how do they compare to non-foam options?
    As far as price goes, I am not on a tight budget, but if I do pay more, I want to make sure I’m getting something of value for the extra price.
    Any suggestions would be most appreciated! Thank you!
    Jeff

  71. Hi Joe,

    I am searching for a new mattress. My finalist list is Avocado, Purple, Sleep on Latex, Alexander Hybrid Nest, Saatva and Winkbed. Can you please provide any advice or insight on these mattresses. I know they are all different. FYI: I am 135 pounds, age 43. I sleep mostly on my side and sometimes on my back. I prefer a bed that is not too firm and not too soft. I do not want to sink much. Right now, I sleep on an innerspring mattress that is decades old.

    Thank you,
    Frank

    • Hi Frank – you’re all over the spectrum in terms of feel, material, and price with those options – so not sure how much insight I can provide at this point. I’d really focus on the feel you want, then narrow your focus from there.

  72. We plan to purchase a mattress in near future but are having trouble deciding – there are a number of them.
    We are both pretty light weight, 145 and 120 pound mostly side sleepers so…………

  73. Joe, I am desperate, need to buy 5 mattresses for summer home Don’t want to spend a lot because used only 50 days of the year but want good mattresses that last forever. Believe in quality so don’t want to be cheap just to get cheap! I have a Nature’s Spa mattress that I love and the Schiftmans all from Bloomingdales. Do I buy from Sleepy’s or should I buy from online like Saatva to get better quality? My price point give it take is $1,000 per mattress w box spring. I would like firm beds. Please help, I am dizzy from reviews & websites! Thank you.

    • Hi Kristin – if you like Nature’s Spa/Schiftmans, I stay stick with what you know! Make sure to negotiate, they should give you a much better deal if you’re buying 5 mattresses.

  74. Hi Joe,

    Have you heard of the hybrid mattress by Futon Covers Online? I don’t see it in your list of reviews, and I was wondering if you have heard any positive or negative feedback about them?

    Thanks,

    Keena

  75. I just tried to send a reply to you from an e-mail update that you had sent to me, but I don’t know if that worked, or if it was o.k. to send it that way, to click on REPLY. Did you receive that e-mail from me ? In case you didn’t, I am sending it again on here. I am wondering if you can please tell me which memory foam mattress has the LEAST or NO smell (or off-gas) ? Also, what do I need to get to put the memory foam mattress ON ? I read that the boards are NOT supposed to be more than 4 inches apart. Where can I get that item – the thing to put the mattress on ? Thank You for all your great reviews of mattresses, & other related products. It is a great help.

    • Hi Licia – the smell of the memory foam comes most from when the mattress is compressed, so look for mattresses that are not compressed. For ones that are delivered, Loom & Leaf is probably the best option, or a store-bought brand that comes non-compressed.

      You can put a foam mattress on a platform bed, box spring, or any hard surface. Slats work as well, but good advice, just make sure the slats are not too far apart (check the warranty for the actual mattress you buy for guidance).

  76. I don’t see any information on the site about gel beds like Intellibed or Technogel. How do they compare to memory foam for side sleepers?

  77. Hi Joe!

    We currently own a 2 year old queen “love bed” by Nest bedding.

    Now looking to upgrade to a king. We love our “love bed” but wish it had some more support. We are looking at the saativa and winkbed. We are interested in trying one with springs and I love a traditional Spring bed. We are also curious about the Alexander hybrid but don’t love memory foam.
    We are 210/150 lbs and mostly side sleepers (wife sleeps on her back sometimes) and we need a cool bed with a quilted too.
    Any thoughts?
    Thanks!

  78. My husband and I are at odds about a new mattress. He doesn’t trust any reviews since he thinks they’re all biased. He keeps looking at the Saatva because he’s worried about memory foam being too hot. I’m looking at the Amerisleep because we both mostly sleep on our sides but also on our backs occasionally. We currently have a pretty thick foam topper on our old mattress and have had it for a couple of years or more. We are getting a lot of low back and hip soreness. My question mostly is – isince we’ve been sleeping on the foam topper, is that enough to give a good idea of what an entire foam mattress would be like? At this point, I’m thinking separate beds!

  79. Hi Joe — Lots of great reviews here, but the selection is dizzying!

    I am a stomach-sleeper and my wife is a back-sleeper. We currently have a Sealy pillow-top mattress that is seven years old.

    We find that the pillow-top has “caved in” over the last few years — so it often feels like we’re sleeping on the sides of a hill. Additionally, we find the mattress uncomfortably “hot”, even in the winter.

    Any suggestions for brands / styles that (a) suit both stomach- and back-sleepers, (b) won’t “cave in”, and (c) don’t cost an arm and a leg?

    Thanks, from another Joe!

    • Great to meet another Joe! With the “caving in”, you just want to make sure that you have some very high quality (best gauge is high-density) foams. Pillow tops, to generalize, are not great for this. I’d check out my best mattress page for top picks as a starting point.

  80. Hi Joe. Trying to decide on which to go with. Leaning towards Tuft/needle. I’m a 140 lb stomach /side sleeper, sleep hot, accustomed to innerspring, prefer firmer feel. Rather not spend a fortune but happy to pay for quality and comfort. Thinking of some type of foam bed as I have a lot of back pain. Have looked into purple, tuft/needle, casper, amerisleep, lucid, and loom/leaf. If you chose a bed for me what would it be? Thank you for your help.

  81. Thanks for the quick reply, Joe. For comparison sake, what firmness ratings would you give the Endy, Love & Sleep, and Leesa?

    I also found the Endy sleeps VERY hot. Did you notice L&S or Leesa being cooler? Maybe that’s just the reality of memory foam… But nobody seems to buy/review innerspring anymore and everyone says memory foam is good for bad backs like mine, so I just hope my next one doesn’t overheat.

  82. Hi Joe,

    Thanks so much for this site!

    I am currently in the 100 night trial window with my Endy mattress. Unlike other mattress reviewers who have described the Endy as firm, you rightfully classify the Endy as a soft mattress. Since we have the same taste, I’m hoping you could help me find a replacement for the Endy, which is really hurting my back.

    Price range is no more than $1000 CDN ($750 USD) for a Queen. I’m a back sleeper and don’t want to feel like I’m sinking into the mattress (like the Endy), I want to feel like I’m sleeping ON something. Like my back is getting some push-back. If you call the Endy a 5 on the firmness scale, I guess I’m looking for a 7. The Endy also SUCKS for sex, so I’m looking for something with more bounce and edge support.

    From reading your site, it looks like the Love And Sleep Mattress might tick all my boxes. The shipping and customs to Canada may price me out of it, however. I’d really appreciate any other suggestions!

    Thanks, Joe.

    Corey

    • Hey Corey – Love & Sleep is a great option, it should have some more bounce than the Endy. Leesa should also be in that price range, and may have slightly more bounce, and feel a bit firmer than Endy.

  83. Oops did not mean to send yet. Have you reviewed Turf & Needle’s mattress? Their price point is better than Purple and they seem much the same. It is so hard to tell and your reviews are so well done! I am looking for the best non-innerspring supportive heat etc. I am back sleeper and usually still while my wife is a side sleeper and very active rolling about. Would like to be under $1000.00 but want the best value. And I can never get her to go to stores! Help?! And THANKS!
    Dixon Teter

Leave a Comment