Anyone who is looking for an online mattress has probably heard of Puffy. Their entertaining online commercials are pretty hard to miss!
Puffy now offers three mattresses: the Puffy original, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal. Which one should mattress shoppers choose? Our Puffy vs Puffy Lux vs Puffy Royal mattress comparison should make it an easy decision!
Puffy Mattresses Overview
The Puffy, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal are bed in a box mattresses that all feature soft, cooling foam. The Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal come in hybrid versions but, today, we are talking about the all-foam models. They range in terms of price and the complexity of their design, however. The Puffy is their simplest mattress, the Puffy Lux is their popular middle-of-the-road model, and the Puffy Royal is their most high-end option.
All three mattresses have a lot to offer, but they are going to be a better fit for different types of sleepers:
Who Should Get The Puffy Mattress?
- Those who want to spend less money on their mattress purchase
- Back sleepers who want a mattress that is a bit on the firm side
Who Should Get The Puffy Lux Mattress?
- Average weight side sleepers who want to experience exceptional pressure relief
- Those who prefer more of a classic memory foam feel with their mattress
Who Should Get The Puffy Royal Mattress?
- Lightweight sleepers, children, and teenagers who want a more advanced mattress
- Those who prefer an extremely soft, plush mattress
Puffy Mattresses Video Comparison
Want to see just how puffy the three Puffy mattresses are? Watch our in-depth video comparison – our reviewer, Marten, will discuss the ins and outs of all three mattresses.
Similarities Between The Puffy Mattresses?
The Puffy mattresses are different in a number of ways, but they do have their significant similarities:
- All three mattresses come from the same company, so they have identical sleep trials, warranties, and customer service terms.
- These Puffy, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal are all-foam mattresses and do not feature coils. The Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal mattresses are available as hybrids, however.
- The mattresses feature similar top comfort layers and base layers as well.
Differences Between The Puffy Mattresses?
Now, let’s get into the major differences between the Puffy, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal mattresses:
- There are some height differences – the Puffy Royal is taller than the Puffy Lux which is taller than the Puffy original mattress.
- The Puffy Royal has more layers than the Puffy Lux, and this has more layers than the Puffy original mattress.
- The Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal contain exclusive comfort layers that are not found in the Puffy original mattress.
- The Puffy Royal mattress features a zoned construction, but the Puffy and Puffy Lux do not.
- There are some firmness differences as well – the Puffy Royal is softer than the Puffy Lux, and this is softer than the Puffy original mattress.
- Finally, there are some significant price differences – the Puffy Royal costs more than the Puffy Lux which costs more than the Puffy original.
RELATED: Puffy vs Puffy Lux
Firmness And Feel Differences
We mentioned that there are some firmness differences between the three mattresses – let’s get a little more specific about their firmness scores and how they affect performance.
How Firm Are The Puffy Mattresses?
In our experience, the Puffy mattress feels like a 7/10 and is just a bit firmer-than-average. The Puffy Lux mattress feels like a 6.5/10, which is basically medium-firm. The Puffy Royal is the softest of the three mattresses and feels like a 6/10, softer-than-average.
The thing to note is these three mattresses will feel firmer or softer depending on the weight of the person sleeping on them. Lighter people might find all three mattresses to be softer than what we experienced, and heavier people might find them to be firmer.
Sleeping On The Puffy Mattresses
Back sleeping on the three Puffy mattresses does feel quite different for us. The Puffy mattress is the firmest, but it still lets our hips sink in a fair amount, and we can also feel some contouring from the top memory foam layer. With the Puffy Lux, our hips sink a bit further, and we feel even more contouring from the top memory foam layers. The Puffy Royal is too soft for us when we are back sleeping, and we feel ourselves dropping through the mattress without getting the proper support.
Side sleeping, we feel most comfortable when we are lying on the Puffy Lux mattress. It’s a bit of a Goldilocks situation here – the Puffy original mattress is too firm and we feel too much pressure on our shoulders and hips. The Puffy Royal is too soft for us and, while are we aren’t feeling pressure on our shoulders and hips, we aren’t getting enough support to keep our bodies properly aligned. With the Puffy Lux mattress, we are feeling little pressure on our shoulders and hips, and the mattress is also giving us enough support at the same time.
Stomach sleeping, we feel the best on the Puffy original mattress because it is the firmest of the three mattresses, and it is providing the best support. That being said, we could still use a bit more support under our hips as they are bowing into the mattress a bit.
What Do The Puffy Mattresses Feel Like?
The Puffy mattresses feature some similar materials, but they really are quite different with regard to their feel. The Puffy original mattress features a balanced foam feel that is quite responsive, and this makes it easy to move around on the mattress. The Puffy Lux mattress boasts a classic memory foam feel that lets us slowly sink in but makes it harder to move around. The Puffy Royal is the plushest of the three mattresses and has a fluffy, cloud-like feel; it is not very responsive, so it is difficult to mover around and change positions at night.
Average Weight Sleepers – 130 lbs – 230 lbs
Average weight back sleepers are going to feel the best balance of comfort and support on the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses. Unless they are closer to 130 lbs, they will probably not get enough support from the Puffy Royal and could feel themselves drop into the mattress.
Side sleeping, most average weight people will prefer the Puffy Lux over the Puffy and Puffy Royal mattresses. Again, if they are on the lighter end of the spectrum, they could get enjoy nice pressure relief from the fluffy Puffy Royal mattress.
Stomach sleeping, average weight people will feel the best support on the Puffy original mattress but, if they are closer to 230 lbs, they still might need a more supportive mattress overall.
Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230 lbs
Heavyweight back sleepers could get enough support when they are on the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses but, if they are closer to 275 lbs or more, they will require a mattress with coils. The Puffy Royal will definitely feel too soft for heavyweight back sleepers, and they will not get enough support.
Heavyweight side sleepers will prefer the Puffy Lux mattress as it will give them both pressure relief and support between their ribs and hips. That being said, heavier people who are 275 lbs or more could “bottom out” and press into the support layers; this could feel very uncomfortable.
Stomach sleeping, heavyweight people will not get enough support from any of these mattresses, and they will want to seek out a firmer mattress with coils in the construction.
Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130 lbs
Lightweight people will get enough comfort and support back sleeping on all three mattresses, so it really comes down to what firmness and feel they are looking for. If they want something firm and balanced, the Puffy original mattress will be the way to go. If they want something medium-firm with a slow-moving feel, the Puffy Lux mattress will be better. If they prefer something very soft and plush, the Puffy Royal mattress will be right for them.
Side sleeping, most lightweight people should prefer the Puffy Lux and Puffy Royal mattresses; the Puffy original might feel too firm for them, but the Lux and Royal should provide excellent pressure relief.
Stomach sleeping, lightweight people should opt for either the Puffy or Puffy Lux mattress; the Puffy Royal will probably feel too soft for them in this position.
Mattress Construction Differences
Now, let’s unzip the covers of the three Puffy mattresses and see exactly what’s inside!
All three mattresses feature a very similar cover that is soft, thin, and breathable – it won’t affect the overall feel of these mattresses too much.
The top comfort layer of the Puffy original mattress is something called Cooling Cloud™ foam (it is basically memory foam with a gel infusion to help with cooling). Below that, there is Climate Comfort™ foam which is more responsive and also designed to help with heat dissipation.
The Puffy Lux features the same two layers plus a layer of Plush Dual Cloud foam – this foam is exclusive to the Puffy Lux and adds some more plushness and pressure relief to the top of the mattress.
The top two layers of the Puffy Royal are exclusive to this mattress – on top, there is a layer of slow-moving foam that is infused with cooling beads; below that, there is a layer of more responsive foam that adds some bounce to the top of the mattress.
Then there is a layer of Climate Comfort™ foam on top of zoned polyfoam (this is designed to make the mattress feel firmer and softer in different areas of the mattress). The idea behind this technology is to offer the right amount of comfort and support no matter what position a person is sleeping in.
All three Puffy mattresses feature a similar Firm Core Support base layer that is durable and, yes, supportive.
The Puffy mattress is 10″ tall, the Puffy Lux is 12″ tall, and the Puffy Royal is 14″ tall.
Puffy Mattresses Size Options And Price
For the most up-to-date sizing and price information, make sure to take a look at the following charts:
|Twin||39″ x 75″ x 10″||$795|
|Twin XL||39″ x 80″ x 10″||$825|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 10″||$995|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 10″||$1150|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 10″||$1350|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 10″||$1350|
|Twin||39″ x 75″ x 12″||$1445|
|Twin XL||39″ x 80″ x 12″||$1495|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 12″||$1595|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 12″||$1795|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 12″||$1995|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 12″||$1995|
|Twin||39″ x 75″ x 14″||$1645|
|Twin XL||39″ x 80″ x 14″||$1745|
|Full||54″ x 75″ x 14″||$2445|
|Queen||60″ x 80″ x 14″||$2695|
|King||76″ x 80″ x 14″||$2995|
|California King||72″ x 84″ x 14″||$2995|
Puffy Mattresses Performance Differences
We put the Puffy mattresses to the test to see how they performed with regard to cooling, motion transfer, and edge support – let’s see how they did!
Sleeping Hot Or Cold
The Puffy, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal are all-foam mattresses, so they are not the most breathable. Also, given that they feature soft memory foam, they will undoubtedly trap some heat – while they do feature cooling gel infusions, hot sleepers might have issues overheating at night.
Based on our tests, the Puffy Lux handles motion transfer better than the Puffy and Puffy Royal mattresses – it has two layers of slow-moving foam toward the top, and these types of foam are usually best at isolating motion.
Because of this, the Puffy Lux should be the best mattress for couples.
The Puffy Lux also wins out when we are talking about edge support – we feel much more secure when we are sitting and lying down near the edge of this mattress. The Puffy mattress also features some decent edge support, but the Puffy Royal makes us feel like we are going to roll onto the floor.
The Puffy Royal is the most substantial of these three mattresses and features the most complex construction. With its more luxurious, high-end design, it might last longer than the Puffy and Puffy Lux mattresses.
These are all-foam bed in a box mattresses, so we were not surprised when there was some off-gassing – this is totally normal, however, and the smell did dissipate after 48 hours.
Given that the Puffy, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal are all-foam mattresses, we did not expect them to make any noise when we moved around. All three mattresses were indeed very quiet when we rolled around and changed positions.
Couples who need the best mattress for sex usually want to find something that is responsive and makes it easier to move around. Out of these three, the Puffy original mattress is the bounciest and does not let us sink in so far; sexual partners should be able to move around on the mattress without feeling trapped.
The Puffy, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal mattresses come with a 101-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty.
Puffy Mattresses FAQs
Now, we would like to answer some of the most frequently asked questions about the Puffy, Puffy Lux, and Puffy Royal mattresses:
Are the Puffy mattresses good?
In our opinion, the Puffy mattresses are indeed good; they are all high-quality mattresses that feature some high-end, exclusive materials. Given that they have three models, customers have three opportunities to find the right firmness and feel for their situation.
How much do the Puffy mattresses cost?
For a Queen, the Puffy mattress costs around $1150, the Puffy Lux costs around $1800, and the Puffy Royal costs around $2700.
Do the Puffy mattresses smell?
The Puffy mattresses come in a box and are compressed and wrapped in plastic. They do have a slight chemical smell when we first unpacked them, but this went away after 48 hours.