DreamCloud vs Puffy – Which Is Best For You?

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

If you’ve almost reached the end of your mattress shopping journey, and you just have to decide between the DreamCloud and Puffy mattresses, you’ve come to the right place.

My DreamCloud vs Puffy mattress comparison will discuss their similarities, differences, and so much more. By the end of this review, you should know which of these online mattresses is right for you!

Product
Firmness
Score
DreamCloud Original Mattress
Firm: 7.5/10
3.8/5
Puffy Mattress
Medium-firm: 7/10
3.9/5
Product
DreamCloud Original Mattress
Firmness
Firm: 7.5/10
Score
3.8/5
Product
Puffy Mattress
Firmness
Medium-firm: 7/10
Score
3.9/5

DreamCloud vs Puffy Mattress Overview

DreamCloud and Puffy are two of the most popular bed-in-a-box brands and for good reason. DreamCloud produces hybrid mattresses that are high-quality, durable, and supportive. You can choose between three comfortable models – the DreamCloud, DreamCloud Premier, and DreamCloud Premier Rest. Puffy is known for mattresses that provide cloud-like comfort and cooling. The brand offers the all-foam Puffy as well as the Puffy Lux Hybrid and Puffy Royal Hybrid mattresses.

This review will focus primarily on the DreamCloud and Puffy base models. However, read to the end to see how the other DreamCloud and Puffy models compare to one another.

Who Should Get The DreamCloud?

  • Stomach sleepers
  • Shoppers who want to spend less
  • Hot sleepers

Who Should Get The Puffy?

  • Light and medium weight side sleepers
  • Those who like something softer
  • Fans of all-foam mattresses

Similarities Between The DreamCloud and Puffy Mattresses

First off, there is some crossover between the DreamCloud and Puffy:

  • DreamCloud and Puffy are both popular online mattress brands.
  • Both mattresses offer a balance of comfort and support.
  • They both come with a lifetime warranty.
  • The DreamCloud and Puffy are both responsive mattresses.

Differences Between The DreamCloud and Puffy Mattresses

Now, let’s look at the major differences between these two mattresses:

  • The DreamCloud is firmer than the Puffy.
  • The Puffy is an all-foam mattress, while the DreamCloud is a hybrid.
  • The DreamCloud is more breathable than the Puffy.
  • The Puffy costs more than the DreamCloud.

DreamCloud and Puffy Firmness and Feel Differences

If you compare the firmness and feel of the DreamCloud and Puffy, you’ll see how they are a better fit for certain types of sleepers.

How Firm Are The DreamCloud and Puffy Mattresses?

On a firmness scale of 1-10, the DreamCloud mattress scores a 7.5/10. This is firmer than 6.5/10, the standard score for medium-firm. The mattress features some high-density foams and supportive coils that help create a firmer sleeping surface.

The Puffy mattress is a bit softer than the DreamCloud and scores a 7/10. The top layers are a bit plusher than what you find on the DreamCloud mattress. Because of this, the Puffy has some more give and lets you sink in a bit more.

Sleeping On the DreamCloud and Puffy Mattresses

I slept on both mattresses, and tried them out in all three sleeping positions. When I slept on my back on the DreamCloud, it was just comfortable and supportive enough for me. While it’s a firmer mattress, my hips still sank into the pillow top while the rest of the mattress supported my body.

Side sleeping, the DreamCloud was too firm for me. This is unsurprising as softer mattresses are usually better for side sleeping. The firmer DreamCloud led to some pressure build-up around my shoulders and hips.

A man sleeps on his side on the DreamCloud

Stomach sleeping, the DreamCloud was decently supportive. However, I’m a larger person and weigh 270 lb. As I’ll discuss below, average weight and lightweight stomach sleepers should feel better support than I did.

Moving to the Puffy mattress, I also found it to be a good match for back sleeping. I felt the top foam layers conform to my curves while the firmer layers beneath supported me.

Side sleeping on the Puffy, I felt some better pressure relief than I felt on the DreamCloud mattress. That being said, I still pushed far into the mattress and felt some discomfort around my shoulders and hips. Read below to see how this might differ for lightweight and average weight side sleepers.

A man sleeps on his side on the Puffy mattress

Stomach sleeping, the Puffy was too soft for my taste. I felt my hips sink down into the mattress, and this caused some pain in my lower back.

What Do The DreamCloud and Puffy Mattresses Feel Like?

The DreamCloud mattress has a bouncy hybrid feel that makes it very easy to move around. Lying down, it feels more like I am lying on top of the mattress instead of in the mattress. While the mattress is firmer, you also get a bit of that plush pillow top feel right on top.

Without coils, the Puffy is not quite as bouncy as the DreamCloud mattress. However, it is still a responsive mattress with a balanced foam feel. I sank in a fair bit, but I never felt like I was stuck.

Average Weight Sleepers – 130 lb – 230 lb

Average weight back sleepers should prefer sleeping on the Puffy mattress. The DreamCloud mattress might feel too firm for back sleepers in this weight range, and they could feel their hips being pushed out of the mattress. The softer Puffy mattress should provide an even better balance of comfort and support.

Side sleeping, the Puffy is also going to be the winner. It is softer than the DreamCloud and should feel even softer for average weight people. They won’t press as far into the mattress as a heavier person might, so they should mostly feel soft pressure relief on their shoulders and hips.

Average weight stomach sleepers are going to want to choose the DreamCloud mattress. It will offer better support than the Puffy mattress and should prevent the hips from sinking too far into the mattress.

Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230 lb

Heavyweight back sleepers should feel more supported on the DreamCloud mattress. Without coils, the Puffy mattress might not be able to handle those heavier weights. The Puffy mattress might not be a bad match for those who weigh less than 275 lb, but the DreamCloud should be the better back sleeper option overall.

Side sleeping, neither of these mattresses are going to work well for heavier people. If you are a larger side sleeper, you will probably feel some serious pressure on your shoulders and hips. Take a look at one of our best mattresses for heavy people for some more options.

Heavier stomach sleepers should feel better support on the DreamCloud mattress. However, it still might not be firm and supportive enough for heavier bodies. If you are bigger-bodied and sleep on your stomach, you may need to find another mattress.

Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130 lb

Lightweight back sleepers should also feel more comfortable on the Puffy mattress. The soft top layers will allow their hips to sink in the right. The DreamCloud will probably feel too firm for the majority of lightweight back sleepers.

Lightweight side sleepers should also prefer the Puffy mattress. The soft foam layers will offer better pressure relief than the top layers of the DreamCloud.

Finally, stomach sleeping, lightweight people could fare well on both mattresses. The DreamCloud will be more supportive, but the Puffy could also offer enough support for lightweight stomach sleepers.

DreamCloud and Puffy Construction Differences

Now, let’s pull back the covers of these two mattresses and see what is going on inside.

Cover

The DreamCloud’s cashmere cover is one of its highlights. It is very soft and gives the mattress a luxurious look and feel. It is also breathable and allows for air to flow through the top of the mattress.

The Puffy features a Cloud cover that is made of hypoallergenic fabric and is thin and breathable as well. It does not affect the overall feel of the mattress.

Comfort Layers

The DreamCloud’s first layer is a plush pillow top. The cover is quilted with Contouring Soft foam that is designed to offer some nice comfort. Below that, the mattress contains a memory foam layer that is gel-infused to help with cooling. This sits atop a Dynamic Response layer which helps prevent you from bottoming out on the mattress.

A side shot of the DreamCloud mattress

The Puffy’s top comfort layer contains Cooling Cloud foam. This material is soft and infused with cooling gel. Below that, Climate Comfort foam acts as a transition layer and also fights overheating.

A cross section shot of the Puffy mattress

Support Layers

The DreamCloud contains individually-wrapped coils that are supportive and promote airflow through the mattress. This rests on a thin layer of base foam that prevents the coils from digging into your bed frame.

The Puffy contains thick base foam in its support layer. It is high-density and much firmer than the foams found in the comfort layer.

Mattress Height

The DreamCloud is 14” tall, and the Puffy is 10” tall.

DreamCloud and Puffy Size and Price Options

See our handy charts for the most up-to-date size and price info.

DreamCloud 

Size Dimensions Price
Twin 38" x 75" C$899.00
Twin XL 38" x 80" C$999.00
Full 54" x 75" C$1099.00
Queen 60" x 80" C$1199.00
King 76" x 80" C$1499.00
California King 72" x 84" C$1499.00

Puffy

Size Dimensions Price
Twin 39" x 75" C$899.00
Twin XL 38" x 80" C$949.00
Full 54” x 75” C$1099.00
Queen 60" x 80" C$1299.00
King 76" x 80" C$1449.00
California King 72" x 84" C$1449.00

DreamCloud and Puffy Performance Differences

I ran the DreamCloud and Puffy through a number of tests to see how they perform with regard to cooling, motion transfer, and other criteria. Let’s see how they did!

Sleeping Hot or Cold

While the DreamCloud and Puffy both feature gel memory foam and other breathable materials, the DreamCloud should sleep a bit cooler. This is because of the coils you find in its support layer. They will allow for more airflow than the foam you find in the Puffy’s support layer.

You should be sleeping cooler on the DreamCloud mattress. See our best cooling mattresses for more options.

Motion Transfer

Motion transfer is important to consider if you need a mattress for couples. Motion transfer occurs when one partner moves around on a mattress, and their partner feels it on the other’s side of the mattress. Some mattresses are better at handling this motion transfer, and others are not.

Between the two mattresses, the Puffy boasts the better motion isolation. I saw less motion transfer on the Puffy, mostly due to its all-foam construction. All-foam, memory foam mattresses perform better with motion isolation, and the Puffy is no exception.

Edge Support

Couples should also think about edge support when they’re shopping for a mattress. A mattress with good edge support will give you and your partner more room to sleep.

Neither mattress featured fantastic edge support. Sitting near the edge of the DreamCloud and Puffy, I felt the mattresses collapse under my weight.

Lying down near the edge of the DreamCloud, I also felt a bit like I would roll off. I felt more secure lying down near the edge of the Puffy, but the support still wasn’t the best.

A man sits near the edge of the Puffy mattress

Durability

The DreamCloud and Puffy mattresses both feature some high-quality materials and should last for at least 7 years. The DreamCloud should last a bit longer because it contains coils. These usually add some life to a bed-in-a-box mattress.

Off-gassing

Off-gassing occurs when you unbox most online mattresses. The trapped gasses escape the now-unwrapped mattress and can let off a chemical smell. This is normal, and the smell will usually go away after 48 hours.

There was some off-gassing with both the DreamCloud and the Puffy. I gave both mattresses a few days to completely off-gas and expand, and there were no smells after that.

Noise

When I moved around on the DreamCloud and Puffy mattresses, I didn’t hear any noise. There were no squeaks, creaks, or groans.

Keep in mind that hybrid mattresses like the DreamCloud might start to squeak after you have had them for a few years. This happens when you’ve slept on a mattress for a while, and the coils start to weaken.

Sex

If you want a great mattress for sex, find a bouncy, responsive mattress. This will make it easier for you and your partner to move around.

While both mattresses should be good for sex, the DreamCloud is the better option. It is firmer, bouncier, and does not let you sink in so far. It will be even easier to move around on the DreamCloud.

Company Policies

Let’s take a closer look at DreamCloud and Puffy’s fine print.

Warranty Info

The DreamCloud and Puffy both come with lifetime warranties.

Sleep Trial

DreamCloud offers a 365-night sleep trial, while Puffy offers a 101-night sleep trial.

Return Policy

You get free shipping and returns with the DreamCloud and Puffy mattresses.

How Do the Other DreamCloud and Puffy Mattresses Compare?

Keep reading to see how the other DreamCloud mattresses stack up against the corresponding Puffy mattresses.

DreamCloud Premier vs Puffy Lux Hybrid

The DreamCloud Premier is one step up from the DreamCloud Original mattress. It contains more layers of foam and feels like a 6.5/10, medium-firm. Like the DreamCloud Original, it is also a responsive mattress with a pillow top feel.

A side shot of the DreamCloud Premier

The Puffy Lux Hybrid is the next model in Puffy’s line of cloud-like mattresses. It features coils, and an extra layer of soft foam not found in the Puffy Original mattress. Like the DreamCloud Premier, it has a good balance of comfort and support and scores a 6.5/10 on our firmness scale. Unlike the DreamCloud Premier, it has more of a foam feel on top of the mattress. Finally, it costs more than the DreamCloud Premier.

A cross section shot of the Puffy Lux Hybrid mattress

Who Should Get The DreamCloud Premier?

  • Fans of a pillow top feel
  • Those who want to spend less money.

Who Should Get The Puffy Lux Hybrid?

  • Shoppers who prefer a soft foam feel

DreamCloud Premier Rest vs Puffy Royal Hybrid

The DreamCloud Premier Rest is the brand’s most luxurious mattress. It features even more foam layers than the DreamCloud Premier and feels like a 6/10, softer-than-average. With its more high-end design, the DreamCloud Premier Rest costs more than the DreamCloud Premier.

A man shows the side construction of the DreamCloud Premier Rest

The Puffy Royal Hybrid is the top-of-the-line Puffy model that contains advanced cooling features and more pressure-relieving foam layers. It is a bit firmer than the DreamCloud Premier Rest with a score of 6.5/10, medium-firm. It also costs more than the DreamCloud Premier Rest.

A cross-section shot of the Puffy Royal Hybrid

Who Should Get The DreamCloud Premier Rest?

  • Those who want a luxury mattress for a value price
  • Side sleepers
  • Fans of softer mattresses

Who Should Get The Puffy Royal Hybrid?

  • Back sleepers
  • Hot sleepers
  • Fans of medium-firm mattresses

FAQs

Which mattress is better, the DreamCloud or the Puffy?

The DreamCloud and Puffy are both great online mattresses, but they are going to work better for different people. The DreamCloud will be better for stomach sleepers, hot sleepers, and value shoppers. The Puffy will work better for light- and medium-weight side sleepers, fans of softer mattresses, and those who like all-foam designs.

Can you flip the DreamCloud and Puffy mattresses?

No, you cannot flip the DreamCloud and Puffy mattresses. They should only lie with their support layers on the bottom and their comfort layers on top.

How long will the DreamCloud and Puffy mattresses last?

The DreamCloud and Puffy mattresses should both last for at least 7 years. The DreamCloud should last even longer due to its more durable hybrid construction.

Gravatar for Marten Carlson

Marten Carlson

Marten is the Lead Reviewer at Mattress Clarity. He is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and covers the mattress industry as well as sleep science news. He is specifically interested in the connection between sleep and overall health. Marten has written for media publications like Consequence of Sound and received a master’s degree in Film Studies from Emory University. He comes from Franklin, Indiana, and spends all the time he can writing, directing, and acting in films.