At some point in our lives, many of us have spent late nights cramming for that big final exam. Every extra minute seems like a chance to grasp that piece of information that could make the difference between a B+ and an A-. However, two new studies at the University of Baylor suggest these cram sessions may be counterproductive.
In these studies, the researchers asked psychology and interior design students (respectively) to try and sleep at least eight hours per night during finals week. To help incentivize this behavior, the students received extra credit points just for getting enough sleep.
We spoke with Michael Scullin, PhD, assistant professor of psychology and neuroscience and director of Baylor’s Sleep Neuroscience and Cognition Laboratory. Scullin, who was involved with both studies, told Mattress Clarity by email that “Sleeping more during final exams week does not hurt one’s grade. If anything, students do a few points better on their final exam.”
Catching Some Shut-Eye During Finals Week
In both studies, student participants wore sleep tracking devices for a five-night period during final exams and attempted to sleep at least eight hours per night.
During the first study, Scullin invited 34 of his undergraduate psychology students to participate in the challenge. If they averaged at least eight hours of sleep over five nights, they would receive eight extra credit points.
l i g h t p o e t/Shutterstock
Out of this group, 24 decided to take the challenge, and 17 averaged more than eight hours of sleep per night. Without taking the extra points into effect, those who slept eight hours or more performed better on the final exam when compared to the group that did not participate
In the second study, Scullin collaborated with lead author Elise King, PhD, assistant professor of interior design at Baylor University (1).
Twenty-two interior design undergraduates participated in a similar incentivized study. If the students slept over eight hours per night, they would receive extra credit points. If they slept between seven and 7.9 hours, they would receive no points. Lastly, they were told they would see a grade reduction if they slept less than seven hours. According to the researchers, there were no actual grade reductions.
Compared with 22 non-incentivized students, the incentivized students slept, on average, 98 more minutes a night. Also, compared with their regular sleep schedules during the rest of the semester, these incentivized students slept 82 minutes more.
The incentivized students performed just as well on their final exams/projects as the non-incentivized students. In addition, those subjects who showed regular, healthy sleep scored even higher.
Scullin told us that one difference between the two studies was that the psychology students learned about the importance of sleep quality in the classroom, while the interior design students did not. However, according to Scullin, simply getting enough sleep was enough to see upticks in academic performance.
RELATED: The Effects Of School Start Times On Sleep
“You do not have to receive detailed education in sleep science to be able to change your behaviors to improve your sleep,” he says. “When we attempted this challenge in freshmen interior design majors, they too were successful on the challenge.”
In the end, it really comes down to motivation. “If students are not incentivized to sleep well then almost none of them will,” Scullin explains. “However, with the opportunity to earn extra credit, 90 percent of students will become seven-hour sleepers and 50 percent will become eight to nine-hour sleepers.”
In both studies, the researchers were surprised by how much the incentives worked and how many students succeeded. “We honestly didn’t know if anyone would be successful on the challenge,” he says. “When I ask my colleagues and students to predict the results, most say they think about 15 percent of students would be successful. I think it’s an exciting, proof of principle finding that if we have a really good motivation then we will change our behaviors, even something that is so ingrained in our culture such as sleep deprivation during finals week.”
More Research Is Needed
This is not the first time Scullin and King have studied the effect sleep has on university students’ academic performance. Their previous work focused on interior design students and how irregular sleep patterns were a detriment to creative work (2).
While this could be another step toward understanding the important connection between healthy sleep and cognitive function, Scullin believes there is still more work to be done.
“Only 1/4 of college students receive any information about sleep health from their university, so that by itself is a hurdle,” he says. “If universities will ‘buy in’ that they should educate students about sleep health then they should concomitantly address motivational and cultural issues to help students engage in healthy sleep on a consistent basis.”
“The Eight Hour Sleep Challenge During Final Exams Week,” was published in the journal Teaching of Psychology. “The 8‐Hour Challenge: Incentivizing Sleep during End‐of‐Term Assessments,” was published in the Journal of Interior Design.
[Editor’s Note: The information provided should not be considered a substitute for professional advice. Please consult a sleep doctor or other medical expert if you have questions related to your own health.]
Featured image: Dragon Images/Shutterstock
- King, Elise, et al., “The 8‐Hour Challenge: Incentivizing Sleep during End‐of‐Term Assessments.” Journal of Interior Design, 18 Nov. 2018.
- King, Elise, et al. “Sleep in Studio Based Courses: Outcomes for Creativity Task Performance.” Journal of Interior Design, vol. 42, no. 4, 21 Apr. 2017, pp. 5–27.
Latest posts by Marten Carlson (see all)
- Purple Gravity Weighted Blanket Review – Heavy Pressure? - December 13, 2019
- Brooklyn Bedding Weighted Blanket Review – A Good Value? - December 11, 2019
- Quilt Vs Comforter – Which Reigns Supreme? - December 5, 2019