Mattress Protectors: SafeRest vs Protect-A-Bed

by

| Updated:

November 22, 2022

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site. See our disclosure page for more information.

There is one major difference between the SafeRest Premium mattress protector and the Protect-A-Bed AllerZip mattress protector. While they will both keep a mattress surface free from allergens, dust mites and liquid damage, one protector can do even more. This comparison will go over the main similarities and differences to help consumers make a more informed decision.

Key Similarities

Waterproof surface
Dust mite and allergen protection
Machine washable, tumble low dry heat
Vinyl, PVC and Phthalate free
10-year warranty

SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector

SafeRest’s Premium Mattress Protector combines waterproof and allergen protection with cotton terry comfort.

Read Full Review

Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Protector

The Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Protector does a great job of protecting your mattress from allergens, bed bugs, and water or other liquids. It’s also certified allergy and asthma friendly and lab tested to prevent bed bugs.

Mattress Clarity Score

4.10 / 5

Read Full Review

Key Differences

SafeRest

Fitted sheet style (protection on five sides)
Hypoallergenic cotton terry surface fabric
Can fit mattresses up to 18 inches thick
SafeRest offers Invisa-Shield Technology which is supposed to protect your mattress without being able to feel it under your sheets.
Sizing: SafeRest offers standard sizes
Comes with a 200+ Wash Durability Rating
Queen size retails for ~$69.95 (See current pricing on Amazon)

The full SafeRest Mattress Protector review is available here.

SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector Review — SafeRest’s protector comes with a cotton terry surface fabric.

Protect-A-Bed

Encasement mattress with 6-Sided Miracle Membrane® barrier that prevents mold, mildew, dust mites, pet dander, and pollen
100% polyester sleep surface
Two depths to choose from (6-inch or 9-inch)
Certified Asthma and Allergy Friendly™ by the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America (AAFA)
Certified bed bug proof
Categorized as an FDA Class 1 Medical Device
Multiple sizes available, including sofa protectors
Queen size retails for ~$129.95 (See current pricing on Amazon)

The full Protect-A-Bed Mattress Protector review is available here.

Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Protector Review — Protect-A-Bed protector is made of 100% polyester material

Pros and Cons of Each Protector

Who Might Want the SafeRest…

Those who want a protector that goes on a mattress like a fitted sheet
People who have a thicker mattress (can fit up to 18-inch mattresses)
Those who want a protector with a cotton terry surface
People who want a protector that costs less than $100 (for a Queen)
Those who want a protector with a 200+ Wash Durability Rating.

SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector

SafeRest’s Premium Mattress Protector combines waterproof and allergen protection with cotton terry comfort.

Read Full Review

SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector Review

Who Might Want Protect-A-Bed…

Those who want an encasement mattress that can be sealed to protect against bed bugs
People who want a protector that is Certified Asthma and Allergy Friendly™ by the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America (AAFA)
Those who want to cover a unique mattress – like a sofa mattress
People who want a super snug fit on the mattress (protector comes in two depth options)

Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Protector

The Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Protector does a great job of protecting your mattress from allergens, bed bugs, and water or other liquids. It’s also certified allergy and asthma friendly and lab tested to prevent bed bugs.

Mattress Clarity Score

4.10 / 5

Read Full Review

ProtectABedAllerZipReviewPackage — This is my review of the Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Encasement. This encasement mattress protector prevents allergens like dust mites and pollen as well as bed bugs and liquid from entering your mattress on all six sides. It’s smooth and has polyester lining and polyeurthane interior lining. It is a little expensive at over $100 for a protector but it’s easy to care for and can be completely sealed. It’s also considered a medical device and is certified asthma and allergy friendly.

[rwp-table id=”0″]

Overall

These protectors are so different that most people’s choice will most likely come down to personal needs and priorities. For people who are looking for a mattress that is waterproof, easy to put on and off, easy to care for and relatively affordable, the SafeRest protector may be the ideal option.

SafeRest Premium Mattress Protector Review — SafeRest protector fits mattresses up to 18-inches thick (10-inch thick mattress used in the review).

SafeRest’s protector is a straightforward protector that will go on a mattress like a fitted sheet and will keep the surface safe from liquid damage and allergies. However, some people may need a more serious mattress protector. What does a “serious” protector mean? This term applies to people with the following issues:

Potential for bed bugs
Major allergy or asthma issues
Potential for a lot of liquid damage

Protect-A-Bed AllerZip Smooth Mattress Protector Review — Protect-A-Bed AllerZip is an encasement protector that covers all six sides of the mattress

Protect-A-Bed Allerzip has the option to completely seal off the mattress from the outside world. It’s listed as a medical device and has been certified and lab tested to keep the mattress truly protected from allergens and asthma. It comes with a steeper price tag at $12.95 for a Queen – nearly double the cost of the SafeRest protector – but it offers much more. I personally preferred the overall fit and functionality of the Protect-A-Bed Allerzip protector. While I did not care for the price tag, for the value and quality I think it’s definitely worth the money. Those looking for something simpler, the SafeRest protect may be a good fit.

Subscribe to Mattress Clarity!

Get special coupons, discounts, and giveaways!

Katie Golde

Katie Golde

Senior Digital Content Manager/Managing Editor

About Author

Katie Golde is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and previously served Managing Editor and Head of Sleep Research for Mattress Clarity. She handled the daily operations of the site and you’ll still see her in plenty of reviews, from mattresses to travel pillow and bed pillow reviews – plus the occasional How-To video. In addition, Katie reported, writed, and edited sleep health and sleep industry news for the site.

Since joining the Mattress Clarity team in 2016, she has reviewed hundreds of sleep products, like bed pillows and mattresses and written over 200 sleep-related stories for the site. She probably knows more about bamboo sheets and bed pillows than any one person should.

Katie has been writing about wellness-related topics, including sleep, for the last eight years. The first sleep story she wrote covered the best and worst foods to eat before bed. Her previous work can be found in print and online publications like Discover Magazine, USA Today, Bustle and The Huffington Post.

She has a bachelor’s degree in Sociology from Northwestern University and a master’s degree in Journalism with a focus on Interactive Publishing from Northwestern’s Medill School of Journalism as well. During her graduate studies, Katie focused on health and science reporting and she received the G.D. Crain Award for demonstrating leadership, management, and entrepreneurial excellence during her final innovation project.

Education & Credentials