Casper Pillow Review

Note: Casper provided a loan to our company to acquire another site, Sleepopolis.com. On Mattress Clarity, we receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site (at no cost to the buyer). See our disclosure page for our list of comped products and affiliate programs.

Just when I think I’ve seen every type of pillow imaginable, Casper debuts its “pillow in a pillow” design. The outer pillow is designed to be soft and breathable, and the inner pillow is firmer and more supportive.

I found the entire thing perfectly comfortable and breathable. Read on for my full review.

Key Features

  • Two sizes: Standard and King
  • The Standard pillow is 18” x 26” with a 2” gusset
  • The King Size is 18” x 34” with a 2” gusset
  • Inner and Outer Cover Fabric: 100 percent Supima Cotton, percale weave
  • Outer Filling: Polyester fibers
  • Inner Filling: Nearly one billion coated fibers
  • Care: Separate inner and outer pillows and machine wash and dry (more details below)
  • Price: $55 Standard, $65 King

Who Makes It?

The pillow is a product from Casper, a mattress and bedding company that was one of the first to start selling memory foam mattresses direct to customers online.

Casper now offers other bedding products in addition to pillows, including sheets, multiple mattresses, and a duvet. Check out our review of the original Casper mattress to learn more.

Pros

  • Soft and breathable fabric
  • Can machine wash and dry the entire pillow
  • Unique fiber filling that doesn’t lump or clump
  • Designed to work with all sleep positions

Cons

  • Cannot adjust filling
  • May need consistent fluffing to avoid falling flat
  • Filling may not be as firm or dense as desired by some

Pillow Construction

Imagine taking a firm pillow and wrapping it around a soft duvet cover. This is one way to describe the Casper pillow’s construction. I’ve broken down the parts so you can see them individually.

Covers: The fabric of the inner and outer pillow is made with 100 percent Supima cotton. This is the same cotton used in their sheets as well.

The cotton has a percale weave, which makes it breathable and is designed to give you a crisp feeling.

RELATED: Best Pillow For Side Sleepers

Inner Pillow: The inner core of Casper’s pillow is filled with low-friction, silky fibers designed with contouring and responsive support in mind. Per the company, this is supposed to give the pillow an “adaptive, liquid-like feel that responds to your movements through the night.”

The fibers are blown into the pillow, and Casper says this will prevent them from clumping so the pillow can easily be brought back to its original loft with a quick fluff.

Outer Pillow: The outer layer is filled with the same fibers as the Inner Pillow core. This is designed to give protection to the inner layer and provided added cushion, according to Casper.

Gusset: A gusset is an extra piece of material that helps expand or give structure to a pillow, according to Casper. This gives their pillow a side panel in addition to a top and bottom. Casper added a 2” gusset to give the filling more space to move around and to provide neck support and better spine alignment

Care

One of the best features of the Casper pillow is that you can wash the entire thing. Here’s how Casper recommends you care for your pillow:

Step 1: Unzip the outer pillow and remove the inner pillow.
Step 2: Zip the outer pillow back up.
Step 3: Place both the inner and outer pillow in the washing machine.
Step 4: Wash with warm water and a mild detergent on the gentle cycle. Run the rinse cycle twice. Tumble dry low with dryer balls (or clean tennis balls).

I had a good experience washing and drying the pillow. It’s easy to get the outer cover on and off. When I pulled the inner pillow out of the dryer, I was expecting the filling to feel heavy and lumpy. But it stayed really well distributed and didn’t feel bulky at all.

My Experience

I received two standard pillows in nice packaging that resembles how Casper packages all their sleep products. It came with a card with information and two pillows wrapped in an individual plastic casing.

The first thing I did was wash and dry the pillows. The instructions tell you to separate the outer pillow from the inner pillow. You do this by unzipping three of the outer pillow’s four sides and removing the smaller and firmer inner pillow.

I put everything in the washer on a cool and gentle cycle. When I went to move the pillows to the dryer, I noticed the filling wasn’t clumpy or overly heavy.

I highly recommend following Casper’s instructions with adding tennis balls or dryer balls to a low tumble dry setting. I think this helps the filling stay distributed throughout the pillow during the drying process.

The pillows came out with a crisp and clean feeling thanks to the percale weave in the cotton outer fabric. This matches the feeling of Casper’s sheets.

I am often a side sleeper and found that in this position both the outer and inner pillows were comfortable in terms of feel and firmness. To me, it felt middle-of-the-road in terms of firmness level when it’s fresh out of the dryer.

You do sink into the pillow initially because the filling in the outer layer is minimal compared to the density of the inner pillow. (It has sort of a down-duvet-type feel).

Casper says it makes its pillow for any sleep position. I sleep primarily on my side and on my back, and I can say the pillow was comfortable in both of those positions for the first night.

During the second night of sleep, I woke up with a feeling that the pillow had gotten a little flat. I tried to fluff it up by hand but didn’t have much success. Ideally, you’ll re-fluff it in the dryer on a regular basis.

I received two pillows and gave the second to my husband, who is a stomach sleeper. He shared a similar experience.

This sentiment was echoed by other customers as well. Casper also recommends fluffing your pillow daily. In order for me to enjoy sleeping on it every night, I think I’d have to follow their recommendation.

Casper Pillow Review

Overall

I think Casper’s pillow is creative and provided a very comfortable night’s sleep. It may take consistent fluffing to ensure it’s able to sustain that comfort each night.

I think this pillow could be a good fit for people who enjoy the feeling of crisp cotton sheets, like to sink into their pillows a little bit, and don’t need a lot of support or firmness.

Standard pillows will cost around $55 for a set, which is a pretty good price for what you get. Casper offers a 100-night trial and free returns, so if it ends up not being a great fit, you can return it.

The following two tabs change content below.
Gravatar for Katie Golde

Katie Golde

Katie manages the day to day operations of the Mattress Clarity news site and reviews sleep products in addition to writing and editing sleep news.She hails from Austin, where she lives with her growing family. She is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and has a master’s degree in Journalism from Northwestern University and has a background in health and science content. Her work can be found in print and online publications like Discover Magazine, USA Today and The Huffington Post.
Gravatar for Katie Golde

Latest posts by Katie Golde (see all)

Leave a Comment