Casper Pillow Review

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

Casper is known for their innovative sleep products, and their pillow is no exception. With two plush layers, the Casper pillow feels both soft and supportive.

Still on the fence about it? Our Casper pillow review will help you determine whether it’s the right purchase for you.

Save 10%
Casper Original Pillow
Casper Original Pillow
Casper Original Pillow

The brand's most popular offers a "pillow-in-a-pillow" design that with a crisp cotton cover and down alternative feel. Click the button below to save 10% on a Casper pillow. 

Casper Pillow Overview

Most people know Casper as a bed-in-a-box company, but they don’t just sell mattresses. In fact, the company makes a wide variety of bedding accessories! The Casper foam pillow has a slow-moving and supportive feel, and the Casper down pillow feels soft and malleable.

If you want something that feels both fluffy and supportive, the Casper Original pillow may work best. With a unique pillow-inside-a-pillow design, this product suits a wide range of people. To make things even better, the pillow is available in a low and medium loft.

Who Might Like The Casper Pillow

  • Back sleepers
  • People who prefer a down alternative pillow
  • Those who are on a budget

Who Might Not Like The Casper Pillow

  • Larger side sleepers
  • Those who prefer a slow-moving memory foam pillow
  • People who prefer firm pillows

Casper Pillow Video Review

To really understand how this pillow works, you’ll need to see it in action. Check out our video review below to learn more.

 

Casper Pillow Firmness and Feel

When reviewing pillows, we always focus on firmness and feel. Why? Well, these elements significantly impact how comfortable it will feel. Of course, pillows aren’t one-size-fits-all. Let’s see whether it will work for you.

How Firm Is The Casper Pillow?

The Casper pillow has a soft outer layer and a firm inner pillow. Combined, the pillow feels medium firm. If you’re looking for something with a great balance, this product will deliver.

Sleeping On The Casper Pillow

The key to finding a comfortable pillow is ensuring that it promotes a neutral alignment. If you’re a side sleeper, you’ll want your ears to align with your shoulders. Back and stomach sleepers will want to keep their chins in line with their sternums.

What Does The Casper Pillow Feel Like?

The Casper pillow feels a lot like down, but it’s much more supportive. When you rest your head on it, you’ll gently sink through the outer layer. Thanks to its supportive inner pillow, your head won’t completely bottom out. To keep it feeling soft and pliable, fluff it regularly.

Average Weight Sleepers – 130 lbs – 230lbs

Average weight back sleepers will feel the most comfortable on the mid loft pillow. In this sleep position, the head will get a good balance of comfort and support. The Casper mid loft pillow will work decently well for average weight side sleepers, but some people may feel their head sink too far into the pillow. This may crane the neck out of alignment, which could lead to pain.

Casper Original Pillow - Side Sleeping

Average weight stomach sleepers will need a pillow that is almost completely flat. If this is your preferred sleep position, opt for the low loft pillow.

Heavyweight Sleepers – Over 230lbs

If you’re a heavier back sleeper, you’ll feel quite comfortable on the Casper mid loft pillow. However, this pillow probably won’t feel as supportive while side sleeping. Larger people may sink deeper into the layers, so they’ll need something that feels more supportive. If you fall in this category, consider getting the Casper foam pillow.

Heavier stomach sleepers will want to get the low loft pillow. The soft down alternative feel will help you maintain a neutral alignment.

Lightweight Sleepers – Under 130lbs

For lightweight sleepers, the low loft pillow should work well in all sleeping positions.

RELATED: Best Pillows

Casper Pillow Construction

Now, let’s see how Casper’s unique pillow design all comes together. Here’s a close look at its construction.

Cover

The 100% cotton cover feels soft and comfy. It has a percale weave, which keeps the pillow feeling cool and breathable. The interior filling, made of polyester microfiber, makes the pillow feel like it’s stuffed with feathers.

Core

When you unzip the cover, you’ll find the inner pillow. This feels a bit firmer than the outer cover. Inside, you’ll find more of the polyester microfiber filling. Best of all, it’s clump-resistant for easy fluffing!

Casper Original Pillow - construction

Weight

The pillow weighs 3.5lbs.

Height/Loft

The Casper pillow is available in two lofts. The low loft pillow is 1.25″ tall, and the mid loft is 2″ tall.

Casper Pillow Size Options and Price

Curious about pricing and size options? Our handy chart lays it all out for you.

Size Low Loft Dimensions Mid Loft Dimensions Price
Standard Size 18″ x 26″ x 1.25″ 18″ x 26″ x 2″ $65
King Size 18″ x 34″ x 1.25″ 18″ x 34″ x 2″ $85
Save 10%
Casper Original Pillow
Casper Original Pillow
Casper Original Pillow

The brand's most popular offers a "pillow-in-a-pillow" design that with a crisp cotton cover and down alternative feel. Click the button below to save 10% on a Casper pillow. 

If you want to add an extra layer of plushness to your bed, check out our Casper mattress topper review.

Casper Pillow Performance

Now, for the tiny details. Let’s investigate Casper’s cooling features, off-gassing period, and care instructions.

Sleeping Hot or Cold

Memory foam pillows often trap heat, but because this pillow has microfiber fill, sleepers should feel cool all night long. To create even more airflow, Casper made their cover out of thin and breathable cotton.

Need more ideas? Check out our list of the best cooling pillows.

Off-Gassing

When you unbox a Casper mattress, you’ll notice a slight chemical smell at first. We call this phenomenon “off-gassing”, and it’s completely natural. However, because the Casper pillow doesn’t contain memory foam, off-gassing won’t be an issue. You can rest on this pillow right away.

Care Instructions

To keep things easy, Casper made their pillow machine washable. Just place the inner and outer pillow in the washing machine on the gentle cycle with mild detergent and cool water. Run the rinse cycle twice, and tumble dry low with dryer balls or clean tennis balls.

Allergies

The Casper Original pillow feels a lot like down, but it won’t trap dust mites and allergens like feathers often do. If you suffer from allergies, this could be a great pick.

Company Policies

It’s always wise to skim the company’s policies before purchasing a new pillow or mattress. We’ve highlighted the main points below.

Warranty Info

Casper offers a 1-year limited warranty.

Sleep Trial

The Casper Original pillow comes with a 30-night trial period.

Return Policy

If you aren’t happy with your pillow during the trial period, you can return it for a full refund.

Common Casper Pillow Complaints

Most customers love the Casper pillow, but we have come across a few negative reviews on Amazon. Some people didn’t think the pillow was supportive enough. Because it resembles down, you will sink through it a bit. This makes it great for most back and stomach sleepers, but larger side sleepers may feel it’s not a great fit.

How Does The Casper Pillow Compare To Other Pillows?

Now that we have a full grasp of the Original Casper pillow, let’s take the time to look at some of its competitors.

Casper Original Vs. Casper Foam

Both pillows are available in a low and medium loft, but they have many differences. The Casper foam pillow has a slow moving feel, which creates wonderful cushioning and pressure relief. Around the outside, you’ll find Casper’s proprietary AirScape foam. This material has tiny holes in it, which promotes breathability and helps sleepers stay cool. For these reasons, we named it one of the best memory foam pillows.

Casper foam pillow construction

The Casper Original is a great pillow if you’re looking for something made with down alternative. It feels light and airy, so it’s fantastic for back and stomach sleepers. It may not offer enough neck support for side sleepers, however.

The Casper foam pillow costs a bit more than the Casper Original, but they should both last a long time.

Who Should Get The Original Casper Pillow

  • Those who like down alternative pillows
  • Back and stomach sleepers

Who Should Get The Casper Foam Pillow

  • People who prefer a slow-moving memory foam feel
  • Those who want to save some money

Read our full Casper Foam pillow review.

Casper Pillow Vs. Purple Harmony Pillow

Both pillows have unique constructions, but they will work better for different people. The Purple Harmony pillow features the company’s squishy hex grid in the cover. Beneath that, you’ll find a solid piece of Talalay latex foam. This makes the pillow feel especially breathable and supportive. Because this pillow is so dense, it will work well for heavy people.

Purple Harmony pillow construction

The Casper Original pillow feels cloud-like, but it requires frequent fluffing. Because it isn’t as supportive as the Purple Harmony, it’s a better fit for smaller back and stomach sleepers.

The Purple Harmony pillow costs a little bit more than the Casper, but the Purple should last much longer.

Who Should Get The Casper Pillow

  • People who like down feather pillows
  • Lightweight people

Who Should Get The Purple Harmony Pillow

  • Heavier people
  • Those who like a more supportive pillow

Read our full Purple Harmony pillow review.

Our Casper Pillow Ratings

It’s the moment you’ve been waiting for! Take a look at our final tallies below.

Original Casper Pillow
3.5 Overall
Support
Cooling
Durability
Warranty
Sleep Trial Period

FAQs

Before wrapping up, we’ll answer some of the most frequently asked questions about the Casper pillow.

Is the Casper Pillow worth it?

Our answer: yes! With this product, you get two pillows in one. It feels soft like down feathers, but it’s much more supportive than others you’ll find on the market. It works especially well for lightweight back and stomach sleepers.

What is the difference between the Original Casper and Casper Down pillows?

Both pillows are made with high-quality materials and have a soft and fluffy texture. The Casper Down pillow, however, is made with ethically-sourced down feathers.

Which pillow is better: Casper or Purple?

Both pillows help people get a good night’s sleep, but they’re not one-size-fits-all. The Casper Original pillow is best for lightweight back and side sleepers. The Purple Harmony pillow works well for heavier people.

Gravatar for Katie Golde

Katie Golde

Katie manages the day to day operations of the Mattress Clarity news site and reviews sleep products in addition to writing and editing sleep news. She hails from Austin, where she lives with her growing family. She is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and has a master’s degree in Journalism from Northwestern University and has a background in health and science content. Her work can be found in print and online publications like Discover Magazine, USA Today and The Huffington Post.