Saatva vs WinkBeds

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site. See our disclosure page for details.

I’ve been getting a lot of questions about how Saatva compares to WinkBeds, so I thought I’d put this comparison together since I’ve spent a good amount of time on them both (start with my Saatva review and WinkBeds review).

Saatva has been around longer, has more reviews, and is the larger and more established business. WinkBeds is the  relative newcomer attracting a lot of interest. So which should you buy?  The differences are subtle, but I’ll try to go through everything you should think about in order to help you make a more informed decision.

Overall Construction
With an innerspring mattress there are several key aspects of construction to consider:

  • Coil count.
  • Thickness of cushioning on the top layer.
  • Types of coils used (pocketed vs. bonnell)

Click Here To Get The Highest Available Discount On Winkbeds

Here is a quick sketch that roughly illustrates each bed’s overall construction:

Saatva vs WinkBeds

Top Layer of Foam

WinkBedsSaatva
2" top layer. 1" of hypersoft foam and 1" of cooling gel foam, each of 1.5 lb density.1" top layer .625" soft foam and .375" visco memory foam. 1.2 - 2 lb density.

Both mattresses feature a high quality euro-top style sleep surface. You can see that WinkBeds has more foam on top, but in terms of the feel, I found them to be pretty similar. Saatva is a little softer because of the visco foam, while WinkBeds is more responsive with its hypersoft/gel foam blend. If you like the sink-in of memory foam, Saatva has more of that type of feel on its top layer. If you want the foam to respond right away when you move around (i.e. no body impressions), WinkBeds is more like that.

Individually Wrapped Coils

WinkBedsSaatva
2.4" layer of individually wrapped micro AirSprings (1722/King).4" layer of individually wrapped coils (1088/King)

Both mattresses use individually wrapped coils in the top layer. This is an advanced feature as each coil can contour on its own to the shape of your body, and is definitely the preferred type of coil. WinkBeds has the higher coil count at about 600 more coils per king mattress. Theoretically, more coils should mean more individual contouring to your body shape. In practice though, it’s hard to tell how much of a difference the added coils really make. I found the difference in feel to be subtle.

Saatva vs WinkBeds Review

Mattress Support Core

WinkBedsSaatva
1054/King individually wrapped 8" high profile pocket coils. High gauge wire of 17. Support core is encased along the edges by a 4.5" layer of foam and along the top using a 0.5" layer of pre-compressed densified cotton.520/King 7" Bonnell Coil Innerspring with 13 gauge wire and foam encasement. Steel edge guards and 1/2" Loft Pad + 7/8" Fiber Pad Bottom.

The support cores between the two mattresses is where we start to see some differentiation. Saatva uses heavy duty Bonnell coils, while WinkBeds uses the taller and thinner high profile pocket coils. Because of the way the coils are constructed, WinkBeds is able to fit about twice as many coils in the support core. I’m not sure that more coils equals more support, but it is worth noting the difference. During my testing, I found both mattresses to be extremely supportive. Also, because of the spring coil interiors, these two mattresses have a very healthy bounce.

For edge support, Saatva uses steel edge guards while WinkBeds uses a high density foam. Saatva’s edge guards are definitely firmer than WinkBeds, which comes in handy if you are sitting on the side of your mattress. On the other hand, WinkBeds’ foam edge guards allow for use with an adjustable frame while Saatva’s edge guards do not.

Durability Factors

WinkBedsSaatva
1054/King individually wrapped 8" high profile pocket coils. High gauge wire of 17. Support core is encased along the edges by a 4.5" layer of foam and along the top using a 0.5" layer of pre-compressed densified cotton.520/King 7" Bonnell Coil Innerspring with 13 gauge wire and foam encasement. Steel edge guards and 1/2" Loft Pad + 7/8" Fiber Pad Bottom.

Saatva has been around a bit longer and has strong reviews when it comes to durability, so it’s a pretty safe bet. Since WinkBeds is still relatively new, you can’t tell for sure how well the mattress will hold up until it has been used by consumers for a few years – though I do like that they had their mattress thoroughly tested for durability.

Price
WinkBeds comes in at $1100 for a queen (including shipping) while Saatva comes in at $900 (not including shipping). Thus Saatva wins on price, though note in the specs section WinkBeds can probably justify the higher cost.  Both mattresses are priced well below similar mattresses sold through traditional retailers (most similar would be the Simmons Beautyrest line). Saatva also offers some additional add-on options that might increase price (and convenience) such as frame, foundation, and mattress removal options.

Firmness Preference
One difference to note is firmness preference. Saatva has three options, Plush Soft, Luxury Firm (medium), and Firm. WinkBeds only has one firmness option, which would be most comparable to Saatva’s Luxury Firm. The “medium” option fits 90% of sleepers in my experience, but if you happen to strongly prefer a soft or firm sleeping surface, you will need to go with Saatva.

Final Recommendation

I have recommended both of these mattresses to people with great success. Saatva has been around a little bit longer and has the lower price, while WinkBeds has the slight edge on some of the technical components. If you know you want an innerspring mattress, both are great choices and a far better choice than the over priced in-store brands!

The following two tabs change content below.

Joe Auer

Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site. He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 100 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 4 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications. When he isn't testing sleep products, he enjoys working out, reading both fiction and non-fiction, and playing classical piano. He enjoys traveling as well, and not just to test out hotel mattresses! Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.

32 thoughts on “Saatva vs WinkBeds

  1. My wife and I are considering these two mattresses. Does either have an advantage with motion isolation? Also, we’ve tried the Beautyrest Black in stores and liked it (firm) but don’t like the price. Which of these is most similar to that? Thanks!

  2. I know this is redundant. Im 6’3″ – 265 lbs 66yrs old, fit with restless leg syndrome, horrible insomnia and use a cpap machine. Our current Stearns and Foster mattress has completely disintegrated on the edges as Im a back sleeper who sleeps in one position towards the outside of the bed. Which mattress would work best to keep the edges from collapsing.

  3. What about the third party testing of the Winkbeds, Does that provide strong indication that the Winkbeds is very durable and will not sag much? I am a side sleeper and weigh around 170 lbs. I previously had purchased top of the line Simmons Beautyrest king mattress sold at Sleepy’s approximately 4 years ago. The mattress started sagging within the first 6 months and after 2 years had to get rid of it. Also, how does the 15-year Saatva and 10-year Winkbeds warranties compare. I can not find anything on the Winkbeds warranty other than it’s10 years.

    • I just look at the specs, rather than any third party testing. I think the Saatva will last longer. You can take a look at the Sapira as well. That will be extra durable.

  4. My problem with inner spring mattresses is the eventual sagging that occurs. The mattresses feel great when new, but how long does that last before they start sagging and become a pain in the back. Any opinion on Saatva vs Winkbeds regarding potential for sagging?

  5. I am considering buying the Winkbed. I am thinking that I should choice the new softer version instead of the medium version. My husband and I are both side sleepers. i have hip pain from our current old mattress. My husband has mid and lower back issues because of his spinal discs. We had considered the Simmons BRB Alcove or the Kingsdown Passion Rome at Sleep Experts. Do you know which of the versions of Winkbeds would be closest to those beds? Thank you.

  6. Every review is so non-committal , I’m looking for your opinion on which mattress has the edge over the other…..A little bit about myself , I’m a back sleeper, I have apnea and use a CPAP, I’m 250+ 5’6″ and fractured L1 and L2 vertebraes a few years back, after that I purchased a Sealy Ultra Plush pillow top, Its now on its last legs and I realize I need something that’s firmer but I would still like some plushness…..Winkbed or Saatva?…

  7. Which is the best mattress for back sleepers? I weight roughly 270 and also suffer from sleep apnea….Price isn’t an issue so if you have any other recommendations other then these 2 that would be great!

  8. Joe,
    My girlfriend and I have narrowed are options down to either the Saatva or Winkbed. We like a medium mattress probably a 5.5 – 6 out of 10. I am 5’11 180 male typically back and side sleeper, my girlfriend is 5’5 110 and is a side sleeper she typically likes a little softer mattress. What is the difference in feel between Saatva Medium and Winkbed. Also where does the Alexander Hybrid fall in between these? I understand it is a great Hybrid mattress as well any thoughts?

    • Hi Taylor – WinkBeds and Saatva are much more similar than feel to each other than the Alexander Hybrid. The Alexander Hybrid feels more like a foam mattress, while the other two feel more like a spring mattress.

      As for WinkBeds vs Saatva, I’m not sure I can provide any more info on the feel difference than I described in the post…they are similar in terms of feel, so a bit hard to describe!

  9. I would love to read a comparison between Winkbeds and the new Sapira. I’m trying to decide between them, mostly judging on the height right now depending on the style of platform bed I go with, but I’d love to learn more about the other differences in feel, heat retention, firmness etc. Thanks!

    • Thanks Meghan! I’ll put it on the to-do list. For a brief summary:

      Sapira feels more similar to a foam mattress/WinkBeds feels more similar to an innerspring mattress
      I would say both sleep about the same level of cool, I had no issue with either
      Sapira felt slightly firmer than Winkbeds to me (though both are within the average firmness spectrum)

    • Hi Stephane – both great options, generally I say go for WinkBeds if you’re of a side sleeper because it has some extra foam on top, but plenty of side sleepers love Saatva as well!

  10. I am a 225lb guy, 120lb girlfriend. We are both side sleepers. We tried a few innerspring mattresses/hybrid/foam/latex at a local store. Neither of us liked the foam. With the exception of one latex mattress that seemed to feel OK (only 2 min test), we are fairly sold on innerspring. Based on reviews, the Saatva wins. However, I feel like it’s the “goto” choice. I’m leaning towards the Winkbeds due to the durability and materials used.

    My question is do you see or hear of anymore good/bad reviews of the Winkbeds since they’ve been around a while? Just trying to see if anyone mentioned sag or anything else around durability after owning one for a while.

    Thank you in advance.

    • I would go with the Winkbed. I own them both and the Winkbed is hands down the more comfortable bed. I’m also a Side Sleeper. I have a Winkbed and a 11.5″ Saatva Luxury Firm. They are supposed to be similar but the Winkbed is very much the more comfortable bed.

    • I have the winkbed luxury firm..I hate it,,husband says its fine for him.. Im a side sleeper, it takes me forever to fall asleep, and I wake up constantly through the night with leg pain and hip pain. I’ve only had it 3 nights and I cannot wait for the 30-day trial to be over

  11. I am about to buy a br black, Sonya, or brb hybrid Wellington I think is the name. My wife and I are on the heavier side , and both of us have osteo arthritis in our hips and back. Both of these mattresses have the ability to let us sink in for pressure point relief on hips, back and shoulders, while keeping us supported and spine straight. We are both hot sleepers and the tempurpedic cloud was too hot. We have had 5 beds in 6 years trying to get the painful hip situation under control without burning up. We have an adjustable base currently on our super uncomfortable sleep number, which I now call sleep dumber bed. We have spent tens of thousands on mattresses and would like to stop the madness. My question is when considering the first two mattresses from brb line, would the winks bed be a cost saving alternative that would still accomplish the same level of comfort we believe the brb would give us? We are both mainly side sleepers.

    • Hi Zach – WinkBeds is definitely targeting the mid-range Beautyrest Black in their work. Personally I think WinkBeds is almost as good (95% as comfortable) but obviously a fraction of the price.

    • I disagree that the differences between these beds are subtle. I tried both and ended up with the Winkbed. My first impression was that the Winkbed feels like a much more substantial, higher quality bed. Where the Saatva collapses when you sit on the edge, the Winkbed doesn’t budge. Also, motion transfer is far more pronounced in the Saatva. I’m conscious of my partner moving around in the Saatva. In the Winkbed I feel nothing when my partner moves around. The Saatva has a more ‘springy’, jiggly feel to it as well. the Winkbed more solid feeling. But rather than the Saatva feeling softer than the Winkbed, to me it just feels like the springs in the Saatva are more flexible. Also, after a couple weeks in the Saatva, the impression of my 170 lb body could be seen in the mattress after I got out of it. The Winkbed comes off as feeling like a much higher end bed than the Saatva.

Leave a Comment