Pillow Reviews: Brooklyn Bedding #BestPillowEver vs. Leesa

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

With foam fillings and knitted covers, Brooklyn Bedding’s #BestPillowEver and the Leesa pillow appear to be very similar. But wait a moment – there’s actually a lot that set these pillows apart and makes them stand out in their own way. So, what should you know? Read on for our full comparison.

Key Similarities

  • Solid pieces of molded and ventilated foam
  • Products of mattress companies (Brooklyn Bedding and Leesa)
  • Made in the USA
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Trial periods available
  • Soft knitted and removable covers (that can be laundered)
  • Multiple sizes available

Key Differences


  • Dimensions (Queen Plush): 16″x 29″ x 7″
  • Cover: 60% Polyester, 40% Charcoal Bamboo Blend
  • Filling: Single piece of ventilated Talalay latex foam
  • Firm and Plush options (I am reviewing the Plush)
  • Anti-microbial
  • Weight: 3.5 – 6 lb (depending on size and firmness)
  • Certifications: 2017 Oeko-Tex Certified Latex & 2017 Certi-Pur Certified Poly Foam
  • 3-year warranty
  • 30-night trial
  • Queen and King sizes available
  • Price: $59.99 (Queen) and $79.99 (King)

Click here for the #BestPillowEver review, here.


  • Standard size: 18” x 26” x 5”
  • Filling: solid piece of 100% Avena foam (ventilated)
  • Cover: 70% Polyester, 17% Viscose, 13% Nylon
  • Comes in King and Standard size
  • Designed for all styles of sleeper and all body types
  • Price: $75 for Standard size, $95 for King size
  • Included in Leesa’s One-Ten Program, one pillow will be donated for every ten sold
  • 100-night trial

Check out the complete Leesa pillow review. 

You Might Choose…

#BestPillowEver If…

  • You want firmness options. The pillow comes with two comfort options: Plush and Firm. Back sleepers will most likely benefit from the Plush version, while side sleepers will probably find the Firm a more comfortable option. Stomach sleepers may struggle with the 7″ height profile and supportive foam feel.
  • You want to spend the least amount of money possible. A Queen size #BestPillowEver retails for $59.99 while the Standard size Leesa pillow is $75. This makes the Queen #BestPillowEver the least expensive option.

Leesa If…

  • You like a charitable aspect to shopping. The pillow is part of Leesa’s One-Ten Program, which means one pillow will be donated for every ten pillows sold.
  • You are a side sleeper. The Leesa pillow is 5″ in height and offers a decent firmness and support. While everyone’s weight and height vary, this should be a good pillow for most side sleepers to get comfortable with.

Either If…

  • You like the bouncier feel of latex foamThe #BestPillowEver is made with blended Talalay latex foam and Leesa’s pillow is filled with Avena foam – a performance fabric that has latex characteristics (it’s considered a latex alternative). Both pillows have latex-like qualities, including a bouncy feel and quick response time.
  • You like covers that are easy to clean. The soft knitted covers on both of these pillows are easily removable with a zipper on the side of the pillow. You can launder them both as well as needed.

Related: Best Pillows for Back Sleepers


There are many reasons to love both of these pillows. If you want comfort level options, the #BestPillowEver may be the best fit for you and people who love the Avena foam layer on Leesa’s mattress may enjoy it in a pillow as well.

Luckily both pillows come with trial periods that help mitigate the risk of finding the right pillow.

The following two tabs change content below.
Gravatar for Katie Golde

Katie Golde

Katie manages the day to day operations of the Mattress Clarity news site and reviews sleep products in addition to writing and editing sleep news.She hails from Austin, where she lives with her growing family. She is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and has a master’s degree in Journalism from Northwestern University and has a background in health and science content. Her work can be found in print and online publications like Discover Magazine, USA Today and The Huffington Post.