Brooklinen Mid-Plush Down Pillow Review

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs. See our disclosure page for more information.

Brooklinen’s Mid-Plush Down pillow stands alone from the typical down pillow design, it still provides all the cozy comfort of a down-filled pillow but with enough support and loft so the pillow doesn’t fall entirely flat overnight.

The Mid-Plush version is the most popular and also the most versatile within the available support levels. So what else is there know about it and is it worth the price? Watch my in-depth pillow review or read on for my complete written review.

Brooklinen Deals
Brooklinen Down Pillow
Brooklinen Down Pillow
Brooklinen Down Pillow

The Brooklinen Down Pillow features inner and outer chambers to make sure you get the perfect amount of comfort and support. Click the button for the best deal on the Brooklinen

Brooklinen Mid-Plush Down Pillow: Key Features

  • Firm feather core chamber with soft down surround
  • 400 thread count 100% cotton shell
  • Oeko-tex® certified to be free of harmful chemicals
  • Hypoallergenic with anti-microbial treatment
  • Made in Canada
  • 60-night trial
  • Comes in Standard (20″ × 26″) and King sizes (20″ × 36″)
  • Care (from Brooklinen): We recommend washing our pillows as seldom as possible so as to not disturb the texture and fluffiness of the down fibers. If a product is stained, we recommend spot washing it with Woolite or Oxyclean around the stained area. Should a pillow need to be washed, we recommend washing on a low and gentle cycle and tumble dry on low.
  • Price: $69 for Standard and $89 for King
  • Canada Goose Down Certified
  • Comes in:
    • Plush
    • Mid-Plush (This review)
    • Firm

Firmness Options

I reviewed the Mid-Plush pillow but spoke to a customer service representative about each option: Firm, Mid-Plush, and Plush and who they may be a good fit for. Here is how she described each:

  • Firm: The Firm Pillow has an 86/14 ratio of feathers to down-blend so it balances out firmness with fluffiness for great support through the night. We recommend our Firm Pillows for back sleepers.
  • Mid-Plush: Our Mid-Plush has a dual-core construction, meaning that it is a firm feather pillow inside of a plush pillow. It has a great balance of support and plushness, offering a “best of both worlds” with a firm and plush pillow in one – we recommend the Mid-Plush for side sleepers.
  • Plush: Our Plush Pillow is 100% Down fill and is super soft and plushy. We recommend it for stomach sleepers.

Who Makes the Brooklinen Mid-Plush Down Pillow?

Brooklinen is an online bedding company that focuses on making simple products and are transparent about their manufacturing processes.

In addition to pillows, they also sell comforters, sheets, blankets, and candles – check out our review of their Classic Hardcore Sheet Bundle.

Pillow Construction

The Mid-Plush down pillow comes in Standard (20″ × 26″) and King sizes (20″ × 36″) – I’m reviewing the Standard size.

Brooklinen reports that the Mid-Plush pillow is the most versatile and their best-seller among three options. The pillow features a “dual-core construction,” which essentially means the core is a firm feather pillow built inside a plush down pillow. This is intended to balance out support and softness.

Brooklinen Mid-Plush Down Pillow

The manufacturer tag says that – in total – the pillow is made up of 85% waterfowl feathers in the inner chamber and 15% down in the outer chamber. This gives the pillow a firmer feel than most down pillows, which tend to fall on the plush side.


  • Soft and cozy down feel
  • Doesn’t fall flat as much as a typical down pillow
  • Best fit for some side sleepers and those who sleep in multiple positions
  • Risk-free trial
  • Hypoallergenic and anti-microbial (according to Brooklinen)


  • Pricier – but comparable to other higher-end down pillows
  • May not be a good fit for stomach or back sleepers
  • May need to be fluffed regularly
  • animal-friendly friendly (uses real feathers and down)

Brooklinen Mid-Plush Down Pillow construction

My Experience with the Brooklinen Mid-Plush Down Pillow

The Brooklinen Mid-Plush down pillow is unique with its pillow-in-a-pillow construction. It reminded me of the Casper pillow (with a similar design) but the Brooklinen pillow features a center pillow filled with feathers surrounded by a down pillow. It can’t be opened in the way the Casper pillow can, but it does a good job of providing loft and support with this design.

I choose to review the Mid-Plush option (Firm and Plush are also available) because I sleep in multiple positions and thought this would be the most middle-of-the-road option. Luckily for me, the customer service team at Brooklinen confirmed my decision by telling me that the Mid-Plush pillow is the most versatile pillow and recommended mainly for side sleepers but will work for those who sleep in multiple positions as well.

Laying on this down pillow feels different from other down pillows I’ve reviewed because of the firmer feather pillow in the center. This inner pillow stops the head from going all the way through and really stops it from going completely flat after a few nights of use.

Sleepers still get all the benefits of the cozy down pillow feel from the surrounding pillow. To me, this pillow has a good amount of loft and was almost too thick for me when I slept on my side.

Individuals can see from the photo that my neck is tilted upwards just slightly – which means my head, neck, and spine are not in neutral alignment (which is the ultimate goal). With time, the pillow does flatten a little bit and then it’s a better loft/height for me.

Larger framed individuals or those with broader shoulders might prefer this pillow.

Brooklinen Mid-Plush Down Pillow side sleeper

Brooklinen suggests seldom washing the pillow – but that it is technically machine washable and dryer friendly. I decided to test it out and the pillow came out of the low gentle tumble dry in good shape. The loft and support were maintained but it did have a strange smell (comparable to a burned feather). So I would highly recommend not washing it unless one absolutely has to!


Brooklinen’s Mid-Plush Down pillow is a nice option for those who love the feel of down but want more than the typical amount of loft and support. Based on my experience, I think it’s best for side sleepers or those who want a good amount of thickness – perhaps individuals with larger body frames or broader shoulders.

Additionally, Brooklinen says their pillow is hypoallergenic, which is great news for those with down allergies dying to try a down pillow. It also has a 60-night trial so sleepers can decide which firmness option is the best fit.

Gravatar for Katie Golde

Katie Golde

Katie manages the day to day operations of the Mattress Clarity news site and reviews sleep products in addition to writing and editing sleep news. She hails from Austin, where she lives with her growing family. She is a Certified Sleep Science Coach and has a master’s degree in Journalism from Northwestern University and has a background in health and science content. Her work can be found in print and online publications like Discover Magazine, USA Today and The Huffington Post.