Tuft And Needle Vs Nectar Mattress- Which Should You Choose?

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site (at no cost to the buyer). See our disclosure page for our list of comped products and affiliate programs.

If you are looking to buy a mattress online yet don’t want to break the bank, you might have come across Nectar and Tuft and Needle.  These are two great value mattresses that can be a great choice for a lot of sleepers.  While there are some similarities between the two mattresses, there are also some key differences.  I’l go over those differences in this article to help you make an informed decision.

Key Similarities

  • Both have a similar business model / value proposition
  • Both are all foam mattresses
  • Both use poly foam in the base layer
  • Both have good cooling properties

Click Here To Get The Best Available Deal On Tuft & Needle

Key Differences

  • Tuft and Needle is made in the USA, while Nectar is made in China
  • T&N uses a specialty poly foam in the comfort layer, while Nectar uses memory foam
  • T&N is more responsive / uses faster-responding foam, while Nectar’s foam is more slow-moving
  • In our opinion, the T&N is slightly firmer than the Nectar
  • Nectar has a more sinking into the mattress feel than Tuft & Needle does
  • Tuft and Needle has been in business for much longer than Nectar
  • Tuft and Needle sells a Queen for $675 (you can sometimes get $50 off from that), while Nectar sells a Queen for $795 (you can usually get $125 off from that)

Click Here To Get The Best Available Discount On Nectar

Tuft And Needle Construction

You can get a general sense of the layers of the Tuft & Needle from the picture below.  Here’s a breakdown:

  • The top layer is 3 inches of a specialty poly foam the company calls Adaptive foam.  It is high-density (2.8 lbs.) and is infused with graphite and gel to keep the mattress very breathable.  It has good bounce to it and good pressure relief.
  • The base layer is a 1.8 lb. density poly foam layer.  This is a pretty standard base layer for bed-in-a-box mattresses.

Read Our Tuft And Needle Mattress Review

Nectar Construction

You can get a general sense of the layers of construction of the Nectar mattress below.  The cover is made from tencel and cotton and is quilted with gel memory foam .  The first layer is one inch of gel memory foam and is faster-responding than most memory foam.  The next layer is 3 inches of more memory foam and then there is a high-density poly foam support layer (slightly higher than the T&N).

Read Our Nectar Mattress Review

Construction Differences/Notes

  • The Nectar is 11 inches thick, while the T&N is 10 inches thick
  • The Nectar comfort layer is thicker than the Tuft and Needle’s
  • The Tuft and Needle is bouncier, providing a more “on” the mattress feel, while the Nectar has slower-moving foams and a more “in” the mattress feel
  • I expect the durability of both mattresses to be about the same
  • I believe the Nectar will have slightly better pressure relief
  • I expect the T&N to have a slight edge in sleeping cool

Related: Best Mattress 2017

Firmness/Feel Differences

It is our opinion that the Tuft and Needle is firmer than the Nectar.  I think most people would agree.  You can see from the videos below that the T&N is bouncier / more resilient.  With Nectar you sink into the mattress a little bit more (potentially better for side sleepers).

Motion Transfer Differences

Both of these mattresses do pretty well with motion transfer.  I would, however, give the slight edge to Nectar because of its use of multiple layers of memory foam.

What Should You Base Your Decision On?

  • Made in USA vs China– The Tuft and Needle is made in the US, while the Nectar is made in China
  • Firmness Difference– Most would agree the T&N is firmer than the Nectar
  • Feel Difference– The T&N is bouncier and has a more “on” the mattress feel, while with Nectar you sink into the mattress more and it has an “in” the mattress feel
  • Company Reputation– With T&N, you get the benefit of many reviews over a long period of time compared to Nectar
  • Shipping– Nectar is currently facing shipping delays

Overall

These are pretty different mattresses.  Therefore you should really think about what qualities you want the most out of your mattress and make a decision from there.

The following two tabs change content below.

Joe Auer

Joe Auer is the editor of Mattress Clarity. He mainly focuses on mattress reviews and oversees the content across the site.He likes things simple and take a straightforward, objective approach to his reviews. Joe has personally tested nearly 100 mattresses and always recommends people do their research before buying a new bed. He has been testing mattresses for over 4 years now, so he knows a thing or two when it comes to mattress selection. He has been cited as an authority in the industry by a number of large publications.When he isn't testing sleep products, he enjoys working out, reading both fiction and non-fiction, and playing classical piano. He enjoys traveling as well, and not just to test out hotel mattresses!Joe has an undergraduate degree from Wake Forest University and an MBA from Columbia University.

10 thoughts on “Tuft And Needle Vs Nectar Mattress- Which Should You Choose?”

  1. Hi. My husband is 200lbs and 5′ 11′ he sleeps on his back and side. I am a side sleeper (sometimes back) with hips that hurt on one side (180lbs, 5’6”). We both like firm for our backs. We are in our late 40’s and are bodies aren’t young. LOL. We are getting a new mattress (King). I have narrowed it down to these two Tuft and Needle and Nectar due to $ we have to spend. Which do you recommend.

  2. I bought a Zinus Green Tea Mattress a few months ago. It’s OK but a little too firm for my liking. Now my research has led to the Nectar and Tuft & Needle mattresses. I have arthritis issues in my lower back and neck and the Zinus has not provided much relief. What do you recommend?

  3. Hi, I have been comparing these 2 mattresses , as well as others, and certifications are another comparison point that you might consider including in the future. Nectar and T&N are both Certi Pure US, but T&N appears to also be Greenguard Gold and Oeko Tex Standard 100 certified as well. The T&N is very appealing from an Eco/Natural perpsective as well, especially at their very modest pricepoint. The only reason I have not pulled the trigger on T&N is the perceived firmness, as i am looking for a mattess more in the medium to medium-soft range.

Leave a Comment