Pillow Reviews: Five Star Down Alternative vs. Casper

We receive free products to review and participate in affiliate programs, where we are compensated for items purchased through links from our site (at no cost to the buyer). See our disclosure page for our list of comped products and affiliate programs.

Both the Five Star Down Alternative and the Casper pillow are down alternatives with 100% cotton covers, which means that when it comes to telling them apart, it’s all in the details. So which one could be the right fit for you? Read on for my full comparison.

Key Similarities

  • Filled with 100% polyester fibers (down-like filling)
  • 100% cotton covers
  • Gussets for extra width
  • Traditional-shaped
  • Machine washable and dryer friendly
  • Hypoallergenic

Key Differences

Five Star Down:

  • 100% cotton cover – called Damask fabric with satin piping
  • 300 thread count
  • 1.5″ gusset
  • Flat and formed – cannot be scrunched up like a down pillow
  • Sizes: Standard, Queen, King, and Euro Size
  • No trial period or warranty options (unless specified by retailer)

Five Star Down Alternative Pillow Review

Check out the full Five Star Down Alternative pillow review, here.

Casper:

  • Pillow in a pillow design
  • Inner pillow filled with coated polyester fibers
  • Inner and Outer Cover Fabric: 100% Supima Cotton
  • 400 thread count
  • 2” gusset
  • Fill is sourced in South Korea and assembled in the USA
  • Standard and King sizes available
  • 10-year warranty and 100-night trial

Casper Pillow Review

Read the complete Casper pillow review, here. 

You Might Choose

Five Star Down If…

  • You are on a budget. Compared to the Casper pillow, the Five Star Down Alternative pillow is significantly less expensive and – on its own- could fit most budgets.
  • You are a stomach sleeper. It does provide slightly more firmness and even distribution than a down pillow (based on my experience). However, I think this pillow is the best fit for stomach sleepers (or even back sleepers) more than side sleepers.

Casper If…

  • You want to see and feel the pillow before buying it. You can now take a look at the Casper pillows in Target stores. This will let you get an idea of what the “pillow in a pillow” concept is all about before purchasing one.
  • You are a back or side sleeper. Because the Casper pillow is essentially two pillows in one and there is a 2” gusset, you get more firmness and loft than the Five Star Down Alternative. This puts it right at a good place for side and back sleepers. Stomach sleepers can, of course, remove one of the pillows and be happy as well.

Top pillows for side sleepers

Either If….

  • You like down but have allergies. Both of these pillows are hypoallergenic and made with 100% polyester fibers. The good news is they also both have that cozy down feel to them.
  • You want easy care. Both pillows are easy to machine wash and dry and may only require occasional fluffing in the dryer to keep it in good shape.

Overall

From their polyester fillings to their gussets and cotton covers, these pillows are extremely similar.

What sets them apart – mostly – is that Casper’s pillow in a pillow design gives it slightly more loft and support. This makes it a better fit for back and side sleepers while the Five Star Down Alternative could be a home run for stomach sleepers.

The following two tabs change content below.

Katie Golde

Katie manages the day to day operations of the Mattress Clarity news site and reviews sleep products in addition to writing and editing sleep news.She hails from Austin, where she lives with her growing family. She has a master’s degree in Journalism from Northwestern University and has a background in health and science content. Her work can be found in print and online publications like Discover Magazine, USA Today and The Huffington Post.

Latest posts by Katie Golde (see all)

Leave a Comment